Ðóñ Eng Cn Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Culture and Art
Reference:

Traditional Buryat cuisine as a component of the ethnocultural identity of the Buryat population of the Trans-Baikal Territory

Erokhina Elena Gennad'evna

ORCID: 0009-0004-3177-2852

Postgraduate student, Department of Socio-Cultural Activities, East Siberian State Institute of Culture

670031, Russia, Republic of Buryatia, Ulan-Ude, Tereshkova str., 1

erohinaelena514@mail.ru

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0625.2024.2.69657

EDN:

VDWHTL

Received:

24-01-2024


Published:

03-03-2024


Abstract: The subject of this article is the traditional cuisine of the Buryat people, the object is the ethnocultural identity of the Buryat population of the Trans–Baikal Territory. The author examines in detail such aspects of the topic as ethnocultural markers of the ethnos, traditions and cooking technologies, observance of the ancestral features of the national cuisine, recipes existing in the territory of the region and its individual parts. The author partially presents the developed theoretical materials concerning the issues of Buryat cuisine and thematic interviewing materials collected as part of expedition trips to the territory of the Aginsky district of the Aginsky Buryat district of the Trans-Baikal Territory, including the technology and recipe for cooking traditional Buryat dishes. The author lists the forms of events (festivals and holidays) that exist in the region, popularizing the traditional cuisine and culture of the Buryat population of the Trans-Baikal Territory. The main method of research was the analysis of thematic literature and materials, interviewing speakers of traditional culture within the framework of expedition trips. As the main conclusions, the author cites expediency, rationality, geographical and climatic features, conditions and place of residence of ethnic communities as main factors of shaping the local cuisine. And today, thanks to scientific and technological progress, ethnic identity, including in traditional cuisine, is gradually decreasing or disappearing completely. Therefore, the issue of fixing and transferring ethnic culture, including traditions, customs, etc., to future generations in order to preserve their ethno-cultural identity, is acute. Many people do not realize how important and existential this can be for some people who live and think through the prism of their ethnicity.


Keywords:

ethnic group, ethnic and cultural identity, traditional cuisine, festival, conservation, popularization, recipe, Buryats, Transbaikalia, holiday

This article is automatically translated. You can find original text of the article here.

  At the present stage of human development, there are many methods and technologies developed by world science for studying a particular nation, its history, customs, traditions, spiritual and social foundations that make up an ethnic group. To preserve one's people, ethnic group, its uniqueness and identity is one of the most important and priority directions in the national policy of the Russian Federation, which is enshrined in the Constitution, as well as in the documents of state strategic planning.

  Ethnocultural markers of any ethnic group include such features as: a single territory of residence, language, religion, culture, traditions, etc. Traditional cuisine, implying a certain process with a wide range of technologies and resources, historically formed from generation to generation, forms those authentic features of national cuisine, which are one of the ethnocultural markers a certain ethnic group. The cooking procedure implies a kind of ritual, and the one who is engaged in cooking is directly part of this cultural ritual, thereby differentiating himself from others and correlating himself as part of the culture of his ethnic group. This fact indicates that a person recognizes his identity. Food traditions are important elements of material culture that link culture and biology. Food traditions and eating habits are supported by all members of the ethnic community, who carry this knowledge beyond their group.

Gastronomy is an important resource of the territory, a source of formation of its identity, and for a person unfamiliar with a particular nation, immersion in traditional cuisine will allow you to get a more complete picture of the culture and way of life of the nation [13].

It is no coincidence that gastronomic tourism is so widespread in the world – a type of tourism, the main purpose of which is to get acquainted with a particular country through the prism of national gastronomy. For the gastronomic tourist, food is primarily a category of culture. From this perspective, traditional cuisine is perceived in connection with history, religion, economics, politics, customs, legends and other factors that form the unique identity of a country or region. A food tour is a tasting of dishes typical of the local cuisine. Culinary geography lessons take place not only in restaurants, but also in markets, farms, kitchens of local residents, during carnival and harvest, at the table and just outside.

