Ðóñ Eng Cn Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Culture and Art
Reference:

Skorokhodova T.G. Dialogic Hermeneutics as a Method of Understanding the Other in the Bengal Renaissance

Abstract: Used by the Bengal Renaissance thinkers in the process of understanding of Other, a method of dialogical hermeneutics is reconstructed in the article. The method is described as a mental phenomenon and general way of understanding the Other, the latter is being represented by the Western culture and its representatives. The generality of the method depends on both circumstances of colonial urban society and educational and scientific development in India and general aspiration to revive as well as general aspiration of Bengal intellectuals to revive and develop India. Admitting the presence of some general method of understanding, the author reconstructs the method based on the phenomenological approach and analysis of texts created by the key persons of the epoch. The methodology helps to present a structure and peculiarities of the process of understaning as well as working of dialogic hermeneutics. Dialogic hermeneutics is described as a trajectory of the thought moving that proceeds from the aspiration to find universal grounds behind differences of cultures and points of contacts and similarity of traditions, and then it moves from an exposing the deep similarity to an understanding of differences as a result of many-sides of life. This method opened new ways of self-cognition for Indian culture and created “understanding as an event” (M. Buber) owing to which India opened herself to interaction with the modern world.


Keywords:

liberalism, hermeneutics, method of understanding, understanding of the Other, the Bengal Renaissance, Indian philosophy, Indian culture, East–West dialogue, conservatism, self-cognition of culture


This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article

This article written in Russian. You can find original text of the article here .
References
1. Averintsev S. S. Svyaz' vremen. Kiev, 2005.
2. Aurobindo Shri. Dukhovnoe vozrozhdenie. Sochineniya na bengali. SPb., 2005.
3. Buber M. Dva obraza very. M., 1999.
4. Gadamer G. G. Aktual'nost' prekrasnogo. M., 1991.
5. Gesse G. Stepnoy volk. Igra v biser. M., 2003.
6. Pomerants G. S., Mirkina Z. N. V teni Vavilonskoy bashni. 2-e izd. M., 2012.
7. Rashkovskiy E. B. Nauchnoe znanie, instituty nauki i intelligentsiya v stranakh Vostoka XIX–XX vv. M., 1990.
8. Skorokhodova T. G. Anglofil'stvo bengal'skikh intellektualov: put' k sebe ot priznaniya Drugogo // Voprosy filosofii. 2013. ¹ 6. S. 118–128.
9. Skorokhodova T. G. Bengal'skoe Vozrozhdenie. Ocherki istorii sotsiokul'turnogo sinteza v indiyskoy filosofskoy mysli Novogo vremeni. SPb., 2008.
10. Skorokhodova T. G. Drugoy v traditsii induizma i filosofii Bengal'skogo Vozrozhdeniya: opyt sopostavleniya // Zografskiy sbornik. Vyp. 3. Otv. red. Ya. V. Vasil'kov. SPb.: MAE RAN, 2013. S. 191–207.
11. Skorokhodova T. G. “Palomnichestvo v stranu Zapada” v opyte mysliteley Bengal'skogo Renessansa // Voprosy filosofii. 2011. ¹ 11. S. 163–173.
12. Skorokhodova T. G. Rammokhan Ray, rodonachal'nik Bengal'skogo Vozrozhdeniya. SPb., 2008.
13. Tagor R. Osoznanie istiny // Kur'er YuNESKO. 1994. Mart. S. 38–39.
14. Tagor R. Sobranie sochineniy v 12 tt. / Per. s beng. i angl. M., 1961–1965.
15. Awakening in Bengal in the Early Nineteenth Century. Selected Documents / Ed. by G. Chattopadhyaya. Calcutta, 1965.
16. Banerjea Krishna Mohun. Dialogues on the Hindu Philosophy. L.–Edinburgh, 1861.
17. Bankim‘s Hinduism. An Anthology of Writing by Bankimchandra Chattopaddhyay. Ed. by. Amiya P. Sen. New Delhi, 2011.
18. Chaudhuri N. Autobiography of Unknown Indian. Mumbai, Delhi, 2003.
19. Chaudhuri N. Ch. The Intellectual in India. New Delhi, 1967.
20. Collet S. D. The Life and Letters of Raja Rammohun Roy. Calcutta, 1962.
21. Dasgupta Subrata.The Bengal Renaissance: Identity and Creativity from Rammohun Roy to Rabindranath Tagore. Delhi, 2012.
22. Flora G. The Evolution of Positivism in Bengal: Jogendra Chandra Ghosh, Bankimchandra Chattopaddhyay, Benoy Kumar Sarkar. Napoli, 1993.
23. Halbfass W. India and Europe. An Essay of Philosophical Understanding. Albany, 1988.
24. Justyński Janusz. Mysl Spoleczna i Politiczna Renesansu Indyiskiego, od Rama Mohana Raya do Rabindranata Tagora. Warszawa etc., 1985
25. Kopf D. British Orientalism and Bengal Renaissance. Berkeley, 1969.
26. Poddar A. Renaissance in Bengal. Quests and Confrontations.1800–1860. Simla, 1970.
27. Poddar A. Renaissance in Bengal. Search for Identity. 1860–1919. Simla, 1977.
28. Roy Raja Rammohun. The English Works. Ed. by J. C. Ghose. In 4 vols. New Delhi, 1982.
29. Sarkar Susobhan. Bengal Renaissance and Other Essays. New Delhi, etc., 1970.
30. Vivekananda Swami. Complete Works. In 9 vols. Mayavati – Almora, 1998–2002