Ðóñ Eng Cn Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Psychology and Psychotechnics
Reference:

Current Trends in the Manifestation of Socio-Psychological Distress in Adolescents

Tsirul'nikova Elena Aleksandrovna

ORCID: 0000-0003-1648-1761

PhD in Pedagogy

Associate Professor, Department of Theory and History of Pedagogy, Yaroslavl State Pedagogical University named after K.D. Ushinsky

150000, Russia, Yaroslavl region, Yaroslavl, Republican str., 108/1, office 1

e_ceryl@mail.ru
Other publications by this author
 

 
Lukanin Nikita Sergeevich

Graduate Student, Department of Theory and History of Pedagogy, Yaroslavl State Pedagogical University named after K.D. Ushinsky

150000, Russia, Yaroslavl region, Yaroslavl, Republican str., 108/1

lukanina-mv@mail.ru

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0722.2022.4.39430

EDN:

SIEQXE

Received:

17-12-2022


Published:

30-12-2022


Abstract: The subject of the study is the content of the main socio-psychological difficulties and problems that encourage modern adolescents to seek psychological help and are manifestations of socio-psychological distress. The study was conducted on the basis of an analysis of the content of requests for advisory practice for the period 2012-2022. The city center of psychological, pedagogical, medical and social assistance of Yaroslavl. All requests for psychological help were classified by the authors into several groups: communicative problems (reflecting the specifics of relations with the adolescent's society); problems arising in the development of general educational and universal actions; psycho-emotional difficulties and crises (including experiencing eating disorders, suicidal disorders, autoaggression, traumatic experience) and destructive behavior (antisociality, aggression and dependent behavior). A mathematical analysis of the dynamics of appeals of each type was carried out. As a result of the conducted research, conclusions were formulated about the content of the main difficulties and problems that are relevant for modern adolescents and are the subject of an appeal to a psychologist. These include difficulties in relationships with others, the development of a tendency to autoaggression, eating disorders and an increase in a number of problems associated with psychoemotional difficulties, violence. In conclusion, the types of innovative activities of the center for improving the communicative, psycho-emotional and behavioral aspects of the socio-psychological well-being of adolescents are described. The novelty of the described research consists in the development and testing of a system of programs to reduce the socio-psychological distress of adolescents. A special place in them is occupied by programs of work with parents.


Keywords:

Socio-psychological trouble, adolescents, subjective well-being, communication, deviant behavior, psycho-emotional state, general educational activities, universal educational activities, psychological assistance to adolescents, counseling practice

This article is automatically translated. You can find original text of the article here.

Socio-psychological well-being in adolescence plays an important role in the formation of personality and affects all further human development. At the present stage of development of society, the ongoing socio-cultural changes, modernization of the educational process, increasing the requirements for the personality of the student also have a significant impact on the psychological state of adolescents. In particular, one of the main aspects that come to the fore in the development of the modern education system is the creation of conditions for the formation of psychological skills and abilities among students, with the help of which they will be able to maintain a positive direction in their own development and self-realization under rapidly changing conditions, information saturation and inconsistency of the modern world. We can definitely say that the portrait of a modern teenager is undergoing significant changes under the influence of external factors and changes in the conditions of its development. All this actualizes research on the topic of socio-psychological well-being of schoolchildren and the study of modern trends in the manifestation of the studied state from the point of view of the dynamic aspect.

The topic of subjective well-being over the past decade has attracted increasing attention to the study of both foreign and domestic researchers (M. Argyle, N. Bradburn, A. Waterman, E. Diener, K. Riff, R. Emmons, S. A. Mukhina, R.M. Shamionov, I.S. Zimina, M.N. Gavrilova, O.V. Polozova, O.S. Savelyeva, V.A. Ananyev, A.V. Voronina, T. O. Gordeeva, D. A. Leontiev, L. V. Kulikov, O. A. Idobaeva, T.D. Shevelenkova, etc.). Psychological well-being reflects a sense of subjective mental comfort and health of the individual. This condition is primarily associated with a person's ability to be highly active and efficient, as well as with the adaptation of the subject to society [1].

