Ðóñ Eng Cn Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Actual problems of Russian law
Reference:

Survillo, Y.V. International legal responsibility of states for the harm caused to the environment by dangerous activities

Abstract: It is noted in the article that regularly the right to implement especially dangerous types of activity is usually provided by the state to the state enterprises or private persons under control of the states. The author analyzes the problem of responsibility of states for the fulfillment of guarantees regarding absence of harm to the environment of other states and regions outside the national jurisdiction due to the risky activities within their jurisdiction. The author singles out two main principles (regimes), on which international responsibility may be based: responsibility based upon the proven guilt of a person, and objective responsibility. The author discusses various points of view on which regime should apply when the harm to environment is caused by private companies acting under the state control. It is noted in the article that opinions of the scholars on preferable regimes of responsibility under the international law and their application are divided. The author supports the position that the general standard of international responsibility for the unlawful act in the presence of proven guilt of the person should be amended by inclusion of the special regime of responsibility in this sphere under which strict responsibility for the harm may be applied.


Keywords:

pollution, harm, environment, responsibility of states, international law, jurisprudence, guilt, strict responsibility, dangerous activity.


This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article

This article written in Russian. You can find original text of the article here .
References
1. Ushakov N.A. Osnovaniya mezhdunarodnoy otvetstvennosti gosudarstv. — M., 1983. — 181 s.
2. Ferdross A. Mezhdunarodnoe pravo. Perevod s nemetskogo. Tunkin G.I. (red.). — M., 1959. — 652 c.
3. Akehurst M.B. International Liability for Injurious Consequences Arising out of Acts not Prohibited by International Law // Netherlands Yearbook of International Law. 1985. — P. 3-16.
4. Barboza J. The environment, risk and liability in international law. — Leiden; Boston., 2011. — 204 p.
5. Bedjaoui M. Responsibility of States: Fault and Strict Liability // 10 Encyclopedia of Public International Law. — Amsterdam, 1987. — P. 358-362.
6. Brownlie I. State Responsibility and the International Court of Justice // Issues of State Responsibility before International Judicial Institutions. — Oxford, 2004.
7. Brownly I. Principles of public International law. — Oxford, 2008. — 784 p.
8. De Aréchaga E.J. International responsibility // Manual of Public International Law. — N.Y., 1968. — P. 531-603.
9. Dupuy P.M. La responsabilité internationale des États pour les dommages causés par les pollutions transfrontières Aspects juridiques de la pollution transfrontière. — Paris, 1977. — 309 p.
10. Goldie L.F.E. Liability for damage and the progressive development of International Law // International and Comparative Law Quarterly. 1965. V. 14. — P. 1189-1264.
11. Handl G. State Liability for Accidental Transnational Environmental Damage by Private Persons // The American Journal of International Law. — 1980. — ¹ 3. — P. 525-565.
12. Pisillo Mazzeschi R. Forms of International Responsibility for Environmental Harm // International Responsibility for Environmental Harm. — London; Dordrecht; Boston, 1991. — P. 15-35.
13. Pisillo-Mazzeschi R. The Due Diligence Rule and the Nature of the International Responsibility of States // German Yearbook of International Law, 1992. — P. 9-51.
14. Schachter O. The Greening of International law. In Mélanges Réné-Jean Dupuy. Humanité et droit international. — Paris, 1991. — 382 p.
15. Show M.N. International Law. — Cambridge, 2003. — 1288 p.
16. Stein R.E. Legal Problems and Institutional Aspects of Transfrontier Pollution // OECD, Problems of Transfrontier Pollution. — Paris, 1974. — 316 p