Ðóñ Eng Cn Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Culture and Art
Reference:

Contemporary Chinese Animation Design as a Reinterpretation of Traditional Cultural Connotations Based on Shadow Puppet Theater

Gao Chaomeng

ORCID: 0000-0001-5230-5509

Professor; Animation Department; Qingdao Huanhai University School of Film and Television

672000, Russia, Zabaikalsky Krai, Chita, 125 Babushkina str., office 60

ivanovayuv@gmail.com

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0625.2024.9.71442

EDN:

ESWBSW

Received:

10-08-2024


Published:

06-10-2024


Abstract: The object of the research is modern Chinese animation design and its evolution over the past 70 years. The subject of the research is the potential for rethinking traditional cultural connotations of Chinese shadow theater in modern animation design. The synthesis of the canonical principles of shadow theater with modern animation technologies enhances the expressiveness of cartoons and their ability to convey philosophical, ethical, artistic and technological values. The theoretical analysis of the problem and the practical development of innovative methods of animation design by the author using digital technologies open up new prospects for preserving cultural heritage and finding ways of innovative development of traditional culture. The article uses a comprehensive methodology of cultural studies, art history and computer technology to analyze the processes of rethinking the traditions of shadow puppet theater in modern Chinese animation design. The methods of comparative research, experimental design and expert exchange help to evaluate representative works of contemporary animation in terms of visual style, narrative structure and cultural narrative. The author argues that the processes of enriching contemporary animation with philosophical ideas and ethical imperatives of traditional Chinese culture on the one hand and rebranding traditional culture through animation on the other hand help to preserve the cultural identity of Chinese animated films and enhance their competitiveness in the global market. Careful reinterpretation of cultural connotations enables animated films to preserve and promote traditional virtues such as loyalty, filial piety and courage in figurative form. On the artistic level, Chinese animation design draws on the aesthetics of traditional art, classical painting and calligraphy, and humorous storytelling, combining them into a unique visual style. The latest technologies enrich animation design and open up new possibilities for a modern interpretation of traditional Chinese culture.


Keywords:

China, tradition culture, culture connotation, three-dimensional animation, animation design, cultural heritage, shadow play, moral imperatives, digital technology, motion capture

This article is automatically translated. You can find original text of the article here.

Introduction

Chinese traditional culture has a long history and rich content that attracts the attention of the whole world. The founder of modern Chinese literature, Lu Xin, believed that everything national is also global. The "Great Chinese Dream" of the rebirth of the nation implies the careful preservation of traditional culture, which contributes to the consolidation of cultural diversity in the unifying reality of globalization. Therefore, the study of the interaction of traditional culture and innovative processes in society is of great relevance for China and other countries studying this instructive experience.

The object of the study is modern animation design in China and its evolution over the past 70 years. The subject of the study is the potential of reinterpretation of traditional cultural connotations of Chinese shadow theater in modern animation design. The main objectives of the research include the analysis of ways to integrate traditional culture in animation design in different historical periods and to identify the possibilities of synthesizing the canonical principles of shadow theater with modern animation technologies.

Many authentic forms have been formed in the traditional art of China, including guohua painting, calligraphy, carved seals, shadow theater, jianzhi papercutting art, porcelain, embroidery and others. All of them demonstrate the artistic skills, aesthetic ideals and cultural wealth of the Chinese nation. The article by Wang Tong and Li Jian "Research and practice of popular science animation in the context of Chinese traditional culture and art" examines the process of interaction between traditions and innovations in Chinese art using the example of a short film about the intangible cultural heritage of Shaanxi Province "The Game of Shadows of Hua County". The authors note: "Thanks to the use of modern animation technologies, traditional elements have received a new life." [1]. Being a relatively new art form, modern Chinese animation has become an important way to preserve traditional culture, a key tool for its creative transformation and innovative development.

Shadow theater has been one of the most popular folk entertainment and has existed for thousands of years in many countries, including China, Turkey, Indonesia, Malaysia, Nepal, India, Iran, Thailand. Shadow puppet theater in China ("shadow play") is an ancient form of stage performative art, as well as an artistic text with a rich cultural basis. The plots of the performances were based on folk epics and customs, legends, legends, classical literary works, therefore the shadow theater was an important channel for the transmission of historical knowledge and cultural heritage.

The main props of the shadow theater include a white translucent screen, a lamp and flat reed puppets. Traditional shadow doll production methods involve high skill in material preparation, carving, coloring, joining parts and final assembly of the doll. Cow or donkey skin is used as the starting material for shadow dolls, which is soaked, dehydrated and thinned to achieve uniformity and transparency. The artists decorate the details with exquisite patterns that reveal the psychology of the character and the plot of the story. When coloring, natural or synthetic pigments are used, which retain brightness for a long time. Sometimes the puppets are additionally decorated with scraps of silk, so that the shadows become colored. At the final stage of production, the carved parts are connected with ropes, wooden slats or wire, forming a finished shadow puppet character or decoration with flexibility and strength. The movable design of the dolls made it possible to convey the complex movements of the characters.

