Ðóñ Eng During last 365 days Approved articles: 2065,   Articles in work: 293 Declined articles: 786 
Library

Paramonov D.O. Tradition and Revolution: Emotional Experience and the Search for Relevant Terms in European and Indian Philosophical Traditions

Published in journal "Philosophy and Culture", 2015-10 in rubric "The dialogue of cultures", pages 1489-1503.

Resume: The article is devoted to the assessment of philosophical grounds for creating the terms that would explain the demand for social changes and revolutions based on subjective experience. For European classical philosophy revolutionary state of mind can be 'removed' only by self-consciousness while under the conditions of individual consciousness revolutionary query is unavoidable as an element of reflection. Can the tradition 'take' the place that German classical philosophers 'prepared' for self-consciousness? Does the tradition contain revolutionary energy? The opposition between revolution and tradition allows to extend the prospects and horizons of philosophisizing through involving other philosophical systems including Indian classical darshan into the scope of their philosophy. Another important traditional philosophy of India is the philosophy of Mimansa. Representatives of Mimansa developed their own conceptual framework allowing to 'bind' revolutionary energy and somehow eliminate contradictory dialects of self-consciousness whle avoiding revolutions and demands for radical social transformations. In his research Paramonov has used the comparative-historical method, philosopho-comparative approach to culture based on the study of the main works of M. Petrov, D. Zilberman, A. Paribka and V. Lysenko. The scientific novelty of the research is caused by the fact that the author searches for subjective, i.e. transcendental, cognitive and psychological grounds for such concepts and phenomena as 'revolution' and 'tradition' and compares Western European and Oriental (Indian) mental attitudes associated with these concepts and phenomena. The author describes the social and political environment of Indian traditional philosophy and offers his interpretation of the mission and functions of Mimansa as one of the darshans (i.e. branches of Indian philosophy).     

Keywords: social changes, revolution, tradition, dialects of a subject, European philosophical tradition, Indian philosphical tradition, rituals, darshans, Mimansa , Apurva