The study of the characteristics of the traditional cuisine of the Buryat population in the framework of this study is relevant in connection with globalization, urbanization, mass migrations, the geopolitical situation, etc. As Andreeva L.A., Hopiyainen O.A., Filimonova N.V. note in their research: "the national cuisine of a certain people is not constructed, and therefore has the opportunity to preserve its uniqueness for a long time period, thereby demonstrating the everyday mechanism of ethnic identity formation. In addition, familiarizing others with the culture and traditions of nutrition, obtaining scientific knowledge about the food of a particular ethnic group carries the ideas of tolerance and contributes to the formation of family values, as well as the greatest mutual understanding between nations through close contact with material culture" [2].

The research conducted in the village of Chelutai in the Aginsky municipal district is aimed at collecting materials on the technology and recipe of national cuisine, studying the degree of its preservation, fixation, and the actual materials obtained for further translation and introduction into scientific circulation. The peculiarities of the nutrition system, the content of the food itself, the technology of its extraction and production serve as the main criteria that determine the economic and cultural type of human communities.

The study of theoretical material concerning national cuisine suggests that cuisine directly depends on the lifestyle and type of management of any ethnic group. Considering that earlier the Buryats led a nomadic and pastoral lifestyle, while engaged in cattle breeding, sheep breeding, horse breeding, sometimes fishing and hunting, the traditional Buryat cuisine was formed and functioned around these crafts. The menu consisted mainly of meat and dairy dishes, depending on the time of year.

According to its structure, the Buryat food system was based on "a balance of meat and various dishes from meat, blood, dairy products with the addition of vegetable products, as well as those obtained during hunting and fishing" [3].

Thanks to centuries-old cattle breeding, Buryat cuisine is saturated with a large assortment of dairy products that were consumed at different times of the year, regardless of milk yield. Preparations were made for the winter. Milk was most often consumed in boiled form, using fermentation and evaporation technologies, different types of cheese were prepared, airag, turag – a type of curdled milk, urme foam, among drinks – tarasun milk vodka, dried curd mass – arul and hurut.

In the book "My Twelve Jewels" by the Buryat writer Afrikan Balburov, the following words are recorded: "The Buryats have an ancient custom: first of all, they put something dairy on the guest's table, whether it's sour cream, cream, or just milk. Any treat starts with it. We drink tea only with milk. No wonder they say: "Tea with milk is for a friend!" [6].

In Buryat culture, there is a Zoohei Naadan holiday, the so-called "sour cream evening", the main product of which was sour cream. The celebration for girls and women began with the collection of sour cream.

As each individual farm was combined with others into a single whole, the collected sour cream became the main unifying element of the celebration.

The main treat of the holiday was "salamat" or sour cream porridge. During the preparation of salamat, the Buryats performed ceremonial dances, songs and important rituals. For example, the Chief cook and elder, with a request for abundance and well-being, addresses the Hearth and the surrounding Nature: "Galdaa madulne", i.e. drips salamat oil into the hearth, and sprinkles a few drops on all four sides with the words: "For the common well-being and world peace!" All, enhancing the effectiveness of benevolence, answer them in chorus: "So be it!" [1].

The summer meat diet mainly included mutton, the winter – beef. When cooking meat, rice or millet, noodles were added to the broth. Lamb's head, shoulder blade, and rump were considered an exquisite dish in the Buryat cuisine, as a rule, they were served for honored guests. Horse meat was also eaten. Horse fat and horse blood had a special delicacy, and taking these products, in addition to saturating the body, added a healing effect. Meat was harvested in autumn, cattle were slaughtered, meat was cut and dried. Flour dishes present in the Buryat cuisine include buuza, which is made from unleavened dough with steamed meat filling. Another flour dish is flatbreads made of unleavened dough fried in mutton fat. Among the drinks there was tea, milk, salt and lard were added to it, they drank from wooden cups [7].

This information is confirmed by research materials obtained in the same Buryat village of Chelutai, where the object "Traditional cuisine of the Buryat Aginsky district of the Trans-Baikal Territory" was recorded from informants, which included the dish "Buuza". It is widespread among the Buryat population of Transbaikalia. It is prepared from beef, lamb, pork with the addition of wild steppe onions and steamed. The technology of cooking the filling consists in chopping or slicing meat. The dough is made from water and flour, with the addition of salt. There is also a certain technology of modeling, in thirty-three pinches, which corresponds to the number of folds on the lamas' clothes. "Buuza" is shaped like a traditional Buryat dwelling – a yurt. This dish is popular to this day, in Transbaikalia and is widespread everywhere among other peoples.