Fig. 1. The work of the Chinese puppet Theater artists behind the screen during the performance.

The shadow play of the traditional shadow theater can be considered the oldest prototype of animation in the history of mankind, which overcame the static of graphic images by artistic means. In Europe, it was only in the XV century that the camera obscura became widespread, projecting some image onto the screen. The invention of the "magic lantern" probably belongs to the Dutch scientist Christian Huygens. In 1779, Jean-Paul Marat used a "solar microscope" in his speeches, a version of a magic lantern that allowed objects to be projected in color and movement. The early history of European animation ends with the invention of the celluloid base for film (1888), while the early history of Chinese animation, thanks to the traditional shadow theater, can be dated back to the first millennium BC, because its basic principle (image projection on the screen) was known in Ancient China. As an important area of traditional culture, shadow puppet theater serves as a source of inspiration for modern animation and gives it a deep subtext, including various elements of cultural heritage.

Chinese animation gets a new development in the twentieth century. The book "The History of Chinese Animation" edited by Sun Lijun, Dean of the Animation School of the Beijing Film Academy [2] examines the process of formation of Chinese animated cinema from the 1920s to the beginning of the XXI century, in which the authors identify four significant periods: 1949-1978. (beginning), 1979-1988. (development), 1989-1999 (maturity) and 2000 – present (modernization). The book provides a detailed description of each of these periods, analyzes the features of the development process, representative works and aesthetic concepts of Chinese animation. The authors rightly see one of the ways to revive the vitality of traditional culture in bringing archetypal cultural connotations to animation design, creating new impulses for the development of animation art. This idea, with different accents, sounds like a refrain in all scientific research by Chinese authors on this topic.

Modern processes in Chinese animation attract the attention of many researchers in China. Thus, Wang Xiangyu in his work investigated the process of creating digital animation of shadow puppets from the point of view of innovations in the field of intangible cultural heritage [3]. He noted that thanks to digital animation technologies, traditional elements of shadow puppet theater can be presented in a completely new form, which not only enriches the expressiveness of animation art, but also expands the channels of dissemination of intangible cultural heritage. The digital animation work "Shadow Legend" mentioned by Wang Xiangyu combines the art of traditional shadow puppet theater with modern animation technologies to update the audiovisual characteristics of the works.

Chen Jiahui's research discusses the problems of transferring the legacy of the traditional culture of shadow puppet theater into digital form [4]. The author emphasizes that digitization is not only a way to protect and record traditional art forms, but also an innovative attempt to inherit and develop them. Using the example of a modern animated film in the style of shadow puppet theater "The Dream of Dunhuang", Chen Jiahui demonstrates how digital technologies help to reproduce the emotional impact of classical shadow puppet theater and adapt it to the aesthetic needs of a modern audience of the Internet era, when the presentation of information becomes more diverse, imaginative, dynamic, interactive.

Jin Minglei's research provides another compelling example of studying the integration of animation and traditional culture [5]. Analyzing the changing attitudes of college students towards traditional Chinese culture after 2000, he emphasizes the importance of cultural trust in modern society. Jin Minglei cites the animated film directed by Liang Xuan and Zhang Chun "Big Fish and Begonia" (2016) as a good example. The film is based on ancient Chinese treatises (including "Zhuangzi", "The Book of Mountains and Seas") and myths. The incorporation and reinterpretation of Chinese cultural heritage (visuals, plot and issues) has made this film popular not only in China, but also around the world. Animation breaks down the stage limitations of shadow puppetry, implements more flexible and smooth movements, uses sound effects and background music to enhance emotional impact, giving new life to ancient traditions.

Yang Yahui, based on the analysis of articles in the magazine "Cinema and Television", also reconstructs the perception of traditional culture in Chinese animation [6], which skillfully includes elements of religious beliefs and philosophical ideas about the need for harmony between man, the socio-natural environment and the universe as a whole. One of the illustrative examples was the animated film "Nezha: the Birth of the Devil" (2019), which not only achieved great success at the box office, but also influenced modern Chinese culture. The mythological protection deity Nezha has been revered in China for more than a thousand years and is one of the most formidable and mysterious Chinese gods. In the film, this mythological character is successfully included in the actual plot, and modern visualization methods give a new reading to traditional stories. The modification of Nezhi's image and the innovative reinterpretation of his weapons (the Qiankun Fire Circle and the Red Ribbon of Hong Tianling) reflect the filmmakers' deep understanding of and respect for traditional culture: the golden color of the Qiankun circle symbolizes dignity and power, and the red color of the Hong Tianling ribbon symbolizes passion and courage.