Socio-psychological well-being can be defined as a characteristic reflecting the quality of a person's life associated with his level of socio-environmental orientation and socio-household adaptation, which, in turn, include optimal modes of social, family, household and professional activity for an individual [2]. From the point of view of inner experience, psychological well-being is reflected in the openness of the individual, the ability to react emotionally and live the whole range of emotional responses, in the ability to overcome alienation and feel unity with the surrounding world (N.K. Smirnova, M.V. Valyuzhenich) [6].

Socio-psychological difficulties of adolescents in foreign literature are considered as a combination of such aspects as social (external social conditions, the influence of peers and family, social support), emotional (feelings and emotional experiences of a teenager) and educational (various cognitive problems, school motivation and adaptation) [7]. In the study of N. Y. Makeeva, behavioral and neurotic symptoms of socio-psychological distress are highlighted:  communication with peers prone to illegal behavior, lack of hobbies, hobbies, constant absenteeism in educational institutions, lack of stable friendly relations with peers, conflicts with teachers, unkempt appearance, non-compliance with personal hygiene standards, the presence of bad habits, a tendency to theft, a tendency to escape, leaving home [5].

As part of our research, we tried to determine the content of the main difficulties that reduce the level of socio-psychological well-being of adolescents. To do this, we analyzed the content of counseling practice with teenagers of the Municipal Institution "City Center for Psychological, Pedagogical, Medical and Social Assistance", Yaroslavl and identified the typology of requests for consultations in the period from 2012 to 2022. Based on this, all consulting requests were classified by us as follows:

- communicative problems, reflecting the specifics of the relationship with the society of a teenager;

- problems arising in the development of general educational and universal actions related to the experience of the examination period, with motivation and school failure, with the peculiarities of the formation of cognitive functions;

- psychoemotional difficulties and crises, this aspect reflects various kinds of psychoemotional difficulties, the experience of eating behavior disorder, suicidal disorders, autoaggression, as well as traumatic experience;

- destructive behavior associated with antisociality, aggression and dependent behavior.

The difficulties and problems presented above, faced by modern adolescents, determine the content of the socio-psychological distress of schoolchildren.

In the studies of T.V. Kornilova, S.D. Smirnov, E.L. Grigorenko, the factors influencing the socio-psychological distress of adolescents are differentiated into external and internal. The authors found that these components influence each other and determine the overall level of socio-psychological distress of a teenager's personality. Thus, the internal psychological distress is more influenced by such an external factor as a cruel attitude (violence) over a schoolboy. Destructive behavior of adolescents is formed both on the basis of social and with various psychoemotional disorders of adolescents. Also, researchers have found that problems related to relationships in the family affect psychological distress and difficulties with socialization in adolescence. [4]

According to the research of V.N. Kolesnikov, Yu.I. Melnik, it has been established that the problems of a communicative nature that determine the level of socio-psychological distress are considered in some studies from the point of view of a teenager's ability to seek help and social support. Neither school nor teachers are a source of social support for teenagers. At the same time, 49.8% of young men note that they generally do not have a person on whom they could rely and to whom they would be ready to turn for help. While 70% of girls say that close people are still present in their lives. In general, the willingness of a teenager to seek social support contributes to the reduction of socio-psychological distress of adolescents. At the same time, first of all, schoolchildren are ready to turn to the "significant other", in second place – to family members and in third to friends. In adolescence, there is an average severity of anxiety, and, in general, girls are more likely to experience anxiety and various kinds of fears (V.N. Kolesnikov, Yu.I. Melnik) [3].

At the same time, according to modern research, life satisfaction, including relationships with parents, peers, teachers and grades, has average values in adolescents. Most of all, teenagers are not satisfied with school life in this matter, in particular, with their own assessments and relationships with teachers (V.N. Kolesnikov, Yu.I. Melnik) [3].

Next, the results of the analysis of advisory practice on each type of difficulties and problems of socio-psychological well-being among adolescents in the Yaroslavl region will be presented.

