Eng During last 365 days Approved articles: 2065,   Articles in work: 293 Declined articles: 786 

Back to contents

PHILHARMONICA. International Music Journal

Was there a Manuel Garcia's Mistake? An Attempt to Dispel the Myth about the Main Secret of the Garcia School
Reshetnikova Svetlana Vladimirovna

voice coach at Children Music School No. 13, Kazan, post-graduate student at Kazan State Conservatory

420004, Russia, respublika Tatarstan, g. Kazan', ul. Okol'naya, 1






Review date:


Review date:


Publish date:



This article explores the pedagogical activity of Manuel Patricio Rodríguez García, analyses and substantiates the difference between the versions of edition of the work "The Complete Treatise on the Art of Singing" of 1840-1847 and 1856, which has raised questions among singers and vocal pedagogues over a long period of time. Despite the fact that the work "The Complete Treatise on the Art of Singing" has been repeatedly published in Russian, the disputes about its principles continue unabated up to now even in the media. The theoretical and methodological basis of this study is as follows:  analysis of musical and pedagogical problems, cultural and historical analysis, comparative analysis. This article clarifies the author's recommendation on the use of various types of breathing stated in the treatise of 1840-1847 and 1856. In the middle of the XIX century vocal pedagogy developed in accordance with the performance practice of the era of Romanticism and new aesthetic intentions, that's why Manuel Garcia Junior, the author of the treatise, improved his treatise and recommended singers to use chest-diaphragmatic breathing instead of small (clavicular) one.

Keywords: Manuel Garcia Junior , aesthetic standards, clavicular breathing, Manuel Garcia Senior, chest-diaphragmatic breathing, the era of romanticism, treatise by Garcia, vocal pedagogy , Garcia school, theoretical work
This article written in Russian. You can find full text of article in Russian here .

Aspelund, D. Razvitie pevtsa i ego golosa. Izdatel'stvo: M.-L.: Muzgiz. 1952. 192 s.
Garsia M. Polnyi traktat ob iskusstve peniya. Russkii per. pod red. Bagadurova V. M.: Prosveshchenie, 1957. 356 s.
Drach I. Opernoe tvorchestvo V. Bellini i G. Donitsetti v ital'yanskoi muzykal'no-teatral'noi kul'ture epokhi romantizma. dissertatsiya ... kandidata iskusstvovedeniya: 17.00.02 / Kiev, 1990. 17s. [Elektronnyi resurs]. URL: http://cheloveknauka.com/opernoe-tvorchestvo-v-bellini-i-g-donitsetti-v-italyanskoy-muzykalno-teatralnoy-kulture-epohi-romantizma (data obrashcheniya 04.05.2016)
Pluzhnikov K. Vokal'nye vozzreniya dinastii Garsia. Izdatel'stvo Kompozitor. Sankt-Peterburg, 2006. 103 s.
Pokrovskii A.V. Pevcheskoe dykhanie / Sovremennaya nauka // Aktual'nye problemy teorii i praktiki // Seriya Gumanitarnye nauki // Nauchnye tekhnologii (Moskva), 2013g. 9-10, S. 6-13.
Sladkopevets R.V. Brend bel'kanto v ital'yanskoi vokal'noi shkole // [Elektronnyi resurs] // Vestnik MGUKI 4 (54) iyul'avgust 2013 s. 245249. URL: http://files.msuc.org/Vestnik/2013/4/2013-245-249.pdf (data obrashcheniya 05.10.2016).
Khoffmann A.E. Fenomen bel'kanto pervoi poloviny XIX veka: kompozitorskoe tvorchestvo, ispolnitel'skoe iskusstvo i vokal'naya pedagogika : dissertatsiya ... kandidata iskusstvovedeniya : 17.00.02 / Ros. akad. muzyki im. Gnesinykh. Moskva. 2008. 225 s.
Castellengo M. Manuel Garcia fils: un observateur perspicace de la production de la voix chantée // [Elektronnyi resurs] // Congrès Pevoc 2005, Londres, pp, 1-11. URL: https://f.hypotheses.org/wp-content/blogs.dir/198/files/2013/10/2005-Garcia_v2012_F.pdf (data obrashcheniya 05.10.2016).
Pilotti K. The Road to Bel Canto. [Elektronnyi resurs] // Musicology with Artistic Focus. Masters thesis at the Academy of Music, Örebro University, Sweden 2009. URL: www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:291620/fulltext02 (data obrashcheniya 02.02.2016).
Mackinlay S. Garcia the Centenarian and his times; W. Blackwood & son, Edinburgh.1908. 335 p.
Radomski T. Manuel García (1805-1906): A Bicentenary Reflection [Elektronnyi resurs] // Australian Voice. 2005. Vol. 11. pp. 25-41. URL: http://www.harmonicorde.com/Radomski%20Australian%20Voice.pdf (data obrashcheniya: 09.03.2016).