Ðóñ Eng Cn Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law
Reference:

Savchyn M.V. Constitutional Values, Legitimacy of Public Power and Constituent Legitimacy

Abstract: The problem of constituent legitimacy in the context of comparative analysis of models of legitimating of public power in the light of constitutional values is examined in the article. The problem of the democratic legitimacy of the constitutional order is analyzed in the article and proposals for the improvement of the constitutional system of Ukraine are developed on the basis of interdisciplinary approach and combined achievements of political science, sociology, law and doctrine of natural and positive law. Relations between democratic legitimacy and constitutional values through deliberative legitimacy (complicity) and the democratic legitimacy of human rights are analyzed in the article. A comparative analysis of models of neutral way of unitary, egalitarian and axiological achieving the consensus in society is made. The nature of the constituent legitimacy in the light of constitutional values and the legal status of the Constitutional Assembly established to prepare a bill on renovation of the Constitution of Ukraine are revealed. The author formulates key issues that should be the subject of public debate and consideration by the Constitutional Assembly. The mechanism of the revision of the Constitution in accordance with the Europeans constitutional values and democratic legitimacy is defined.


Keywords:

democracy, Constitutional Assembly, constitutional values, constituent legitimacy, constituent power, human rights, rule of law, sovereignty.


This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article

This article written in Russian. You can find original text of the article here .
References
1. Allan TRS. Konstituts³ina spravedliv³st'. L³beral'na teor³ya verkhovenstva prava. K.: Vidavnichii d³m Kiºvo-Mogilyans'ka Akadem³ya, 2008. 385 s.
2. Veber M. Politika kak professiya // Izbrannye proizvedeniya: Per. s nem.; sost., obshch. red. i poslesl. Yu.N. Davydova; predisl. P.P. Gaidenko; komment. A.F. Filippova. M.: Progress, 1990. 651 s.
3. Gabermas Yu. Zaluchennya ³nshogo: Stud³¿ z pol³tichno¿ teor³¿ / Per. z n³m. L'v³v: Astrolyab³ya, 2006. 415 s.
4. Dal' R. Demokratiya i ee kritiki / Per. s angl. M.: ROSSPEN, 1998. 576 s.
5. Dzhagaryan A. Suverennaya demokratiya kak otobrazhenie konstitutsionnykh tsennostei v zerkale obshchenatsional'-nykh interesov // Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie. 2007. ¹ 4 (61).
6. Zhakke Zh-P. Konstitutsionnoe pravo i politicheskie instituty / per. s fr. V.V. Maklakova. M.: Yurist'', 2002. 365 s.
7. Zor'kin V. Aksiologicheskie aspekty Konstitutsii Rossii // SKO. 2008. ¹ 4 (65). S. 7-20.
8. Kozyubra M. Printsip verkhovenstva prava ³ konstituts³ina yurisdikts³ya // V³snik Konstituts³inogo Sudu Ukra¿ni. 2000. ¹ 4. S. 24-32.
9. Lyusher F. Konstitutsionnaya zashchita prav i svobod lichnosti. M., 1993. 384 s.
10. Mere Zh. Printsip suveren³tetu. ²stor³ya ta osnovi nov³tn'o¿ vladi / per. z fr. L. Kononovich. L'v³v: Kal'var³ya, 1996. 216 s.
11. Nor´aard O. Ekonom³chn³ ³nstituts³¿ ta demokratichna reforma. Por³vyanl'nii anal³z postkomun³stichnikh kra¿n / per. z angl. M. Kozuba, A. Galushki. K.: N³ka-Tsentr, 2007. 424 s.
12. Pro Konstituts³inu Asambleyu: Ukaz Prezidenta Ukra¿ni v³d 17 travnya 2012 r. ¹ 328/2012 [Elektronnii re-surs] — Rezhim dostupu http://www.president.gov.ua/documents/14752.html
13. Pro vnesennya zm³n do Konstituts³¿ Ukra¿ni : Zakon Ukra¿ni v³d 8 grudnya 2004 r. // V³domost³ Verkhovno¿ Radi Ukra¿ni. 2005. ¹ 2. St. 44.
14. R³shennya Kostituts³inogo Sudu Ukra¿ni ¹ 20-rp/2010 v³d 30.09.2010 r. (sprava pro doderzhannya protseduri vne-sennya zm³n do Konstituts³¿ Ukra¿ni) // V³snik Konstituts³inogo Sudu Ukra¿ni. 2010. ¹ 6. S. 142-151.
15. Rozanvalon P. Demokratichna leg³timn³st'. Bezstoronn³st', reflektivn³st', nablizhen³st' / Per. z fr. ª. Mar³cheva. K.: Vidavnichii d³m Kiºvo-Mogilyans'ka Akadem³ya, 2009. 286 s.
16. Rolz Dzh. Teor³ya spravedlivost³ / Dzhon Rolz; per. z angl. O. Mokrovol's'kii. K.: Vidavnitstvo Solom³¿ Pav-lichko «Osnovi», 2001. 822 s.
17. Savchin M. Osnovn³ suchasn³ tipi konstituts³onal³zmu // Naukovii v³snik Uzhgorods'kogo nats³onal'nogo un³versitetu. Ser³ya Pravo. Vip. 9. S. 135-140.