Fig.1. Dynamics of teenagers' consulting requests to the City Center for Psychological, Pedagogical, medical and Social assistance from 2012 to 2022.According to the results of the study of the dynamics of requests for consultations among adolescents from 2012 to 2022, the following can be said.

Communication problems for the presented period range from 103 to 250 requests per year. In general, the value of the registered cases is in the same range, no significant differences in the severity of the communicative aspect of socio-psychological well-being were found for the selected period of time (p?0.05). Despite this, over the past 5 years there has been a tendency to increase the appeals of adolescents with communication-related problems. This suggests that over time, the relevance of teenagers' requests on the topics of relationships with parents, teachers and peers increases.

General educational and universal actions for the period from 2012 to 2022 also remain in the range of values from 76 to 222 cases of appeals per year. Significant differences in the severity of aspects of general educational and universal actions during the study period were established (p?0.05, U=764.5). However, since 2015-2016, there has been a downward trend in registered cases of appeals on this topic. The results obtained indicate that there is currently a decrease in the number of adolescents seeking help in situations of upcoming exams, low academic motivation, school failure, unformed UUD or with neuropsychological problems.

Such an aspect of socio-psychological distress as psycho-emotional difficulties and crises in the period from 2012 to 2022 has a statistically significant tendency to increase actualization in adolescence (p?0.001, U=648.5). This may indicate two trends:  firstly, the fact that over the past decade, the relevance of such problems as violence, suicidal tendencies and autoaggression, eating disorders, as well as personal psycho-emotional difficulties has been increasing among adolescents; secondly, in recent years, systematic work on early detection and prevention of these problems has been significantly updated – educational organizations closely cooperate with medical andpsychological and pedagogical centers – from this the number of consulting cases increases, but many difficulties are solved at the initial stages.

The risk of destructive behavior as an indicator of socio-psychological distress of adolescents varies in the range from 44 to 107 cases of appeals per year. There is a slight tendency to an increase in appeals on this topic, but no statistically significant differences were found (p?0.05). In addition, fewer clients apply for the aspect of destructive behavior than for other issues. All this suggests that behavioral disorders, dependence on surfactants and gadget addiction are not relevant requests for treatment among adolescents, despite the increase in the number of such cases.

It is important to note that 2015-2016 was a turning point in the dynamics of teenagers' requests regarding aspects of socio-psychological distress. Requests of a communicative nature related to emotional difficulties and destructive behavior began to increase, while cases of appeals related to general educational and universal actions decreased.

At the same time, as a result of correlation analysis, it was found that with an increase in problems in the communicative aspect of socio-psychological distress, the severity of deviant behavior in adolescents increases (r=0.738, with p<0.05). This suggests that with difficulties in relationships with significant adults, peers, parents and teachers, the likelihood of deviant behavior, aggression, and various forms of addiction increases. I. S. Ganishina in her research has established that the peculiarities of relationships with close people leads to the formation of deviant behavior [2]. This also confirms the relationships we have identified.

Summarizing the results obtained, we can say that at the moment there are a number of trends in the manifestation of socio-psychological distress: such aspects as difficulties in relationships with others are becoming more acute, adolescents tend to show autoaggression, eating disorders and face psychoemotional difficulties, violence. The revealed trends may indicate that modern adolescents, experiencing crisis situations and severe emotional states, unable to receive social support from the environment, are increasingly inclined to live their states in themselves through autoaggression.

The obtained research results substantiate the relevance of the development of psychological assistance and support for adolescents, which is reflected in the updating practice of the center for psychological, pedagogical, medical and social assistance.

Responding to the current needs of adolescents, a system of new correctional, developmental and preventive programs has been developed and implemented on the basis of the City Center for Psychological, Pedagogical, Medical and Social Assistance.

 To improve the psycho-emotional aspect of socio-psychological well-being, such innovative activities of the center as the municipal internship platform "Crisis psychological counseling in educational organizations are being implemented. Specifics and methods of work of a teacher-psychologist".