DOI: 10.7256/1999-2793.2015.10.12994

This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article

Bibliography:
Magun A.V. Edinstvo i odinochestvo: Kurs politicheskoy filosofii Novogo vremeni. –M.: novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2011.
Kralechkin D Nansi i dukhi. [Elektronnyy resurs]. URL http://www.censura.ru/articles/demoveritas.htm, data obrashcheniya 10.02.2013
Dzolo D. Demokratiya i slozhnost'. Realisticheskiy podkhod. Izdatel'stvo GU-VShE, M., 2010
Magun A. Otritsatel'naya revolyutsiya. K dekonstruktsii politicheskogo sub'ekta. Izdatel'stvo Evropeyskogo universiteta v Sankt-Peterburge, SPB, 2008
Dodds E.R. Greki i irratsional'noe. Moskva-SPB, Kul'turnaya initsiativa. 2000.
Zhizhek S. Dobro pozhalovat' v pustynyu real'nosti [Elektronnyy resurs] URL: http://yanko.lib.ru/books/cultur/zizek-welkome-8l.pdf, data obrashcheniya 13.03.2013, Arendt H. On Revolution. NY. Viking Press. 1965; Penguin books, 1990
Sementsov V.S. Problemy interpretatsii brakhmanicheskoy prozy M., "Nauka", 1981
Putilov B.N. Epicheskoe skazitel'stvo Tipologiya i etnicheskaya spetsifika. Izdatel'skaya firma «Vostochnaya literatura» RAN, M., 1997
Torchinov E.A. Religii mira. Opyt zapredel'nogo. Transpersonal'nye sostoyaniya i psikhika. Tsentr Peterburgskoe vostokovedenie. SPB, 1998.
Agamben D. «Homo Sacer: suverennaya vlast' i golaya zhizn'». M., Evropa, 2011
Uayt Kh. Metaistoriya: Istoricheskoe voobrazhenie v Evrope KhIKh v.
Paramonov D. Yazykovaya politika i demokratiya v sostoyanii narastayushchey slozhnosti. Modeli refleksivnoy sotsiologii//Vestnik RGGU, ¹ 2, 2011).
Kozhev A. Vvedenie v chtenie Gegelya SPb.: Nauka, 2003
Adorno T. V. Negativnaya dialektika.-M.: Nauchnyy mir, 2003
Bauman Z. Tekuchaya sovremennost'. SPB, Piter, 2008
Bauman Z. Svoboda. M, Novoe izdatel'stvo, 2005
Malamud Sh. Semantika i ritorika v ierarkhii induistskikh tseley cheloveka// Malamud Sh. Ispech' mir. M., Izdatel'skaya firma «Vostochnaya literatura», 2005
Verpoorten J-M. Mimansa Literature. Otto Harrassowitz. Wiesbaden. 1987
Jaimini: Mimamsasutra Based on the ed. by B.D. Basu, Allahabad 1923-1925 (Sacred Books of the Hindus, 27) URL: www.sansknet.org, data obrashcheniya 12.07.2012
Thapar R. The Future of the Indian Past. Seventh D. T. Lakadawala Memorial Lecture, New Delhi, 21 February 2004, [Elektronnyy resurs] (URL: http://www.sacw.net/India_History/r_thaparLecture21022004.html , data obrashcheniya 13.03.2013).
Pimenov A. Vozvrashchenie k dkharme. M., Natalis, 1998
Pimenov A. Mimansa v kontekste etnicheskoy istorii Indii// Istoriya filosofii. Vyp. 7. M.: IF RAN, 2000
Paramonov D. Refleksiya. Genezis ponyatiya v kontekste evropeyskoy i indiyskoy filosofskikh traditsiy. // Raboty po filosofii, M. Klyuch-S, 2012
Paramonov D. Yazykovaya politika i demokratiya v sostoyanii narastayushchey slozhnosti. Modeli refleksivnoy sotsiologii//Vestnik RGGU, ¹ 2, 2011.
Zil'berman D.B. Genezis znacheniya v filosofii induizma. M., URSS, 2001
Ankersmit F.R. Vozvyshennyy istoricheskiy opyt. M., Evropa, 2003
Shokhin V.K. Shkoly indiyskoy filosofii. M., Izdatel'skaya firma «Vostochnaya literatura», 2004,
Yoshimizu K. Kumārila’s Reevaluation of the Sacrifice and the Veda from a Vedānta Perspective// Mimamsa and Vedanta. Interaction and Continuity. Ed. By J. Bronkhorst. Motial Banarsidass Publishers Private Limited, Delhi 2007
Volovik V.D. Zametki k ponyatiyu dvizheniya//XIX Chteniya pamyati G.P. Shchedrovitskogo,[ elektronnyy resurs], URL: http://www.fondgp.ru/lib/chteniya/xix/mat/presentations, data obrashcheniya 12.03.2013)/
Dolgopol'skiy S.B. Ritoriki talmuda. Analiz v poststrukturalistskoy perspektive. Affekt i figura. Peterburgskiy evreyskiy universitet. SPB, 1998.
Serebryanyy S.D. O sovetskoy paradigme. [Elektronnyy resurs]. URL: http://www.i-u.ru/biblio/archive/serebraniy_o/00.aspx, data obrashcheniya 21.12.2012
Gächter O. Hermeneutics and Language in Pūrva-Mimansa. Motial Banarsidass Publishers Private Limited, Delhi, 1990
Sementsov V.S. Problemy interpretatsii brakhmanicheskoy prozy M., "Nauka"
Platon. Protagor
Aristotel'. Sobranie soch. v 4-kh tomakh., t.4., M., Mysl', 1984,
Raju P.T, Activism in Indian Thought// Studies in Mimansa. Dr. Mandan Mishra Felicitation Volume. Ed. By R.C. Dwivedi, Motial Banarsidass Publishers Private Limited, Delhi, 1994
Delez Zh. Razlichie i povtorenie. SPB, Petropolis, 1998

Correct link to this article:
just copy this link to clipboard