Fig. 2. The poster of the film "Nezha: the Birth of the devil", which depicts the main character and his weapon – Qiankun Fire circles and Hong Tianling red ribbon. Image source: https://img2.baidu.com/it/u=625660996 ,1477177033&fm=253&fmt=auto&app=138&f=JPEG?w=800&h=11

Speaking about the research results of Chinese scientists, we should not forget that similar problems attract the attention of foreign authors. A detailed analysis of their works is beyond the scope of our article, but as representative examples we can mention the fundamental publications of D. Bendazzi [7] and N. G. Krivuli [8].

The monograph of the Italian animation historian Giannalberto Bendazzi (1946-2021) "Animation: a World History" (2015) is based on the idea that animation is an art form that deserves its place in science. Bendazzi analyzes animation in Russia, Africa, Latin America and other regions and introduces readers to little-known but worthy authors from all major regions of the world (more than 90 countries), covering the history of animation production on each continent for three centuries.

N. G. Krivuli's fundamental research "Animatology: The Evolution of World Animatographs" (2012) and her subsequent monographs are devoted to the comprehensive study of theoretical and empirical problems of animation, including the identification of patterns of its evolution, interrelation with social life, art and culture. The author of the term "animatology" (the name of the scientific direction proposed by her) evaluates the variety of artistic and stylistic concepts in animation, the form and content of an animated work, changes in animation and screen culture caused by the advent of digital technologies. Thus, the modern art of animation occupies an important place in the life of society, and its multidimensional research has become an urgent topic in cultural studies of scientists from different countries.

Integration of traditional culture in animation design in different historical periods

The connotations of traditional culture are a concentrated reflection of the cultural characteristics of a certain stage in the history of the people. Today, as China's traditional culture is constantly being enriched and reinterpreted, the combination of animation design and traditional shadow theater creates new opportunities for development. In their study "Applied Research on the Combination of Digital Technology and the Art of Shadow Play", Dong Xiaoli and Zhang Dongxue proposed innovative ways to use digital technology to revive the art of shadow play. They believe that "digital media can overcome the limitations of space and time, allowing more people to understand and appreciate this unique art form"[9]. In the context of global cultural exchange, animation design actively absorbs the essence of traditional culture in the selection of themes and the embodiment of connotations of traditional culture in terms of form, artistic concept and visual design. This marks a conscious return of animation art to subjectivity – an open expression of the author's worldview and artistic taste. Let's look at some examples of the use of cultural connotations in animation design.

(1) The development of the artistic concept of traditional Chinese ink painting in animation

Ink painting, in which water and ink form a unique artistic language, holds a special place in traditional Chinese culture. Modern animation uses ink drawing in an innovative way, giving new life to the drawing, color and artistic concept in dynamics, animating static ink-drawn images on the screen. The animation shows the color change of ink fills from thick and heavy to light and translucent, with rich and varied visual effects. Combining modern aesthetics with the needs of animation, ink and watercolor are flexibly transformed to give viewers aesthetic pleasure and evoke historical and cultural resonance. Qu Peng and Yang Baoting [10] mentioned in their article "The breakthrough and change of traditional IP films of the new "Chinese animation school"" that the cartoon "Little Tadpoles are looking for Mom" (小,, 1960, Art Director: Te Wei) is the first ink animation based on Qi paintings Baishi (1864-1957) was a great Chinese artist, classic of Guohua, winner of the Peace Prize.

Qi Baishi believed that the essence of painting, the secret of mastery, is the balance of similarity and dissimilarity of nature and its depiction in the painting, since complete similarity is vulgar, and dissimilarity is deception. Using the example of the movement of tadpoles, the film conveys this aesthetic concept of a balance "between similarity and dissimilarity." The film is drawn in the traditional Chinese painting style of "Xie yi" (sweeping and concise painting focusing on conveying an idea), opposed to the manner of "Gong bi" ("careful brush"). The difference between them for the European viewer vaguely resembles the ratio of impressionism and photorealism. The "similarity" in the animated film "Little Tadpoles are looking for Mom" is expressed in the anatomical truthfulness of the depicted animals – frogs, crabs, turtles and others, and the "dissimilarity" – in the conventionality of the image of a reservoir in which water is represented in the traditions of Gohua as an empty space of the picture. The film opened a new era of animation expressiveness, won international recognition and gave a new breath to the art of animation.

