Ðóñ Eng Cn Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Financial Law and Management
Reference:

Krotkova N. V. Sergei A. Kotlyarevskiy as a Representative of Soviet Jurisprudence

Abstract: The article highlights the views of S. A. Kotlyarevskiy on the Soviet constitutional system, as well as his analysis of financial activity of the Soviet state. It is shown that in the search for an appropriate balance of interests, Kotlyarevskiy examines in detail the relationship between the USSR and republics and tries to build an optimal boundary line in distribution of competence to ensure the successful functioning of the federation. The bulk of sources consist of works by Kotlyarevskiy in Soviet period. When studying his papers it is important to relate the chronology of works with the facts of his personal biography and political events in the world and Russia. The main principles of the present study are: historicism, documentalism, comprehensive and unbiased analysis, critical evaluation of the material. The research work uses the following general research methods: logical, historical, comparative, sociological, and deduction, induction, analysis, synthesis, hypothesis, analogy, and others. It is concluded that Kotlyarevskiy considers the Soviet constitutional system mainly from the formal dogmatic point of view, however, he attempts to give political characteristics of social structure of the USSR and its republics. He was one of the first scholars who carried out a systematic analysis of the financial activities of the Soviet state for the first years of its existence and gave valuable practical recommendations. He is justly considered to be one of those who stood at the origins of the Soviet state, administrative and financial law.


Keywords:

Sergei A. Kotlyarevskiy, state, Constitution, federalism, financial legislation, fiscal relations, budget of the USSR, local budgets, income tax, agricultural tax.