At first, buuzas were mainly prepared by lamas in datsans. In Barguzin, for example, they did not know buuz as an ordinary meal, the old people said: "Dasanei buuza". That is, buuz were considered exclusively Datsan food. Tsyben Zhamsarano also mentions the Datsan roots: "In the Transbaikalian Buryats, qatar is developed among the Datsan lamas who have reached a respectable position of gebshi, especially among those who, contrary to medical prescriptions, like too juicy food – buuza. Such venerable persons usually travel to Badgar and Tibet, few recover" [10].

Another dish, "Borso" (dried meat), is also widely used in the cuisine of the Buryats to this day. Given the nomadic lifestyle, this dish was very convenient for the Buryats, as it was subject to a long shelf life (up to several years). With the ready-made "Borso" it was easy to prepare a rich broth. The meat was dried in the period from November to April, stored in canvas bags. This dish was a nutritious and restorative remedy, so it was prepared by adding it to the broth for women in the first months after childbirth.

Milk and dishes made from it are sacred among the Buryats, revered and often used in ritual actions. Dairy food is most common in the period from April to October, and accompanies a person all his life from the moment of his birth. Milk is used at the meeting of honored guests, as well as as an offering for spirits, during rituals before a long journey, for good luck, to obtain a rich harvest, etc.

The dish "urme-khushoohe" (foam from melted milk) is a popular dish, acts as a dessert and is very much loved by children. It was prepared from fatty cow's milk by long-term boiling over fire. For taste, locust bulbs (L. Pilosiusculum, currently listed in the Red Book) or ground cherry were added. This dish was prepared, as a rule, for holidays such as "Sagaalgan", weddings, etc. Currently, the recipe has undergone changes in terms of flavoring additives (raisins, apples or bananas were put in the dish).

The dish "Aarsa" (fermented milk drink) is a popular dish among the Buryat population, which is recommended to be consumed after eating fatty meat, as a natural enzyme for the digestive system. They were cooked in large quantities, including for the winter, because the warming effect of this product is known. This drink is considered a product of distilling milk vodka. Milk vodka "archi" was distilled from a liquid - "khurege", formed during the preparation of oil. They allowed the "Khurenge" to sour for two days, and then poured it into birch bark tubs for storage. The initial product for the preparation of the above drinks was fresh milk, which was allowed to sour, thereby obtaining a "tarag" from which butter was prepared.

Thus, we can see how environmental, historical and social factors have influenced the food system of Buryats. Cuisine and food traditions were formed on the basis of a nomadic lifestyle and type of farming. The rational use of all products of animal husbandry, sheep breeding, horse breeding, and crop production is based on a well-designed extraction system, methods of cooking and storing food. The organization of a balanced diet is based on an understanding of the medical benefits of foods. All this characterizes the peculiarities of Buryat cuisine, which is one of the important components of the cultural identity of the Buryats. Of course, today, due to the advent of household appliances, the Buryat kitchen has undergone changes in terms of the technology of making dishes, as well as their storage conditions.

At the present stage, we can say that the Buryat cuisine has been partially preserved, its ethnic specificity is retained. I am particularly pleased that in the territory of Chita there is a well-developed network of cafes of Buryat cuisine, which has more than 25 units of cafes and restaurants. It has become popular in public catering organizations with Buryat cuisine to prepare their own local dishes, although it is worth noting that the menu of these organizations does not exclude foreign ethnic borrowing.

It has also become popular to broadcast national cuisine through gastronomic festivals, festivals of national cultures and on various holidays. As an example, the intermunicipal young festival "Agin mutton on the rocks" (festival of Buryat national cuisine "Khorkhogoy Naadan") can be cited. The leading idea of which is the preservation and revival of traditional Buryat cuisine among the population of the Trans-Baikal Territory. Within the framework of this event, it is planned to broadcast dishes of Buryat cuisine, traditions of cooking, butchering meat that exist among the Buryat people.

