Ðóñ Eng Cn Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Litera
Reference:

The magical paradigm in the V. Pelevin`s late novels

Sil'cheva Alina Georgievna

ORCID: 0000-0002-6501-1339

PhD in Philology

Associate Professor, Department of the History of Journalism and Literature, Moscow University named after A.S. Griboyedov, Moscow, Russia

111024, Russia, Moscow region, Moscow, Highway Enthusiasts str., 21

alinka-krasulka@mail.ru

DOI:

10.25136/2409-8698.2024.3.39937

EDN:

IBABJR

Received:

10-03-2023


Published:

09-04-2024


Abstract: The issue of attribution of the creative method of V. Pelevin, implemented in later works, clarification of the author's artistic principles is acute for modern literary criticism. The article attempts to determine the specifics of the implementation of magical motif in Pelevin's works as artistic tool that allows to reflect reality in a work of art. The subject of the research is magical motif in artistic structure of late novel prose, namely in the novel «Secret Views of Mount Fuji» (2018). Such works as: «The Holy Book of the Werewolf» (2004), «Empire V» (2006), «Love for Three Zuckerbrins» (2014), «Invincible Sun» (2020) and «KGBT +» (2022) are also mentioned. The article is notable for its scientific novelty: for the first time magical elements are revealed in late novels of the author, specificity of the acting hero is indicated. The features of the embodiment of the magical in works at the level of the plot, the chronotopic organization of the text, in speech and the system of characters are presented. We additionally seek to answer the research question: is it right to consider V. Pelevin in the context of magical realism as a special type of thinking? It is noted that the author includes mythological and folklore reminiscences in the narrative: V. Pelevin refers to recognizable mythologemes, transfers well-known literary, mythological, folklore characters and typical magical creatures to a different chronotopic pattern, while maintaining their recognizability, which, together with the comparison by combining the components of magical prose with structural, plot and other elements of Pelevin's novels, allows us to answer the question in the affirmative. Structural and cultural-historical methods were used.


Keywords:

magical motives, artistic principles, magical realism, artistic method, novel, modern postmodern prose, chronotope, system of characters, Viktor Pelevin, literary text structure

This article is automatically translated. You can find original text of the article here.

In the article, we set a modest task and strive to identify the specifics of one of the constituent elements of the author's artistic method implemented in later works, namely, the features of the embodiment of the magical motif. L. M. Krupchanov in the textbook "Theory of Literature" defines an artistic or literary method as "a system of principles of artistic cognition, reflection and generalization of reality in their concrete historical refraction" [1, p. 288], that is, the method is a way of reflecting the author's perception of reality.

Traditionally, V. Pelevin is characterized by domestic and foreign researchers as a postmodernist (for example, A. Magun in the work "The Postmodern Apocalypse of Victor Pelevin" [2] or S. Y. Dvinin in the dissertation "Categories of time and space in the artistic discourse of postmodernism (based on the novels "Hawksmoor" by P. Akroyd, "Alverton" by A. Thorpe, "Chapaev and the Void" by V. Pelevin, "Altyn-Tolobas" by B. Akunin)"). However, a number of literary critics define the author's artistic method in a broader context: for example, D. V. Krotova notes modernist tendencies in early work [3], and A. G. Kovalenko identifies allusions to the two worlds of symbolists [4]. L. G. Kihney considers V. Pelevin's prose as magical, noting the author's attraction to otherness [5; 6]. According to M. A. Dvorak, the same work can be interpreted differently, both in the context of postmodernism, and within the framework of science fiction or magical realism [7].

We do not define V. Pelevin unambiguously in the context of exclusively postmodernism or another literary trend, but focus on the study of one principle typical of Pelevin's artistic method. The method is more labile than the literary direction as a historically established category.

The article uses structural and cultural-historical methods. The empirical base of the research is represented by the novel "Secret Views of Mount Fuji" (2018), such works as "The Holy Book of the Werewolf" (2004), "Empire V" (2006), "Love for the Three Zuckerbreens" (2014), "Invincible Sun" (2020) and "KGBT+" (2022).