(2) Displaying the humorous style of shadow theater in animation art

Shadow puppet theater, as a kind of folk art with a long history, is a living legacy of traditional culture due to its special way of interacting light and shadow, as well as methods of narration, portrayal of characters, storylines, plastics, and other artistic elements. As Li Shunli noted in his article "The traditional cultural Nature of Chinese Animation Design" [11], China's first shadow puppet animation "Pig Bazze Eats Watermelon" (猪八戒吃西西, 1958, Wang Guchan) included funny plot moves and comical movements of the characters in the style of shadow theater, bringing expressiveness and visual impressions to animation art. The cartoon showed that modern animation is able to continue using the artistic techniques of shadow puppet theater and improve its motives, for example, with the help of new technologies of three-dimensional animation.

The animated film "Honest Official Li Jian" (2018, Shanghai Institute of Visual Arts) combines three elements of intangible cultural heritage: shadow puppet theater, traditional opera accompanied by gong and drum, and ink drawing animation. The film uses updated drawing techniques. Li Jian (1440-1505) was a real historical figure who lived in Sijing. According to the story, Li Jian, as an expert in mathematics, was invited to Beijing to help the imperial court with the audit of finances. In the process of checking accounts, he was not afraid of threats and in three years brought order to the judicial accounting department, confiscating the ill-gotten wealth of corrupt officials. Despite the fact that the film will raise a serious topic of the fight against corruption, the friendly local accent of the actors, slightly humorous remarks and grotesque characterizations of the characters give the performance a local flavor and a humorous touch. Thanks to this, the film popularized shadow puppet theater among a wide audience and demonstrated the ageless charm of traditional art.

(3) Abstract ethnic design style in animation art

Chen Chen in his article "The study of the application of elements of folk art in the design of characters in animated films" [12] proves that Chinese traditional decorative art with its rich artistic forms and deep cultural connotations is a complex system, the main principles of which are the principles of symmetry, harmony, balance. Based on decorative art, modern animation art can not only present ethnic decorative techniques, but also implement traditional visual style in character design and reveal allegorical meaning. Ye Jinhui and Yin Jun in their article "A brief analysis of the application of traditional elements in the design of character modeling in Destruction in Heaven" [13] conclude that the artistic style of the animated film Destruction in Heaven is largely borrowed from classical Dunhuang frescoes and folk New Year paintings. Combining the stylization of characters under murals and elements of the art of splint painting in animation art creates visual effects of formal and allegorical beauty. Thanks to this transformation, the shadow puppet theater has not only been updated in form, but also acquired a connection with a modern audience in terms of connotation. The classical principles of shadow theater (its cultural connotations, narrative rhythm, aesthetics of silhouettes, drawing of characters) were carefully transferred to the space of the cartoon, enriching the cultural meaning and artistic identity of the work.

Figure 3. A frame from the animated film "Sun Wukong fights Bai Gujing three times", the production of which was directed by the author of the article.

Strategies and ways to synthesize the art of shadow theater with modern animation technologies

Combining the traditions of shadow theater and modern animation technologies allowed not only to update the form of ancient art, but also to strengthen the connection with a modern audience. In her article "Research on the Application of shadow design in digital animation", Sun Lijun [14] deeply explored the characteristics of shadow dolls in digital animation design. She noted: "The use of digital technologies has not only made the production and distribution of shadow puppet theater more convenient and efficient, but also significantly expanded its audience and influence." This highlights the important role of digital animation in the inheritance and popularization of traditional shadow puppet theater and opens up new perspectives and methods for modern animation design. The use of modern animation technologies such as 3D modeling and motion capture provides a new platform for traditional elements of shadow puppetry, making it more attractive and competitive in cultural exchange.

Figure 4. Work on character movement using modern computer technology. From the work experience of the author of the article.

(1) Animated design of shadow puppet elements

The essence of incorporating shadow puppet elements into modern animation design is to accurately convey the stylistics of their traditional forms and dynamic characteristics and innovatively enrich this heritage. With the help of computer graphics technologies, the beauty of shadow dolls' silhouettes is preserved, the style is updated, the accuracy of color rendition and modeling details are improved, animated characters become more vivid and realistic. The design goes beyond imitation, using modern technologies to animate shadow puppets, adding smoothness of movement, brightness of emotions, and historical authenticity to them. This provides a new digital life to traditional images. Exquisitely selected shades of light and shadow enhance the visual impact on the viewer, expand the means of expression of the art of shadow puppet theater.

Figure 5. The stages of character creation. From the work experience of the author of the article.