In conclusion, we note that the traditions and customs of any nation have been formed over many millennia. National cuisine, habits and food culture are also formed historically, which is influenced by many factors, including geographical and climatic features, conditions and place of residence. Today, unfortunately, the ethnic identity of the Buryat and other small peoples of Russia, including in traditional cuisine, is gradually decreasing or disappearing completely. Therefore, the issue of the transit of ethnic culture to the next generations and the preservation of a unique ethno-cultural identity is acute. We hope that studies like ours will help to draw attention to the problem of preserving the ethnocultural identity of peoples, as well as intensify activities in this direction.

References
1. Altaeva, A.E., (2018). The main aspects of the Buryat national holiday... "Sour cream evening": based on the materials of M.P. Danchinova. Izvestiya AltGU. "Historical Sciences and Archaeology", 5(103), 95-99.
2. Andreeva, L.A., Hopiyainen, O.A., & Filimonova, N.V. (2017). National cuisine as a fragment of ethnic identity. Historical and socio-educational thought, 9(6), 121-126. doi:10.17748/2075-9908-2017-9-6/1-121-126
3. Babueva, V.D. (2004). The material and spiritual culture of the Buryats. A study guide. Ulan-Ude.
4. Budaeva, Ts. B., (2003). The revival of ecological traditions of the Buryats. Sociological research, 6(230), 120-123.
5. Sanzhieva, S.V. (2021). Buryat folk holidays. Chita: GUK "Umtskint".
6. Tsydynzhapov, G., & Baduyevà, E. (1984). Buryat cuisine. Ulan-Ude: Buryat. Publishing House.
7. Geniatulin, R.F. (2009). Small Encyclopedia of Transbaikalia: Culture: at 2 o'clock/ch. Novosibirsk: Nauka.
8. Evmenova, L. N., (2018). Traditional food culture of the peoples of Siberia. Bulletin of Slavic cultures, 48, 67-75.
9. Food and culture: collection of art. (2015). Moscow: Center for the study of cultural interaction.
10. Zhamtsarano, Ts. Zh. (1936). Mongolian chronicles of the XVII. L.: Publishing House of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR.
11. Mikhailovà, V. T. (2008). Traditions of Buryat cuisine. Ulan-Ude: Publishing house of GUZ RCMP of the MZ of the RB.
12. Olmoeva, V.D., & Khamnaeva, N.I. (2015). Modern trends in the creation of fermented food products. Monograph. Ulan-Ude.
13. Tatarova, S.P., & Zateeva, N.A., (2020). The national nutrition system as a tourist resource of the cross-border region of Russia and Mongolia. Scientific proceedings of the Free Economic Society of Russia, 2(222), 341-354.
14. Tatarova, S.P., & Zateeva, N.A. (2022). Trends in the national cuisine of the Mongolian peoples of the cross-border region. Theory and practice of social development, 6, 29-36. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.24158/tipor.2022.6.3/

First Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The subject of the research in the article submitted for publication in the journal Culture and Art under the heading "Traditional Buryat cuisine as a component of the ethnocultural identity of the Buryat population of the Trans-Baikal Territory" is a set of components of ethnocultural identity in the traditional cuisine of the Buryat population of the village Chelutai Aginsky municipal district of the Trans-Baikal Territory. Accordingly, as reflected in the title, the traditional cuisine of the Buryats is considered as the object of research. The author justifiably turned to the generalization of the material already accumulated by colleagues in the framework of research on the traditional cuisine of the Buryats and more broadly (within the framework of gastronomic anthropology and ethnology) in order to identify and ethnocultural identification of the most significant features of the cuisine of the Buryat population of the village of Chelutai in the Aginsky municipal district of the Trans-Baikal Territory. Among the essential features of the cuisine, the author highlights: ingredients, cooking technology, calendar periods of preparation of ingredients, preparation and consumption of certain dishes, accompanying calendar holidays, customs and traditional rituals, sacred symbols of individual dishes (in particular, meat and dairy, including some drinks) and their connection with traditional etiquette. Such dishes as "Buuza" (prepared from beef, lamb, pork with the addition of wild steppe onions), "Borso" (dried meat), "urme-khushoohe" (foam from melted milk), "Aarsa" (fermented milk drink) are considered in detail. The author notes that the informants presented only the technology of cooking some dishes that can be prepared at the beginning of the summer period, in connection with which the conducted field research provides partial materials about Buryat cuisine, which, in the context of generalizing theoretical material, are an addition to the volume of empirical material accumulated by researchers. In the final conclusions, the author reasonably summarizes: that the Buryat food system was influenced by environmental, historical and social factors; that the considered dishes of traditional cuisine and food traditions were formed on the basis of a nomadic lifestyle and type of farming; that the rational use of livestock products, sheep breeding, horse breeding, crop production, as well as a competently constructed system of extraction of ingredients, cooking technology and food storage; that on the basis of the transfer of gastronomic experience from generation to generation, a traditional organization of balanced nutrition has developed, built with an understanding of the medical usefulness of products. The noted characteristics allowed the author to attribute them to the peculiarities of Buryat cuisine, which, in his opinion, is one of the important components of the cultural identity of the Buryats. In conclusion, the author notes that the everyday cuisine of the Buryats has undergone changes in terms of the technology of making dishes, has become more automated with the advent of household appliances, storage and cooking conditions have changed, etc., but nevertheless, the popularity of traditional cuisine is growing in the regional catering sector thanks to a complex of socio-cultural projects, including gastronomic festivals of traditional cuisine and the revival of traditional mass celebrations, family ritual traditions. Thus, the subject of the study was considered by the author at a good theoretical level and the article is worthy of publication. The research methodology is based on the generalization of theoretical material, as well as on the description and analysis of empirical material collected during field research. The author applies general theoretical methods of typology, classification, comparison and generalization, complementing them with an ethnological interpretation of the components of the ethnocultural identity of the Buryat population of the Trans-Baikal Territory in the traditional cuisine of the Buryats of the Chelutai village of the Aginsky municipal district. Despite the fact that in the introduction the research program is presented only in terms of substantiating the relevance of the topic, it is clearly visible in the structure of the presentation of the research results. The applied set of techniques is relevant to the results obtained. The author's conclusions are well-founded and expand scientific ideas about the totality of components of ethnocultural identity in the traditional cuisine of the Buryats. The author associates the relevance of the research topic with the risk of devaluation of traditional cuisine under the influence of intercultural integration and globalization of culture, as well as ongoing changes in the traditional way of life of Buryats. Of course, in the context of the inevitable development of society, the fixation and analysis of traditional gastronomic experience, which constitutes a set of components of ethnocultural identity, is an urgent and timely task. The scientific novelty expressed in the introduction of the results of field research and author's generalizations of theoretical material deserves trust. The style is generally scientific, but some common design inaccuracies need to be eliminated: 1) it is necessary to use the same spelling of a long dash in all appropriate cases; 2) since square brackets with reference to sources are part of the sentence, the final dot at the end of the sentence is placed after the brackets, not before them. In addition, the reviewer notes that for the judgment "To preserve one's own people - an ethnic group, its uniqueness and identity is one of the most important and priority areas of activity of all states", the article does not present enough arguments, therefore it is an unjustified generalization: it is more appropriate to mention that it is in Russian politics that the preservation of the people is the most important priority, that It is enshrined both in the Constitution and in documents of state strategic planning (theorists express controversial judgments about other countries, therefore there is no reason to unequivocally assert such a generalization). You should also carefully read the text, there are typos in the words and (for example, "We drink sai only with milk", "... which includes dishes such as "Buuza"" (Buuza dish or a combination, a set of dishes?)). The structure of the article corresponds to the logic of presenting the results of scientific research. The bibliography, taking into account the explication of new empirical material by the author into the theoretical discourse, sufficiently reflects the problematic area of research, although the author did not use the opportunity to include his results in the broader context of international discussions (there has been no foreign scientific literature for the last 3-5 years). The design of the list needs a slight adjustment, taking into account the requirements of the editorial board and GOST. The appeal to the opponents is quite correct and sufficient. The article is certainly of interest to the readership of the magazine "Culture and Art" and after a little revision can be recommended for publication.