Before proceeding directly to the consideration of the elements of magic in V. Pelevin's prose, let us define the concepts of "motive", "magic" and "magical motive".

 By motive in the work we mean the simplest element of the plot, presented in a generalized form and found in a number of works. The term was developed by A. N. Veselovsky, the motif of the literary text was also studied by B. V. Tomashevsky, V. B. Shklovsky, B. M. Gasparov and others. A typological feature of the motif is repeatability [8, pp. 88-94].

Magic is interpreted by us as a supernatural force aimed at transforming the surrounding space or oneself "without the mediation of natural forces", often violating causal connections, chronotope, etc. [9, p. 156]. Such a transformation has practical significance and is carried out, as E.A. Popov points out, with the everyday goal of "getting full or partial help from the "otherworldly" world in meeting their needs" [10, p. 193].

Based on the presented understanding of magic, we formulate the interpretation of the term "magical motif" – this is the transformation of the surrounding space repeated in a work of art, carried out through a directed effort of will to achieve a specific goal, embodied in reminiscences, paraphrases and allusions, chronotope, system, communicative acts and/or actions of characters. In the context of a magical motif, we traditionally call a magician – a person endowed with supernatural abilities who directs his skills to transform the surrounding space. The tool that allows the magician to transform reality is designated as magical.

So, let's consider the embodiment of the magical motif in the novel "Secret Views of Mount Fuji". There are two narrators in the work: the oligarch Fedya and his school sweetheart Tanya. Their storylines are mostly parallel and only occasionally intersect, merging only in the finale. Fedor's story develops Pelevin's traditional "Buddhist" line in combination with discussions about virtual technologies: the hero seeks to achieve enlightenment by using a special device. In the context of the stated topic, Tanya's storyline is of greater interest to us – a story about the heroine using a magic hook and transforming not only her life, but also Fedor's life.

Interestingly, fiction and mythology provide examples of male magicians (as well as wizards): for example, this is the shaman Don Juan from the works of Castaneda, and Merlin from the cycle of legends about King Arthur, and the Witcher, the hero of the series of books by Andrzej Sapkowski, and Harry Potter and other wizards from the series of novels by J. Rowling. However, magic as a force capable of transforming the surrounding world is associatively associated with the energy of creation and female energy, which, for example, is explored in the monograph "Mysteries and Magic of the North (runes and female power)" by F. Asvinn [11]. The female chapters of the novel "Secret Views of Mount Fuji", that is, those episodes where Tanya acts as the narrator, embody just this point of view.

Tanya's path in the world of magic begins with humiliation by Fyodor and a meeting with a mushroom picker in the forest, who gives her Giselle's number. Subsequently, Tanya gets acquainted with a group whose members call themselves the new hunters, whose representative is the heroine's new acquaintance. Tanya dreams of Amanda [the founder of the esoteric feminist community, according to the story of one of the heroines], later she plunges into a ritual trance, defeats an Iguana [deity] and becomes one of the hunters.

These episodes represent the initiation and formation of the heroine. Tanya's story can generally be viewed in a social context (as an artistic interpretation of the feminist movement), satirical (satire and grotesque are among the key author's methods), however, we have articulated only the magical component of the above episodes.

The key place of action is the forest: in the forest there is a fateful meeting with a mushroom picker, and the humiliation of Tanya, and an initiatory ritual. The forest in the magical key is the place of the ritual and the boundary between reality and otherness [12].

Esoteric feminism and the supernatural ability of the new hunters to transform reality and influence it are discussed by the heroines: "... The Amanda system is a mystery based on ancient and intimate female magic. It was forgotten many centuries ago, but Amanda rediscovered it for us. / Magic? Tanya asked incredulously. / – Magic is just a word..." [13, p. 256].