18. Tanchev E. Voznikayushchii nadnatsional'nyi konstitutsionalizm i sovremennye sistemy konstitutsionnogo kontrolya // SKO. 2007. ¹ 4 (61). S. 78-93.
19. Tikhonravov Yu.V. Osnovy filosofii prava. M., 1997. 405 s.
20. Tur M.G. Neklasichn³ model³ leg³timats³¿ sots³al'nikh ³nstitut³v: Monograf³ya. K.: PARAPAN, 2006. 423 s.
21. Uitts R., Shaio A. Konstitutsionnye tsennosti v praktike konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya Vengrii // Sravni-tel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie. 2007. ¹ 2 (59). S. 79-124.
22. F³losof³ya prav lyudini / Za red. Sh. ¥osepata ta ¥. Lomanna. K.: N³ka-Tsentr, 2008. 317 s.
23. Fukuyama F. Sil'noe gosudarstvo. Upravlenie i mirovoi poryadok v KhKh² veke. M.: AST, 2006. 221 s.
24. Funkts³onuvannya demokratichnikh ³nstitut³v v Ukra¿n³: Rezolyuts³ya 1755(2010) Parlaments'ko¿ Asamble¿ Radi ªvropi. http://assembly.coe.int/Main.asp?link=/Documents/AdoptedText/ta10/ERES1755.htm
25. Funkts³onuvannya demokratichnikh ³nstitut³v v Ukra¿n³: Rezolyuts³ya 1862(2012) Parlaments'ko¿ Asamble¿ Radi ªvropi. http://assembly.coe.int/Mainf.asp?link=/Documents/AdoptedText/ta12/ERES1862.htm
26. Tsvºtkov V.V., Kres³na ².O., Kovalenko A.A. Susp³l'na transformats³ya ³ derzhavne upravl³nnya v Ukra¿n³: pol³tiko-pravov³ determ³nanti: Monograf³ya. K.: Vidavnichii d³m ²n Yure, 2003. 495 s.
27. Chebanenko O., Shramovich V., Kovrizhenko D., Kolodyazhna N. Konsol³dovana demokrat³ya: perspektivi dlya Ukra¿ni. K.: Konrad Adenauer Stiftung, 2009. 31 s.
28. Shaio A. Samoogranichenie vlasti (kratkii kurs konstitutsionalizma). M., 1999. 292 s.
29. Yuridichna entsikloped³ya: v 6 t. / redkol.: Yu.S. Shemshuchenko (golova redkol.) ta ³n. K.: Ukr. entsikl., 2001. T. 3. 792 s.
30. Bogdandy A. von, Haussler S., Hanschmann F., Utz R. State-Building, Nation-Building, and Constitutional Politics in Post-Conflict Situations: Conceptual Clarifications and an Appraisal of Different Approach // Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law, Volume 9, 2005, p. 579-613.
31. Constitutionalism: Philosophical Foundation. Ed. by A. Larry. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1998.
32. Decision of Constitutional Conceil of French Republic 92-312 DC of 9 April 1992 // http://www.conseil-constitutionnel. fr/conseil-constitutionnel/root/bank_mm/anglais/a92312dc.pdf
33. Deutsches Staatsrecht. Ein Studienbuch von Reinhold Zippelius und Thomas Wuertenberger. 31. Auflage des von Theodor Maunz begründeten Werkes. München: Verlag C.H. Beck München, 2005. 561 s.
34. Kato, D. 3 Models of Constitutional Continuity: Examining the Notion of Constitutional Continuity via Six Different Historiographies of the Reconstruction Era: Paper presented at the annual meeting of The Midwest Political Science Association, Palmer House Hilton, Chicago, Illinois, Apr 07, 2009 // http://www.allacademic.com/meta/p86466_ index.html
35. Klima, K a kol. Encyklopedia ustavniho prava. Praha: ASPI, a.s., 2007. 542 p.
36. Lijphart Arend. Consociational Democracy // World Politics. Vol. 21, No.2 (Jan., 1969), P. 207 — 225.
37. Opinion of European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission) CDL_REF(2011)012 Concept Paper for the Establishment and Functioning oh the Constitutional Assembly of Ukraine // http://www.venice.coe.int/ webforms/documents/?pdf=CDL-REF(2011)012-e
38. Opinion of European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission) CDL_AD(2013)017 On the Law on National Referendum of Ukraine // http://www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/?pdf=CDL-AD(2013)017-e
39. Stein, Torsten. Demokratische Legetimierung auf supranationaler und internationaler Ebene // Zeitschrift für auslaendischer oeffentliche Rechts und Voelkerrecht, 64 (2004), S. 563-570.
40. Winczorek P. Prawo konstytucyjne Rzeczypospolitej. Warszawa: Liber, 2003. 237 s.
41. Zaitsev A.V. Deliberativnaya demokratiya kak institutsional'nyi dialog vlasti i grazhdanskogo obshchestva // NB: Problemy obshchestva i politiki. 2013. ¹ 5. C. 29-44. URL: http://www.e-notabene.ru/pr/article_689.html
42. Bondar' N.S. Konstitutsionnoe pravosudie i razvitie konstitutsionnoi yurisprudentsii v Rossii: teoriya i praktika // Zhurnal zarubezhnogo zakonodatel'stva i sravnitel'nogo pravovedeniya. 2011. ¹ 4. C. 6-15.
43. Tikhomirov Yu.A. Suverenitet gosudarstv: garantii stabil'nosti i dinamizma // Pravo i politika. 2012. ¹ 3. C. 394-401