Second Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

In the journal Culture and Art, the author presented his article "Traditional Buryat cuisine as a component of the ethnocultural identity of the Buryat population of the Trans-Baikal Territory", in which a culturological and philosophical understanding of the phenomenon of gastronomic culture of a certain people was carried out. The author proceeds in the study of this issue from the fact that the daily life of a person is a multifaceted manifestation, influenced by many factors, among which the worldview, customs, traditions specific to different peoples are more functional. As the author notes, the features of the nutrition system, the content of the food itself, the technology of its extraction and production serve as the main criteria that determine the economic and cultural type of human communities. The relevance of the research is due to the fact that the study of the culture of everyday life, which covers all spheres of human life, is one of the most actively developing areas of modern cultural knowledge and deserves special theoretical study. Familiarization of others with the culture and traditions of nutrition, obtaining scientific knowledge about the food of a particular ethnic group carries the ideas of tolerance and contributes to the formation of family values, as well as the greatest mutual understanding between nations through close contact with material culture The purpose of the study is to consider the food culture of the Buryat people as a socio-cultural component of the traditional culture of society. In the course of the study, both general scientific research methods (analysis and synthesis, deduction and induction, generalization, observation) and socio-cultural analysis were used. The theoretical basis was the works of such researchers as Evmenova L.N., Andreeva L.A., Hopiyainen O.A., Filimonov N.V. and others. The empirical basis was the results of a study conducted in the village of Chelutai in the Aginsky municipal district and aimed at collecting materials on the technology and recipe of national cuisine dishes, studying the degree of its preservation. The practical significance of the research results lies in the possibility of applying the results of the author's scientific research both in shaping the policy of the hospitality industry in a particular region and in developing measures to preserve the intangible cultural heritage. Unfortunately, the author has not analyzed the scientific validity of the studied issues, despite the impressive volume of works available in scientific discourse on both the culture of everyday life in general and gastronomic culture in particular. The scientific novelty of the study was the culturological approach to the study of the traditional gastronomic culture of the indigenous peoples of the Trans-Baikal Territory. The culturological approach in the author's research is an analysis of the interaction of gastronomic culture with the socio-cultural context of the functioning of a particular society. It is aimed at identifying the contents of a certain cultural epoch refracted in it and at detecting the interaction of generally recognized norms and provisions of gastronomic culture and cultural subjects. This allowed the author to create a holistic image of gastronomic culture, to identify an actual and promising study of gastronomic culture from the standpoint of cultural studies. In the context of the development of gastronomic culture, the author draws a demarcation between the conditions that determine the manifestations of gastronomic culture as a special phenomenon and the conditions that determine the specifics of local and temporary alternatives to gastronomic culture. According to the author, gastronomic culture manifests itself as a form of cultural adaptation to natural circumstances and their provision of opportunities for biological survival. In the national food culture, the author observes the originality of the trends of traditionalism. The author pays special attention to the analysis of the specifics of the Buryat gastronomic culture, the reasons that led to its emergence and development, as well as the description of the current state of the Buryat people's food culture and ways to popularize it. In conclusion, the author presents a conclusion on the conducted research, which contains all the key provisions of the presented material. It seems that the author in his material touched upon relevant and interesting issues for modern socio-humanitarian knowledge, choosing a topic for analysis, consideration of which in scientific research discourse will entail certain changes in the established approaches and directions of analysis of the problem addressed in the presented article. The results obtained allow us to assert that the study of gastronomic culture as an iconic layer of the traditional culture of a certain people is of undoubted scientific and practical cultural interest and deserves further study. The material presented in the work has a clear, logically structured structure that contributes to a more complete assimilation of the material. This is also facilitated by an adequate choice of an appropriate methodological framework. The bibliography of the study consisted of 14 sources, which seems sufficient for the generalization and analysis of scientific discourse on the subject under study. The author fulfilled his goal, received certain scientific results that allowed him to summarize the material. It should be noted that the article may be of interest to readers and deserves to be published in a reputable scientific publication. However, the text of the article needs proofreading and editing.