To reduce the risk of destructive behavior of adolescents, the municipal resource center "Preventive work and the provision of psychological and pedagogical assistance to children with autoaggressive and suicidal behavior in educational organizations", the municipal innovation platform "Formation of motivation for rational nutrition among students of educational organizations", as well as the municipal internship platform "Organization of preventive work and the formation of psychological and pedagogical competence in employees of educational organizations working with children who have destructive behavior."

Special attention is paid to systematic work with parents, because the socio-psychological well-being of adolescents directly depends on the degree of involvement of parents and close environment in the life of a teenager, on their willingness to help a teenager master constructive ways of coping with difficult life circumstances [5,8]. Therefore, based on the conducted research, we have compiled a program to reduce the socio-psychological distress of adolescents, as a result of which, through the joint activities of adolescents and parents, the development of communication between them, learning new strategies for coping with stressful situations and the continuity of family constructive ways to overcome difficult life situations, it was possible to reduce the prevalence of communication problems with parents (W=-106 at p<0.05), destructive behavior (W=-189 at p<0.01), as well as to reduce the severity of autoaggression (W=-92 at p<0.05) among adolescents. At the moment, this program is being implemented as a component of the regional project "Parent Academy "Parent +".

Thus, the conducted research made it possible to develop an up-to-date system of psychological correctional and preventive work focused on key subjects of interaction with a teenager and thereby contribute to the resolution of difficulties that reduce the level of socio-psychological well-being of adolescents.

References
1. Ganishina I. S. (2004) Psychological influence of a dysfunctional family on deviant behavior of minors. Ryazan: [Acad. law and ex. Ministry of Justice of Russia].
2. Glossary of medical and sociological terms National Encyclopedic Service: Sociological Encyclopedia. Retrieved from: https://voluntary.ru/termin/socialno-psihologicheskoe-blagopoluchie.html
3. Kolesnikov, V. N., & Melnik, Y. I. (2015). Features of the psychological well-being of students of middle adolescence. Bulletin of the Leningrad State University. AS Pushkin, 5(4), 21-32.
4. Kornilova, T. V., Smirnov, S. D., & Grigorenko, E. L. (2001). Factors of social and psychological ill-being of adolescents in terms of methods of standardized interviews and observation sheets. Issues of Psychology, (1), 107-122.
5. Makeeva, N. Yu. (2021). Chapter 3. Socio-psychological well-being and value orientations of adolescents from families with non-normative family crises. Current issues of psychosocial work. In Socio-psychological problems of modern society in the context of digitalization: personality, organization, management (pp. 46-61).
6. Smirnov, N. K., & Valyuzhenich, M. V. (2012). Formation of the space of psychological well-being as an urgent task of the modern school. Continuing teacher education. ru, (1), 167-167.
7. Johnson J., Manickavasagam B. (2019) Socio-psychological problems of adolescents among higher secondary level students of Thiruvananthapuram city, Kerala. Pramana Research Journal, (9), 899-905.
8. Tuymuratovna, I. D. (2022). Socio-psychological features of correction of adolescents’ emotional stress in the family. Asian Journal of Research in Social Sciences and Humanities, 12(4), 116-118.

First Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The paper "Current trends in the manifestation of socio-psychological distress in adolescents" is presented for review. The subject of the study. As the subject, as the title of the work suggests, are social trends in the manifestation of socio-psychological distress in adolescents. The subject is presented broadly and incorrectly. It is not entirely clear what "current trends" are and how they will be measured. Moreover, the purpose of the work is to determine the content of the main difficulties that reduce the level of socio-psychological well-being of adolescents. This is a more correct formulation, which made it possible to conduct a study. Research methodology. The methodology is the work of foreign and domestic researchers, most of which are missing from the bibliographic list. The conducted study was based on an analysis of the number of applications from adolescents to the City Center for Psychological, Pedagogical, Medical and Social Assistance from 2012 to 2022. Based on this, conclusions were drawn. Relevance. The relevance of the problem raised in the work is justified both from the perspective of socio-cultural changes that are taking place in society, and the need to create conditions for the formation of psychological skills and abilities among students, with the help of which they will be able to maintain a positive direction in their own development and self-realization under rapidly changing conditions, information saturation and inconsistency of the modern world. Scientific novelty. The planned study is interesting both from a theoretical and practical point of view. However, the results obtained made it possible to substantiate the relevance of the development of psychological assistance and support for adolescents. It should be noted that this is reflected, as the author claims, in the practice of daily activities of the center for psychological, pedagogical, medical and social assistance. The significance of the conducted research can be given by the author's developed program of assistance to adolescents, formed on the basis of the results of the conducted research. Since the author speaks as a conclusion about the implementation of certain correctional, developmental and preventive programs at the center. This cannot be a scientific novelty. Style, structure, content. The style of presentation corresponds to publications of this level. The language of the presentation is scientific. The structure of the work is intuitively traceable. The introduction describes the relevance and analysis of the literature. The main part contains a description of the analysis of counseling practice for each type of difficulties and problems of socio-psychological well-being among adolescents in the Yaroslavl region over the past 10 years. Bibliography. The bibliography of the article includes only 5 domestic sources. There are no publications with a publication date for the last three years in the list. The problems of the work correspond to the subject of the article. The bibliography contains both research articles and the abstract of the dissertation, as well as a sociological encyclopedia and an online publication. The sources of literature are heterogeneous, there are many inconsistencies. The bibliographic list is designed incorrectly, the requirements are mostly ignored. Many positions need to be clarified. Appeal to opponents. A more complete theoretical review is needed in the scientific work. Research publications from the last 3 years must also be considered. Since many of the issues that were presented in the experimental study have already been considered by scientists. In conclusion, it is necessary to describe the author's own contribution to solving the problem. Taking into account the recommendations made will allow us to submit a full-fledged research paper to the editorial board. Conclusions. The article is distinguished by its undoubted relevance, theoretical and practical value, and will be of interest to the scientific community. The work can be recommended for publication after correcting the comments.

Second Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The relevance of the topic of socio-psychological well-being of modern adolescents is extremely relevant. In this case, there are many arguments that relate to the quality of life of young people and their social attitudes. The author correctly writes in substantiating the relevance of the study that the portrait of a modern teenager is undergoing significant changes under the influence of external factors and changes in the conditions of its development. All this actualizes research on the topic of socio-psychological well-being of schoolchildren and the study of modern trends in the manifestation of the studied condition from the point of view of the dynamic aspect. All this is true and can be recognized as the merit of the article. But in order to develop this topic, it is necessary to formulate the purpose of the study and its subject. This is so important that it is simply impossible without it. Because in the absence of these formulations, the text is perceived as purposeless and pointless. It is also necessary to substantiate the scientific novelty of this study. Given the relevance of the topic, the justification of scientific novelty should not cause any difficulties. There is no information about the research methodology in the text. The author provides data on those authors who have researched similar topics. Thus, it is noted that the topic of subjective well-being over the past decade has attracted increasing attention to the study of both foreign and domestic researchers (M. Argyle, N. Bradburn, A. Waterman, E. Diener, K. Riff, R. Emmons, S.A. Mukhina, R.M. Shamionov, I.S. Zimina, M.N. Gavrilova, O.V. Polozova, O.S. Savelyeva, V.A. Ananyev, A.V. Voronina, T.O. Gordeeva, D.A. Leontiev, L. V. Kulikov, O.A. Idobaeva, T.D. Shevelenkova, etc.). But this is not a methodology. As a methodological justification, it is necessary to show the theory, concept, or at least the principles on the basis of which the study of modern trends in the manifestation of socio-psychological distress in adolescents is carried out. Therefore, further work is needed. The style of presentation of the text is exploratory. Obviously, the author drew attention to an important problem, managed to consider it as an urgent problem and systematize it structurally. That is, it is clear that the author consistently analyzes the trends of manifestation of socio-psychological distress in modern adolescents. But there are comments on the structure of the presentation of the material. So, apart from the lack of formulations of the purpose, subject, novelty and methodology of the study, the text does not show the methodology, there are no conclusions and conclusions. For this reason, there are questions about the content of the work. So, the author correctly did that he showed the most significant requests for appeals to the Center, highlighting from them such as: - communicative problems reflecting the specifics of relations with the adolescent's society; - problems arising in the development of general educational and universal actions related to the experience of the exam period, motivation and school failure, with features of the formation of cognitive functions; - psychoemotional difficulties and crises, this aspect reflects various kinds of psychoemotional difficulties, experiencing an eating disorder of behavior, suicidal disorders, autoaggression, as well as traumatic experience; - destructive behavior associated with antisociality, aggression and dependent behavior. As confirmation, a quite convincing figure is given, which reflects the dynamics of teenagers' consulting requests to the City Center for Psychological, Pedagogical, Medical and Social Assistance from 2012 to 2022. This could be stopped, starting with the description and analysis of the identified trends. But the author writes, for example, that "communication problems for the period presented range from 103 to 250 requests per year. In general, the value of the registered cases is in the same range, no significant differences in the severity of the communicative aspect of socio-psychological well-being were found over the selected period of time (p?0.05), etc." The question arises about the values of the registered cases. What is this value, what are their values, on the basis of which the criteria for the reliability of differences were calculated, what were compared with what, what were the groups of examined persons, what is the quantitative composition of the groups, why is the corresponding tabular material not presented? But further along the text, there are also other indicators of statistical processing of the material that arose "out of the blue". Apparently, the author has made some statistical measurements, this is correct, but it is possible to write about them only when the research methodology is shown, taking into account the reviewer's questions about the organization of this study. Commenting on the data obtained, the author makes many correct conclusions. On their basis, good and convincing conclusions can be formulated. That is, the work leaves a very good impression overall. But it is necessary to simplify it somewhat, eliminating the statistical part and limiting it to the descriptive level of interpretation of the identified trends. In this case, it is permissible. The bibliographic list consists of sources on the research topic. Given that the work is relevant in its significance and has great potential for refining the text, as well as due to the fact that it will arouse the interest of the reading audience, the article can be recommended for publication in a scientific journal after eliminating the comments indicated in the review.