Later, Tanya transforms reality with the help of a magic tool (hook): "It wasn't some kind of material object. It was all Fedin's fate – Tanya knew that for sure. It was as if she controlled the bed of a distant river, and from each turn of the handle something in the whole nature changed..." [13, p. 359]. Often, the actions of the heroine are described in dry factual language, a passive voice appears, which indicates the practical application of magic: "Tanya formulated a command and sent a hook to Fedin's head ... the order was heard" [13, p. 353].

In the finale of the novel, the heroine becomes Fyodor's lover. Thus, magic for the heroine is a means to achieve what she wants.

Speaking about the embodiment of the magical motif in the work of V. Pelevin, it is necessary to identify the specifics of the hero. The main character has the ability to penetrate beyond the boundaries of reality and move from one world to another. Despite the ability to move and knowledge about the true nature of reality, the hero is still easily attributed by the reader as a representative of a specific aspect of being. Let's consider the cases typical for V. Pelevin:

1) the hero belongs to another world initially (foxes and werewolves, the heroes of the novel "The Holy Book of the Werewolf");

2) the hero makes the transition from reality to the other world (the man Roma Storkin becomes the vampire Ram in the novel "Empire V");

3) the hero moves freely between the real and otherworldly (or virtual) worlds (the novel "The Invincible Sun" ends with the creation of a new reality, and the memory of the old one belongs only to Sasha; at the beginning of the novel, the main character ascends the mountain and experiences a transcendent experience; the main character of the novel "Love for the Three Zuckerbrins" is able to get out from virtual reality and become aware of the physical space surrounding him). 

It should be noted that magic as a kind of force is also present in the latest novel "KGBT+" at the time of writing: the main character briefly mentions valkyries as representatives of the media business: "One of the hypnotic furies that <...> they hire for a lot of money to warm up the reptilian brain of the deep people. I don't really believe in their magic. Rather, there is magic there, and it is very powerful, but it boils down to self-presentation and divorce on a budget..." [14, p. 182].

The examples given vary in scale, and the same can be said about the magical elements in the system of the artistic world. Magical elements are woven into the plot at different levels of narration: at the level of vocabulary (linguistic markers appear indicating a magician, magic, magical object or action); at the level of actions performed by characters; at the level of chronotope organization; at the level of the plot.

When considering the magical in the plot, the question arises: can we, having identified the magical motif in V. Pelevin's prose, attribute it to magical realism? Before proceeding to the search for an answer, it is necessary to formulate a definition of "magical realism".

E. G. Maslova considers magical realism as a type of artistic thinking characterized by carnivalization, an organic combination of fiction and historical reality, which readers are easily able to identify [15]

As A. A. Gugnin notes, household elements are the basis for the growth of the miraculous [16]. Realism as a component of the term is fundamentally significant, since the narrative is based on a realistic chronotope, "which is constantly "torn apart" by elements that do not fit into it and eventually turns out to be deceptive" [17, p. 21].

Let's highlight some components of magical prose, comparing them with episodes or actions of characters taken from Pelevin's novel prose.

1. The degree of reliability and plausibility of the topos, events, characters and objects: the boundary between the real and the unreal is blurred, the acting character often finds it difficult to definitively define what is happening as a dream (hallucination) or reality. So, the space in the Tenerife villa in the finale of the novel "The Invincible Sun" changes, the boundaries disappear, the passage of time does not correspond to the real: the main character, watching her companion dance, sees her aging.

2. The boundary between the worlds: reality and otherness has a clearly defined boundary [18, p. 18]. In relation to the final episode of the novel "The Invincible Sun", the identification of the boundary does not cause difficulties: the door to the hall closes, cutting off reality from otherness, the transformation of the chronotope occurs only in this hall.

Analyzing the novel as a whole, we also find other examples of boundaries – the mention of the fiery river in the song, a dream as the boundary between reality and reality, traveling by plane (a long distance as a border), the primary source of which is found in the mythologies of the peoples of the world. According to N. Z. Koltsova's reasoning, "... awareness of one's "otherness", including from the point of view of the "national code" (and not only in terms of attitude to modern civilization), is the fundamental attitude of the creators of "magical" literature" [19, p. 133].