Third Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The subject of the peer-reviewed study is such a factor of the ethnocultural identity of the Buryat population of the Trans-Baikal Territory as national cuisine. The author rightly associates the relevance of his research with "globalization, urbanization, mass migrations, and the geopolitical situation," which cannot but have a negative impact on the preservation of national cultures, traditions, languages, and gastronomy. Unfortunately, the author completely ignored his duty to properly reflect on the theoretical and methodological foundations of his own research, entrusting this work to the reader. Nevertheless, it can be understood from the context that historical and institutional methods were used in the analysis of Buryat cuisine traditions, as well as methods of included observation characteristic of anthropology and sociology. The correct application of these methods allowed the author to obtain results with signs of scientific novelty. In particular, the identification and description of the key factors that influenced the formation and reproduction of Buryat ethnonational cuisine, as well as its current state and development, should be noted as innovative. The detailing of the elements and some of the technologies of this kitchen itself is also of particular interest. Structurally, the work also does not cause serious complaints: its logic is consistent and reflects the main aspects of the research. Although the rubrication would only decorate the scientific text. The following are highlighted as structural elements in the text: - the introductory part, where a scientific problem is formulated, its relevance is justified, the purpose and objectives of the study are set, but theoretical and methodological reflection is completely ignored; - the historical part, in which the historical prerequisites for the formation of Buryat cuisine are analyzed; - the actual analysis of the content of Buryat cuisine; - the conclusion, where The results of the conducted research are summarized, conclusions are drawn and prospects for further research are outlined. From the point of view of style, the reviewed article can be qualified as a scientific work. There is a certain amount of stylistic in the text (for example, for example, pleonasm as in the expression "technology of its [food] extraction and receipt"; another example: "... Previously, the Buryats led a nomadic and pastoral lifestyle, while engaged in cattle breeding ..."; or repetitions of some words: "...historically formed from generation to generation, it forms..."; or a lost object with which the actor of cooking correlates himself: "separates himself from others and correlates himself [with what/whom? – Rec.] as part of the culture of their ethnic group"; or "character," which "is" (apparently, like wear a dress) study: "the study of the features of traditional dishes... in the framework of the present study is relevant..."; etc.) and grammatical (e.g., unnecessary dashes in the sentence "to Save his people, the ethnic group, its uniqueness and originality is one of the..."; or fused spelling of the adjective in the presence of dependent words: "...For a person unfamiliar with a particular people..."; or, on the contrary, separate writing "not" with the adjective in the sentence, and a comma is not needed: "Not by chance, so common in the world of gastronomy tourism"; but the simple in the complex should be separated by a comma: "...it has Become popular to cook local dishes although it is worth noting..."; or a colon before a quotation instead of a comma in the sentence, "according to Andreeva L. A., Kupiainen O. A., Filimonova N. In. in his research: "the national kitchen...""; or just inconsistent sentences like this: "the Study aimed TO gather the materials..., study of its degree of preservation, fixation, the actual material..."; and the comma after the word "commit" is not needed; it is also incorrect listing as homogeneous sizes of nouns, as in this case: "the Rational use of all animal products, sheep breeding, horse breeding..." (except sheep and horse-breeding are not part of the animal?); etc.) of errors, but overall it is written quite well, at a reasonable Russian language, with correct use of scientific terminology. There are also a number of factual errors, for example, in the maxim "Gastronomy is a significant resource of the territory, a source of formation of its identity ...", an unexpected carrier of identity turns out to be ... the territory. In the future, the author may wish to take a more responsible attitude to the reflection of his own theoretical and methodological foundations, as well as to the design of the results of his research. The bibliography includes 14 titles and adequately represents the state of research on the subject of the article. Although it could be strengthened by including sources in foreign languages. There is no appeal to opponents due to the lack of theoretical and methodological reflection. GENERAL CONCLUSION: the article proposed for review can be qualified as a scientific work that meets the basic requirements for works of this kind. Despite some shortcomings in the design of the study, as well as the design of its results, the results obtained by the author will be of interest to cultural scientists, sociologists and cultural philosophers, specialists in the field of ethnonational traditions and cultures, as well as for students of these specialties. The presented material corresponds to the subject of the magazine "Culture and Art". According to the results of the review, the article is recommended for publication.