(2) Innovative methods of using three-dimensional special effects technology

Exploring the integration of shadow puppet theater and modern animation, we can refer to the description of creative techniques of modern animated films in Ye Feng's article "Research on the processes of creating American three-dimensional animated cinema" [15]. With the help of 3D modeling technology, flat images of a shadow puppet theater can be turned into three-dimensional characters. By adding various animated special effects, such as fire and smoke, the audience can significantly enhance the feeling of involvement in the action on the screen. Yuan Shengchao [16] emphasizes in his article that motion capture technology allows you to capture the details of the performance of shadow theater artists and make the movements of animated characters more convincing. Modern animation combines interactive storytelling and multimedia, allowing viewers to delve deeply into the history of shadow puppet theater. These innovative techniques also expand the expressiveness of animation art and provide new opportunities for inheriting traditional culture.

(3) Modern interpretation of traditional cultural overtones

Inheriting the traditional cultural connotations of shadow puppetry, modern animation design should also focus on interpreting and spreading its modern values. Xie Yannan [17] in his article notes that a deep study of the stories, characters and moral concepts underlying shadow puppet theater gives animated films a deeper cultural authenticity. Modern interpretation is not a literal copying of traditional culture, but its innovative reinterpretation in a modern social context, taking into account the aesthetic, psychological and existential needs of the audience. Interactive projects, such as animated games and virtual reality, allow young people to more actively explore and assimilate the values of traditional culture, presented in a language they understand.

Conclusion

In the 21st century, China's animation industry is thriving successfully thanks to the development of politics, capital and technology. The key to success is a deep study of traditional culture, including its regional forms. An interdisciplinary analysis of the cultural significance of shadow puppet theater and its application in modern animation design proves that the synthesis of elements of shadow puppet theater and modern animation enhances the expressiveness of cartoons and successfully translates moral, artistic and technological values. Careful reinterpretation of cultural connotations makes it possible to preserve and promote in the figurative form of animated films such traditional virtues as loyalty, filial piety, bravery, which helps the younger generation to appreciate the historical significance of the classical cultural heritage. At the artistic level, Chinese animation design relies on the aesthetics of traditional art, the classics of painting and calligraphy, and the humorous presentation of subjects, combining them into a unique visual style. The latest technologies (three-dimensional animation, motion capture, special effects, and others) enrich animation design and open up new ways for modern interpretation of Chinese traditional culture and presentation of its wisdom and originality to the whole world. The market potential of the talented reinterpretation of traditional cultural elements in modern animation design ensures the commercialization of cultural products, promotes the development of cultural industries, increasing cultural trust, social and cultural diversity. Thanks to modern animation, traditional cultural forms can transcend linguistic and geographical boundaries and attract a wider international audience.

The article was the result not only of the author's scientific research, but also of his many years of practical experience in creating animated films that have been highly appreciated in China and abroad. Further research on this issue may be aimed at a comparative study of various schools of animation in China; analysis of the features of animation art of various ethnic groups in China; evaluation of future animated films that innovatively interpret the connotations of ancient Chinese culture, including shadow puppet theater.

References
1. Wang, Tong & Li, Jian. (2023). Research and practice of popular science animation in the context of Chinese traditional culture and art: Taking the Shaanxi intangible cultural heritage themed animation short film "Huaxian Shadow Play" as an example. Art Education Research, 3, 91-93.
2. Sun, Lijun. (Ed.). (2011). History of Chinese Animation. Beijing, China: Commercial Publishing House.
3. Wang, Xiangyu. (2023). Research on digital animation design of shadow puppets from the perspective of intangible cultural heritage innovation. Shoe Crafts and Design, 23, 36-38.
4. Chen, Jiahui. (2023). Digital expression of folk art: A brief discussion on the inheritance of traditional cultural shadow puppetry. Journal of Cultural Studies, 9, 34-37.
5. Jin, Minglei. (2019). Cultural confidence enhancement and the impact of Internet culture: Based on the perspective of post-00 college students’ identification with China’s excellent traditional culture. Journal of Dali University, 3, 78-83.
6. Yang, Yahui. (2021). Research on the application of Chinese traditional culture in domestic animated films. Western Radio and Television, 17, 140-145.
7. Giannalberto Bendazzi. (2015). Animation: A World History: Volume I: Foundations - The Golden Age. London, England: CRC Press.
8. Krivulya, N. G. (2012) Animatologiya: evolyuciya mirovyh animatografij: [v 2 ch.]. Moskva: Ametist.
9. Dong, Xiaoli & Zhang, Dongxue. (2023). Application research of digital technology combined with shadow puppet art. Modern Information Technology, 23, 166-170.
10. Qu, Peng & Yang, Baoting. (2024). Breakthrough and Reshaping of Traditional IP Films by the New “Chinese Animation School”. Film Literature, 8, 49-54.
11. Li, Shunli. (2013). Traditional Cultural Characteristics of Chinese Animation Action Design, Master's Degree Thesis, South China University of Technology. Retrieved from https://kns.cnki.net/KCMS/detail/detail.aspx?dbname=CMFD201401&filename=1013317534.nh
12. Chen, Chen. (2023). Research on the application of folk art elements in animation film character design. Shanghai Packaging, 01, 108-110.
13. Ye, Jinhui & Yin, Jun. (2017). A brief analysis of the application of traditional elements in character modeling design in "Havoc in Heaven". Art and Technology, 1, 133.
14. Sun, Lijun. (2020). Research on the application of shadow puppet design in digital animation art. Tomorrow's Fashion, 9, 34-35.
15. Ye, Feng. (2015), A Study on the Making of American 3D Modeling of Animated Films. Beijing, China: China Film Publishing House.
16. Yuan, Shengchao. (2024). Digital animation inheritance strategy of Tangshan shadow puppet art under new media. Popular Literature and Art, 9, 26-28.
17. Xie, Yannan. (2013). Research on the current situation and development of the combination of shadow puppet art and animation, Master's thesis, Shenyang Normal University. Retrieved from https://kns.cnki.net/KCMS/detail/detail.aspx?dbname=CMFD201302&filename=1013211853.nh

First Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The subject of the research in the article submitted for publication in the journal Culture and Art, as the author outlined in the title ("Modern animation design as a reinterpretation of traditional cultural connotations based on shadow theater materials"), is the reinterpretation of traditional cultural connotations of Chinese shadow theater (in the object) in the modern animation design of Chinese animators. However, the reader has to guess for the author that we are talking exclusively about the work of Chinese animators, which is reflected in the author's sample of empirical material. At the same time, it is not entirely clear which historical period of the existence of Chinese animation (animated films) the author considers modern. In particular, the author mentions, although poorly attributed, as the first "in my country" (apparently in China) cartoon with shadow puppets "Zhu Bazie eats a watermelon", referring, in all likelihood, to the short film 猪八戒吃るる 1958, shot at the Shanghai Animation Film Studio by Wang Laimin and Wang Guchang (aka "Piggy eats watermelon", aka "Mr. Pig eats watermelon"). Whether the historical period from 1958 to the current 2024 should be considered modern, the author is silent, as well as generally does not define the historical boundaries of the existence of animation in China. In addition, as the reviewer notes, the shadow play of the traditional Chinese shadow theater can in principle be considered the oldest prototype of animation in the history of mankind, which overcame the static of graphic images by artistic means. In Europe, it was only in the XVI century that the pinhole camera, which assumes the projection of some image onto the screen, became widespread, and only with the invention of the celluloid base for film (1888), the early history of European animation ended, while thanks to the traditional shadow theater, the early history of Chinese animation can be dated by analogy with the European one from about the first millennium After all, the basic principle (projection of an image onto a screen) was already known in Ancient China. In this regard, the reviewer recommends that the author clarify the chronological framework of the planned study in order to avoid discrepancies. In the goal setting of the study, the author clarifies that he is interested in building an academic (apparently theoretical) foundation that opens up new perspectives for understanding the heritage and development of Chinese traditional culture in the modern era, probably, as indicated in the title, using the example of shadow theater. This goal has not been fully achieved in the presented study: out of the list of references listed in the bibliography, only 4 works by Chinese scientists are mentioned in the text. In addition, the author's focus exclusively on Chinese literature makes it doubtful that the author has achieved universal scientific knowledge as a planned result. To do this, it is necessary to compare the achievements of Chinese science with the thematically similar theoretical experience of Russian, European and other scientists. The author's statement that "The views and ideas of this article are formed on the basis of the author's long-term practical experience and in-depth research of many documents of the Chinese national knowledge infrastructure" is poorly reasoned: the text of the article does not present the "Chinese national knowledge infrastructure" reinterpretation of traditional cultural connotations of Chinese shadow theater in modern animation design, neither exclusively by Chinese animators, nor in the context of the world experience of studying animated films. It is hard to believe that the four Chinese theorists mentioned by the author reveal the "Chinese national knowledge infrastructure" in a sufficiently relevant way. Such a brief review of the literature is difficult to consider systematic or analytical, since it is quite obvious that it is based not on a complex thematic, but on a random and far from complete selection of objects of analysis (scientific literature). In general, if we exclude from attention the numerous semantic repetitions common in the text about the importance of animation design in the spirit of traditional Chinese culture, the author partially approached his goal by identifying certain, obviously the most important areas of planned research: inheritance of the virtues of traditional culture, enrichment of modern animation with philosophical meanings of traditional culture, the aspect of rebranding through animation of traditional Chinese culture and, in particular, the shadow theater, the issues of preserving the cultural identity of Chinese animation products and the related aspect of the competitiveness of Chinese animation in the world market. The reviewer notes that the attempt to identify various directions of a comprehensive study of the reinterpretation of traditional cultural connotations of Chinese shadow theater in modern animation design is the strong side of the text submitted for review, in contrast to practically unexplored methodological issues (setting specific tasks and developing methods for solving them). Thus, the stated subject of the study has not been considered by the author, but it is sufficiently comprehensively problematized. The very formulation of the problem of studying