E. G. Maslova points out that magical realism is based on mythical, mythological and folklore material [15], which we see in the Pelevin artistic method. Examples can also serve: the forest, already mentioned earlier in the article, as the border between the real and other worlds; the novel "The Holy Book of the Werewolf", full of reminiscences of Scandinavian mythology; muses as professional inspirers in the novel "KGBT+", etc.

3. Explaining the nature of what is happening, building cause-and-effect relationships. The unreal is not explained by natural sciences, the statement about the presence of the magical is the basis for the existence of an artistic space. However, the magical world has a specific chronotope and the laws according to which the characters act, as well as a story (the story of the werewolf foxes is told by the main character at the beginning of the novel ("The Holy Book of Werewolves") and is mentioned later).

Thus, we are inclined to assume that V. Pelevin's later work tends towards magical realism. A deeper analysis of the works will further determine the validity of the designation of the late Pelevin texts in the context of magical realism as a type of thinking.

So, the article considers the implementation of a magical motif in the structure of a large prose text by V. Pelevin. Using examples, the specifics of the embodiment of magic in works are studied at various levels, namely: plot, chronotope, speech, character system. A motivated and proven assumption has been made about the author's attraction to magical realism.

The work identifies one of the aspects of V. Pelevin's work. However, there are also mythological, cultural, historical, etc. references that may become the subject of study in further works devoted to the study of V. Pelevin's late work.

Due to the obvious transformation of the author's artistic method and the popularity of V. Pelevin's work, we consider the research direction presented in the article to be promising and of interest to the scientific community.

References
1. Krupchanov, L. M. (2017). Literary theory. Moscow: Flinta.
2. Magun, A. (2017). Viktor Pelevin’s Postmodern Apocalypse. Stasis, 86–102.
3. Krotova, D. V. (2018). Modernist elements in the artistic consciousness of V. Pelevin. Verbal art of the Silver Age and Russian abroad in the context of the era («Smirnov Readings»): a collection of articles on the results of the III International Conference (Moscow, Moscow State University, June 29-30, 2018). Sost. i red. L. F. Alekseeva, V. N. Klimchukova, S. V. Krylova, 72–78.
4. Kovalenko, A. G. (2004). Literature and postmodernism. Moscow: Publishing House of the Peoples' Friendship University of Russia.
5. Kihnej, L. G., & Gavrikov, V. A. (2020). Lev Naumov's prose in the context of «mystical realism» in Russian literature of the XX-XXI centuries. Moscow: Amsterdam: Tardis.
6. Kihnej, L. G. (2019). Multicultural or culturally unattributed space as the embodiment of other being in modern «mystical prose» (M. Petrosyan, V. Pelevin, L. Naumov). Russia in the world: problems and prospects for the development of international cooperation in the humanitarian and social sphere Materials of the VI International Scientific and Practical Conference. Moscow-Penza: PSTU Publishing House, 46–55.
7. Dvorak, M. A. (2013). Science fiction as an interpretation of postmodernism (on the example of G. L. Oldie’s novel «The Messiah Clears the Disk»). Bulletin of the Tver State University. Series «Philology», 6, 267–272.
8. Nikolaev, A. I. (2011). Fundamentals of Literary Studies: a textbook for students of philological specialties. Ivanovo: LISTOS.
9. Ionin, L. G. (2004). New magical age. Logos, 2, 156-173.
10. Popov, E. A. (2007). Philosophy of Magic: Basic Approaches. Bulletin of the Stavropol State University. University, 49, 189–193.
11. Aswinn, F. (1990). Runes and the power of a woman. Secrets of the northern mysteries. Moscow: Eksmo.
12. Sil'cheva, A. G., & Sherchalova, E. V. (2022). Mythological topos in the novels of V. Pelevin. Questions of theory and practice, 10(36), 15, 3174–3178.
13. Pelevin V. O. (2020). Secret views of Mount Fuji. Moscow: Eksmo.
14. Pelevin V. O. (2023). KGBT+. Moscow: Eksmo.
15. Maslova, E. G. (2012). Traditions of magical realism in the novels of T. Morrison in the 1970s-1990s: avtoref. dis. … kand. filol. nauk. Kazan.
16. Gugnin, A. A. (1998). Magic Realism in the Context of Literature and Art of the 20th Century (The Phenomenon and Some Ways of Understanding It). Moscow: Scientific Center for SlavonicGermanic Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences.
17. Sil'cheva, A. G. (2023). Mystical Realism in Russian Literature of the 20th – 21st Centuries: the Case of Dina Rubina. Moscow: MAKS Press.
18. Barkova, A. L. (2019). World mythology. Lectures PRO. Moscow: RIPOL Klassik.
19. Kol'cova, N. Z. (2019). On the issue of magical realism in Russian literature of the XX-XXI cen-turies. From Chekhov to Brodsky: aesthetic and philosophical aspects of Russian literature of the XX century: a collective monograph. Red. G. V. Zykova, S. I. Kormilov, sost. E. A. Korshunova. (133-149). Moscow: Publishing House of Moscow University.