Third Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The object of research in the proposed article is the socio-psychological well-being of adolescents, while its individual aspects are actually the subject. The relevance of the topic is undeniable, since understanding the factors of this well-being makes it possible to more effectively build psychological and pedagogical work in practice. The novelty of the article is due to the original author's research with the processing of a substantial amount of data. The study has a classical structure and consists of theoretical and practical parts, so the main methods of work in this case are psychological and pedagogical analysis and ascertaining experiment. The author's conclusions and final practical reflections allow us to talk about the analytical and synthetic nature of the work. The list of references generally meets the requirements, but it is clearly poorer than the list of names of researchers presented in the theoretical part, and it is desirable to correct this. The very wide time span of the experimental work deserves attention. The proposed article may be of interest primarily to teachers and practicing psychologists. The language of the work generally corresponds to the norms of scientific style, however, it is necessary to check the commas before "as" in the meaning of "as". They should not be in this case. The theoretical part of the work is generally performed at a fairly high quality level, however, there are comments. In theory, insufficient emphasis is placed on age specifics, since in this part there is no information on how the socio-psychological well-being of adolescents differs from the well-being of, for example, students. In addition, if, as the author notes, the topic is so widely researched (as evidenced by a solid list of authors), it would be logical to at least review the contribution of each of them from the point of view of the studied aspects of the problem. The theoretical part would benefit if the author presented and compared a number of different definitions of socio-psychological well-being from the point of view of the essential and meaningful aspects of the phenomenon under study. The main observation on the practical part is that the material as a whole is factual rather than reflexive in nature. The word "trends" in the title implies the identification of patterns, and this in turn means an analysis of the factors of the studied process at the level of nature, as well as the synthesis of certain forecasts, namely the state of this problem in the foreseeable future. I would like the trends to be highlighted and updated more clearly precisely as patterns with an inherent causal relationship. In general, the trends are rather indicated, but not fully disclosed. These remarks somewhat impoverish the content of the text, but do not negate the fact that the work as a whole was performed in compliance with the basic structural and content requirements for works of this kind and can be recommended for publication in a peer-reviewed journal in the psychological and pedagogical field.