the potential of animation design, based on the task of reinterpreting the traditional cultural connotations of Chinese shadow theater, is worthy of theoretical attention. The research methodology is based, in all probability, on the rich practical experience accumulated by the author. The comparison of Japanese anime culture with the potential of reinterpretation of traditional cultural connotations of Chinese shadow theater in modern animation design reveals the significant heuristic potential of the aspect of preservation and promotion of the intangible cultural heritage of traditional Chinese culture problematized by the author. The author explains the relevance of the chosen topic by saying that animation technologies are already being used to preserve the culture and aesthetics of shadow puppet theater, as well as an innovative interpretation of classic stories, characters and folk customs. Therefore, the study of the designated topic has both theoretical and practical significance. The scientific novelty of the study, which consists in setting the problem of studying the potential of reinterpretation of traditional cultural connotations of Chinese shadow theater in modern animation design, deserves theoretical attention.
The style of the text, in the opinion of the reviewer, needs to be improved: 1) semantic repetitions and poorly reasoned emotional judgments regarding the importance of preserving traditional culture should be avoided (to clarify the author's position, it is enough to state this once); 2) the text needs literary proofreading by a native Russian speaker specializing in art history or cultural studies of animation (animation), since there are individual expressions that make it difficult to read the author's thoughts (for example, "In his research, Wang Xiangyu has deeply researched", "and gives animation a deep cultural heritage in terms of moral concepts", "we need to deeply explore the integration of traditional cultural spirit", "This is not only a step forward in animation design, but also the practice of innovative use of traditional culture, which will demonstrate the charm of Chinese cultural and artistic achievements on the world stage", "to bring a deep traditional cultural connotation to the modern design of animation art and create a new era of development of modern animation art. the situation ...", "to avoid formalization [apparently formalism] and strive for harmony and unity", etc.); 3) a fragment of the text devoted to traditional methods of making dolls for the shadow theater is not entirely clear; the meaning of this argument should be clarified or even leave this fragment for the next publication of a more practical nature; 4) everything abbreviations should be deciphered at the first mention, and if they occur once, they should be avoided; 5) the purpose of the fragment "(1) Animation design of shadow puppet elements" is completely unclear. In general, the text looks like a poorly edited machine translation from another language: the Russian reader is not obliged to think out for the author the merits of his work hidden by a bad translation. The structure of the article can be significantly improved, especially considering the obvious linguistic difficulties of the author. A clear presentation of the research program in the introductory part of the article will greatly simplify the understanding of the author's thought (the problem and its relevance, the goal and the scientific and cognitive tasks accompanying its achievement, the scientific methods used by the author to solve the tasks), following in the analytical part a strict logical sequence of tasks with intermediate conclusions based on the results of solving each task, generalization of the results achieved in the final conclusion and the emerging prospects for further research based on the result presented in the article. The bibliography, as noted above, is not fully involved in the research. Besides. the purpose of searching for theoretical ("academic") grounds for studying the potential of reinterpretation of traditional cultural connotations of Chinese shadow theater in modern animation design requires a more thorough study of existing scientific approaches going beyond the limited scope of exclusively Chinese science (especially since the author sets the ambitious task of developing a methodology to enhance the competitiveness of Chinese animation design in the international market. All scientific works and sources indicated in the bibliography should be mentioned in the text of the article. The style of literature description in the bibliographic list needs to be adjusted to meet the requirements of the editorial board and GOST. The appeal to the opponents is correct, but, given the methodological nature of the planned publication, it is extremely insufficient. In the reviewer's opinion, the author's analysis of scientific literature lacks emphasis on methodological principles, which allow him to confidently declare the possibility and expediency of reinterpreting the traditional cultural connotations of Chinese shadow theater in modern animation design. The article is certainly of interest to the readership of the magazine "Culture and Art", but the author should significantly work on the transparency and consistency of the structure of the presentation of the material and the quality of the language of its presentation.

