Ðóñ Eng Cn Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law
Reference:

Troitskaya A.A. Participation of Constitutional Control Bodies in the Process of Changes to the Constitution: Comparative Aspect

Abstract: The article analyzes different methods of amendment of constitutional provisions which correlates to textual amendments and amendments made by the other means (including interpretation of constitutional provisions and adoption of current legislation) and necessity to guarantee the ideas of sovereignty and constitutionalism. The goal of the constitutional control bodies, concerned determination of the limits of legislative amendment, is researched on the basis of judicial practice of constitutional courts and supreme courts of different countries. The comparative method allowed to elicit different ways to solve the problem of constitutional control bodies’ role as subjects of constitutional amendment process is used in the article. The author proves the more significant role of constitutional control bodies, including Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation, in evaluation of justifiableness of amendments to the fundamental law of the state made by the other subjects of the constitutional legal relations and more detailed argumentations in such cases that casual or abstract interpretation of the constitutional control body is resulted in changes of informative components of constitutional provisions.


Keywords:

amendment to the Constitution, constitutionalism, sovereignty, constitutional control, limits of constitutional amendments, immutable provisions, the basic constitutional structure, Constitutional Court, power limits, interpretation.


This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article

This article written in Russian. You can find original text of the article here .
References
1. Opredelenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda RF ot 16 iyulya 2009 ¹ 922-O-O.
2. Certification of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 (4) SALR 744 (CC) // http://www.saflii.org/za/ cases/ZACC/1996/26.html.
3. Edwards v. Canada (Attorney General), [1930] AS 124 // http://www.chrc-ccdp.ca/en/browseSubjects/edwardspc.asp
4. His Holiness Kesavananda Bharati Sripadgalavaru v. The State of Kerala and Others. AIR 1973 SC 1461 // http:// openarchive.in/newcases/29981.htm.
5. Kommers D.P. The constitutional jurisprudence of the Federal Republic of Germany. 2-nd. ed. Durham & London, 1997. P. 55.
6. Murphy W.F. Slaughter-House, Civil Rights, and Limits on Constitutional Change // American Journal of Jurisprudence. Vol.32. No. 1. P. 12.
7. Sartori G. Constitutionalism: a preliminary discussion // American Political Science Review. 1962. Vol. 56. ¹ 4. P. 853–864.
8. Vile J.R. The Case against Implicit Limits on the Constitutional Amending Process // Responding to Imperfection. The Theory and Practice of Constitutional Amendment / Ed. by S. Levinson. Princeton, 1995. P. 198.
9. Avak'yan S.A. Konstitutsiya Rossii: priroda, evolyutsiya, sovremennost'. M., 2000.
10. Avak'yan S.A. Strane nuzhna novaya Konstitutsiya // EZh-Yurist. 2007. ¹ 50. 21 dekabrya.
11. Anichkin E.S. «Preobrazovanie» Konstitutsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii (k voprosu o diskussii vokrug odnoy pravovoy kategorii) // Konstitutsionnoe i munitsipal'noe pravo. 2008. ¹ 22. S. 4.
12. Bogdanova N.A. Konstitutsionnoe pravo. Obshchaya chast'. M., 2005. S. 43.
13. Dvorkin R. O pravakh vser'ez. M., 2004. S. 265.
14. Ellinek G. Obshchee uchenie o gosudarstve. M., 2004. S. 515–516.
15. Kerimov A.D. Problemy konstitutsionnoy reformy i gosudarstvennogo stroitel'stva v Rossii. M., 2003. S. 4–5.
16. Konstitutsiya Rossiyskoy Federatsii: doktrina i praktika / Otv. red. V.D. Zor'kin. M., 2009. S. 12.
17. Medushevskiy A.N. Konstitutsiya Rossiyskoy Federatsii 1993 goda i bol'shie tsikly rossiyskogo konstitutsi-onalizma // Konstitutsionnoe pravo: vostochnoevropeyskoe obozrenie. 2003. ¹ 4. S. 37.
18. Mishin A.A. Konstitutsionnoe (gosudarstvennoe) pravo zarubezhnykh stran. M., 2006. S. 27.
19. Troitskaya A.A. Predely peresmotra konstitutsii: formal'nyy i soderzhatel'nyy aspekty // Vestnik Mo-skovskogo universiteta. Seriya 11. Pravo. 2010. ¹ 1.
20. Khabrieva T.Ya. Reformirovanie Konstitutsii Rossiyskoy Federatsii: vozmozhnost' i neobkhodimost' // Zhur-nal rossiyskogo prava. 2003. ¹ 11.
21. Chirkin V.E. Konstitutsiya RF: k voprosu o probelakh i defektakh // Probely i defekty v konstitutsionnom pra-ve i puti ikh ustraneniya / Pod red. S.A. Avak'yana. M., 2008. S. 59.
22. Shayo A. Samoogranichenie vlasti. Kratkiy kurs konstitutsionalizma. M., 2002. S. 12.
23. Yakobson G.Dzh. Nekonstitutsionnaya konstitutsiya? Sravnitel'nyy obzor // Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie. 2006. ¹ 4. S. 145–161