Peer Review

Peer reviewers' evaluations remain confidential and are not disclosed to the public. Only external reviews, authorized for publication by the article's author(s), are made public. Typically, these final reviews are conducted after the manuscript's revision. Adhering to our double-blind review policy, the reviewer's identity is kept confidential.
The list of publisher reviewers can be found here.

The article "The magical paradigm in the late novels of V. Pelevin" presented for consideration, proposed for publication in the magazine "Litera", is undoubtedly relevant, due to the consideration of the specifics of the texts of the famous writer of the 21st century, our contemporary Victor Pelevin, whose work is extremely popular among Russian-speaking readers. In the article, the author sets the task to identify the specifics of one of the constituent elements of the author's artistic method implemented in later works, namely, the peculiarities of the embodiment of the magical motif. The article considers the "magical motif" as a transformation of the surrounding space repeated in a work of art, carried out through a directed effort of will in order to achieve a specific goal, embodied in reminiscences, paraphrases and allusions, chronotope, system, communicative acts and/or actions of characters. The article is groundbreaking, one of the first in Russian literary criticism devoted to the study of such topics in the 21st century. The article presents a research methodology, the choice of which is quite adequate to the goals and objectives of the work. All the theoretical inventions of the author are supported by practical material. In this paper, the author provides linguistic examples from the writer's works in Russian. The author turns, among other things, to various methods to confirm the hypothesis put forward. The following research methods are used: logical-semantic analysis, hermeneutical and comparative methods, as well as description, structural and cultural-historical methods. This work was done professionally, in compliance with the basic canons of scientific research. The research was carried out in line with modern scientific approaches, the work consists of an introduction containing the formulation of the problem, the main part, traditionally beginning with a review of theoretical sources and scientific directions, a research and final one, which presents the conclusions obtained by the author. Note that the final part does not fully reflect the objectives of the study. The theoretical provisions are illustrated with textual material. However, the author does not indicate the size of the sample obtained, which was used in the study, as well as the sources of its origin and the time period. The bibliography of the article contains 19 sources, including theoretical works in both Russian and English. In some cases, the requirements of GOST for the design of the list of references have been violated, in terms of non-compliance with the generally accepted alphabetical arrangement of cited works. Thus, works in Russian are mixed with foreign-language works, traditionally located at the end of the list, the alphabetical principle of building a bibliography is not observed. In general, it should be noted that the article is written in a simple, understandable language for the reader. Typos, spelling and syntactic errors, inaccuracies in the text of the work were not found. The comments made are not significant and do not affect the overall positive impression of the reviewed work. The practical significance of the research lies in the possibility of using its results in the process of teaching university courses in literary studies. The article will undoubtedly be useful to a wide range of people, philologists, undergraduates and graduate students of specialized universities. The article "The magical paradigm in the late novels of V. Pelevin" can be recommended for publication in a scientific journal.