Second Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The author independently determined the subject of the article "Modern Chinese animation design as a reinterpretation of traditional cultural connotations based on the materials of the shadow puppet theater": "The object of research is modern animation design in China and its evolution over the past 70 years. The subject of the study is the potential of reinterpretation of traditional cultural connotations of Chinese shadow theater in modern animation design." The research methodology is more than diverse and includes comparative historical, analytical, descriptive, etc. methods. The relevance of the article is extremely high, especially in the light of the increased interest of the modern scientific community in the history and culture of the East. The author confirms this idea: "Chinese traditional culture has a long history and rich content that attracts the attention of the whole world." The scientific novelty of the work is also beyond doubt, as well as its practical benefits. The researcher emphasizes: "The article was the result not only of the author's scientific research, but also of his many years of practical experience in creating animated films that have been highly appreciated in China and abroad. Further research on this issue may be aimed at a comparative study of various schools of animation in China; an analysis of the features of animation art of various ethnic groups in China; an assessment of future animated films that innovatively interpret the connotations of ancient Chinese culture, including shadow puppet theater." In our opinion, the author's scientific research may well be continued in a number of other studies. We have before us a very worthy scientific study in which the style, structure and content fully meet the requirements for articles of this kind. It is characterized by an abundance of useful information and important conclusions. The article is clearly and logically structured, has 3 parts: introduction, main part and conclusions (conclusion). The researcher titled each part of the main text: "The integration of traditional culture in animation design in different historical periods: (1) The development of the artistic concept of traditional Chinese ink painting in animation; (2) The display of the humorous stylistics of shadow theater in animation art; (3) The abstract style of ethnic design in animation art; Strategies and ways of art synthesis shadow theater with modern animation technologies: (1) Animated design of shadow puppet elements; (2) Innovative methods of using three-dimensional special effects technology; (3) A modern interpretation of the traditional cultural subtext." Let's focus on a number of positive aspects of the study. The author gives a meaningful description of the shadow theater in the introduction: "The main props of the shadow theater include a white translucent screen, a lamp and flat reed puppets. Traditional shadow doll production methods involve high skill in material preparation, carving, coloring, joining parts and final assembly of the doll. Cow or donkey skin is used as the starting material for shadow dolls, which is soaked, dehydrated and thinned to achieve uniformity and transparency. The artists decorate the details with exquisite patterns that reveal the psychology of the character and the plot of the story. When coloring, natural or synthetic pigments are used, which retain brightness for a long time. Sometimes the puppets are additionally decorated with scraps of silk, so that the shadows become colored." Next, the researcher describes in detail the sources that contain information on the issues he studies. The article is replete with a number of detailed examples: "One of the illustrative examples was the animated film "Nezha: the Birth of the Devil" (2019), which not only achieved great success at the box office, but also influenced modern Chinese culture. The mythological protection deity Nezha has been revered in China for more than a thousand years and is one of the most formidable and mysterious Chinese gods. In the film, this mythological character is successfully included in the actual plot, and modern visualization methods give a new reading to traditional stories. The modification of Nezhi's image and the innovative reinterpretation of his weapons (the Qiankun Fire Circle and the Red Ribbon of Hong Tianling) reflect the filmmakers' deep understanding of and respect for traditional culture: the golden color of the Qiankun circle symbolizes dignity and power, and the red color of the Hong Tianling ribbon symbolizes passion and courage. It is highly commendable that the author provided the work with a number of drawings: "The work of the artists of the Chinese puppet theater behind the screen during the performance; A frame from the animated film "Sun Wukong fights three times with Bai Gujing", the production of which was directed by the author of the article,"etc. The bibliography of the study is extensive, includes the main, mostly foreign, sources on the topic, and is designed correctly. The appeal to opponents is quite sufficient and is not just made at a decent professional level, but it is appropriate to say that the author enters into creative interaction with opponents. The conclusions, as we have already noted, are serious and extensive, here are just a part of them: "In the 21st century, China's animation industry is successfully flourishing thanks to the development of politics, capital and technology. The key to success is a deep study of traditional culture, including its regional forms. An interdisciplinary analysis of the cultural significance of shadow puppet theater and its application in modern animation design proves that the synthesis of elements of shadow puppet theater and modern animation enhances the expressiveness of cartoons and successfully translates moral, artistic and technological values. Careful reinterpretation of cultural connotations makes it possible to preserve and promote in the figurative form of animated films such traditional virtues as loyalty, filial piety, bravery, which helps the younger generation to appreciate the historical significance of the classical cultural heritage. At the artistic level, Chinese animation design relies on the aesthetics of traditional art, the classics of painting and calligraphy, and the humorous presentation of subjects, combining them into a unique visual style." In our opinion, the article will be of great importance for a diverse readership - artists and other creators of animated films, students and teachers, historians, art historians, etc., as well as all those who are interested in issues of art and international cultural cooperation.