This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article

This article written in Russian. You can find original text of the article here .
References
1. Bel'skii K.S. Finansovoe pravo (Nauka, istoriya, bibliografiya). – M.: Yurist, 1994. – S. 53.
2. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Byudzhet i mestnye finansy.-M.: Ekonom. zhizn', 1926.
3. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Byudzhet SSSR, kak on sostavlyaetsya, utverzhdaetsya i ispolnyaet-sya. – L.: Gosizdat.
4. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Byudzhetno-finansovye vzaimootnosheniya Soyuza SSR i soyuz-nykh respublik // Sovetskii federalizm.-M.-L., 1930.
5. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Byudzhetnoe pravo RSFSR i SSSR.-M.-Pg.: Gos. izd-vo, 1924.-S. 17, 18, 142.
6. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Byudzhetnoe pravo SSSR.-M.: Gos. izd-vo, 1925.
7. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Byudzhetnye prava Soyuza i soyuznykh respublik // Finansy i narodnoe khozyaistvo.-1928.-¹ 4. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Byudzhetnyi zakon // Sov. pravo.-1926.-¹ 2.
8. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Byudzhety avtonomnykh i raionirovannykh edinits RSFSR // Sov. pravo.-1925.-¹ 5.
9. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Zheleznodorozhnyi i vodnyi transport // Sov. stroitel'stvo.-1931.-¹ 5-6.
10. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Istoriya «Natsional'nogo tsentra» // Krasnaya kniga VChK.-M., 1989.-T. 2.-S. 171.
11. Kotlyarevskii S.A. K voprosu o byudzhetnykh pravakh Soyuza i soyuznykh respublik // Vestnik finansov.-1928.-¹ 10.
12. Kotlyarevskii S.A. K peresmotru polozheniya o byudzhetnykh pravakh SSSR i soyuznykh respublik // Sov. pravo.-1926.-¹ 1.
13. Kotlyarevskii S.A. K reforme rentnogo oblozheniya // Sov. pravo.-1925.-¹ 4.
14. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Kak volost' sobiraet sredstva i kak ikh raskhoduet. Obshchedos-tupnoe izlozhenie zakonov o volostnom byudzhete.-M., 1925; 2-e. izd., ispr. i dop. M., 1926; 3-e izd., ispr. i dop. M., 1927.
15. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Konstitutsiya i byudzhet Soyuza SSR // Sov. stroitel'stvo.-1927.-¹ 7.
16. Kotlyarevskii S.A. O edinom sel'khoznaloge // Sov. stroitel'stvo.-1926.-¹ 5.
17. Kotlyarevskii S.A. O podokhodnom naloge // Sov. stroitel'stvo.-1928.-¹ 1.
18. Kotlyarevskii S.A. O rentnom oblozhenii // Sov. pravo.-1924.-¹ 2.
19. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Ob avtodorozhnom stroitel'stve // Sov. stroitel'stvo.-1932.-¹ 1.
20. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Osvoenie tekhniki i Sovety // Sov. stroitel'stvo.-1933.-¹ 7.
21. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Perspektivy mestnogo byudzheta // Sov. stroitel'stvo.-1929.-¹ 11.
22. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Plan i khozraschet v sotsialisticheskom stroitel'stve // Sov. stroitel'stvo. – 1931.-¹ 10.
23. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Pravovye elementy planovykh aktov // Sov. pravo.-1928.-¹ 1.
24. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Problema byudzhetnogo prava v noveishem zakonodatel'stve RSFSR // Sov. pravo.-1922.-¹ 2.
25. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Razvitie sovetskogo zakonodatel'stva o mestnom khozyaistve.-M.: Yur. izd-vo NKYu RSFSR, 1928. S. 14, 18, 19.
26. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Sel'skie sovety i sel'skie byudzhety // Sov. stroitel'stvo.-1933.-¹ 10.
27. Kotlyarevskii S.A. SSSR i soyuznye respubliki.-M., 1924. – S. 3, 11, 125, 129, 131, 135.
28. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Tyazhelaya promyshlennost' vo vtoroi pyatiletke // Sov. stroi-tel'stvo. 1934. ¹ 12.
29. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Finansovoe zakonodatel'stvo za 1917-1927 gg. // Pravo i zhizn'.-1927.-¹ 8-10.
30. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Finansovoe pravo // Osnovy sovetskogo prava / Pod red. D. Ma-gerovskogo.-M.-L., 1927.
31. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Finansovoe pravo SSSR.-L., 1926.
32. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Finansovye vzaimootnosheniya Soyuza, respublik i mest v re-konstruktivnyi period // Sov. stroitel'stvo.-1931.-¹ 4.
33. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Finansovyi kontrol' v gosudarstvakh Zapadnoi Evropy.-M., 1928.
34. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Khozyaistvennoe razvitie sovetskogo Severa // Sov. stroitel'st-vo.-1932.-¹ 3.
35. Kotlyarevskii S.A. Yuridicheskie predposylki russkikh Osnovnykh zakonov.-M.: Tip. G. Lissnera i D. Sobko, 1912.
36. Krotkova N.V. Vzglyady S.A. Kotlyarevskogo na konstitutsionnyi stroi Rossiiskoi Imperii i Sovetskoi Rossii // Gosudarstvo i pravo.-2008.-¹ 3.-S. 81, 82.
37. Krotkova N.V. Gosudarstvenno-pravovye vzglyady S.A. Kotlyarevskogo: monografiya.-M.: Yuridicheskoe izd-vo «YuRKOMPANI», 2011 (Seriya «Aktual'nye yuridiche-skie issledovaniya»).-S. 6, 7, 11.
38. Kuprits N.Ya. Iz istorii nauki sovetskogo gosudarstvennogo prava. – M., 1971.-S. 25, 26, 109, 166.
39. Mel'gunov S.P. Sud istorii nad intelligentsiei (K delu «Takticheskogo tsentra») // Na chuzhoi storone.-1923.-Kn. 3.-S. 156.
40. Tomsinov V.A. Sergei Andreevich Kotlyarevskii (1873-1939) // Konstitutsionnoe (gosudarstvennoe) pravo v Moskovskom universitete (K 250-letiyu Moskovskogo universiteta) / Otv. red. N.A. Bogdanova.-M., 2005.-S. 147, 148.