'The role of the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Empire in reform of the criminal justice in accordance with judicial statutes' Law and Politics nbpublish.com
Eng Cn Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Vereshchagina A.V. The role of the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Empire in reform of the criminal justice in accordance with judicial statutes

Published in journal "Law and Politics", 2015-6 in rubric "History of state and law", pages 864-873.

Resume: This article presents the research on the role of the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Empire in the judicial reform of 1864 (predominantly the criminal justice). The author offers periodization of the work of the Ministry of Justice on judicial reform (criterion of inclusion): first period when the Ministry of Justice carried a provisional character, and was not working on devising judicial statutes; second period the realization of the judicial statutes, when the role of the Ministry of Justice in carrying out the reform becomes the key. The author systematizes the normative legal acts passed by the Ministry of Justice throughout the judicial reform and highlights three groups of normative legal acts: 1) acts aimed at improving the financial situation of members of the justice system; 2) organizational acts; 3) acts correcting the justice system and legislation on criminal procedure. Based on the results of the research, the author formulates a conclusion on the need for an educated assessment of the work of the Ministry of Justice in the process of judicial reform.

Keywords: financial support of judges, judges, judicial authority, criminal justice, Ministry of Justice, judicial statutes, judicial reform, irremovability of judges, independent judicial authority, jury trial

DOI: 10.7256/1811-9018.2015.6.15211

This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article

Bibliography:
Vremennye Pravila o primenenii Sudebnykh Ustavov k guberniyam i oblastyam Sibiri: Vysochayshe utverzhdennye ot 13 maya 1896 goda//PSZ III. XVI. Otd. I 12932.-SPb.: Gos. tip., 1896.
O vvedenii v deystvie Sudebnykh Ustavov 20 noyabrya 1864 goda, v polnom ikh ob'eme, v devyati zapadnykh guberniyakh: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 19 iyulya 1877 goda//PSZ II. T.LII. Otd. II..57589.-SPb.: Tip. II Otdeleniya SEIV Kantselyarii, 1879.
O kvartirnom dovol'stvii pomoshchnikov Mirovykh Sudey v Zakavkaz'e: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 3 marta 1903 goda//PSZ III. T. XXIII. Otd.I. 22596 SPb.: Gos. tip., 1905.
O kvartirnom dovol'stvii Sudebnykh Sledovateley oblasti voyska Donskogo: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 10 iyunya 1902 goda//PSZ III. T.XXII. Otd.1 21636.-SPb.: Gos. tip., 1904.
O kvartirnom dovol'stvii Sudebnykh Sledovateley: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 12 fevralya 1901 goda//PSZ III. T.XXI. Otd. I. 19675.-SPb.: Gos. tip., 1903.
O naznachenii raz'ezdnykh deneg Sudebnym Sledovatelyam Varshavskogo sudebnogo okruga: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 17 maya 1877 goda//PSZ II. T. LII. Otd. I. 57375.-SPb.: Tip. II Otd-niya SEIV Kantselyarii, 1879.
O novom shtate Kassatsionnykh Departamentov Pravitel'stvuyushchego Senata i o nekotorykh izmeneniyakh i dopolneniyakh v Sudebnykh Ustavakh 20 noyabrya 1864 goda: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 10 iyunya 1877 goda //PSZ II. T. LII.Otd. I. 57741.-SPb.: Tip. II Otdeleniya SEIV Kantselyarii, 1879.
O poryadke izdaniya Obshchego Nakaza sudebnym ustanovleniyam i o distsiplinarnoy otvetstvennosti chinov sudebnogo vedomstva: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot20 maya 1885 goda//PSZ III. T. V. 2959.-SPb.: Gos. tip., 1887.
O poryadke proizvodstva del prezhnikh sudebnykh ustanovleniy kak v mestnostyakh, gde vvodyatsya Sudebnye Ustavy v polnom ob'eme, tak i v tekh, gde vvodyatsya mirovye sudebnye ustanovleniya otdel'no ot obshchikh: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 10 marta 1869 goda//PSZ II. T.XLIV. Otd. I. 46840. SPB.: Tip. II Otd-niya SEIV Kantselyarii, 1869.
O poryadke raspredeleniya mezhdu Chlenami Okruzhnykh Sudov summy, assignovannoy Vysochayshim poveleniem 12 iyunya 1884 goda na dobavochnoe soderzhanie oznachennykh lits: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 30 aprelya 1885 goda//PSZ III. T. V. 2906.-SPb.: Gos. tip., 1887.
Ob izmenenii i dopolnenii statey Svoda Zakonov, kasayushchikhsya sudoproizvodstva i deloproizvodstva v nyneshnikh sudebnykh mestakh: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 11 oktyabrya 1865 goda//PSZ II. T. XL. Otd. II. 42548.-SPb.: Tip. II Otd-niya SEIV Kantselyarii, 1867.
Ob izmenenii postanovleniy o prisyazhnykh zasedatelyakh: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 12 iyunya 1884 goda//PSZ. Sobr. tret'e. T.IV. 2314.-SPb.: Gos. tip., 1887; Ob izmenenii deystvuyushchikh pravil otnositel'no privoda prisyazhnykh zasedateley k prisyage i raz'yasneniya im prav, obyazannostey i otvetstvennosti: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 3 iyunya 1894 goda//PSZ III. T. XIV. 10710.-SPb.: Gos. tip., 1898.
Ob uvelichenii okladov soderzhaniya uchastkovym mirovym sud'yam v devyati Zapadnykh guberniyakh i ustanovleniya dlya sego osobykh, v etikh guberniyakh, sudebnykh sborov: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 23 aprelya 1874 goda//PSZ II. T. XLIX . Otd.I. 53420.-SPb.: Tip. II Otd-niya SEIV Kantselyarii, 1876.
Ob uvelichenii okladov soderzhaniya Chlenam Okruzhnykh Sudov: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 18 yanvarya 1899 goda// PSZ III. T.XIX. Otd. I. 16361. SPb.: Gos. tip., 1902.
Ob uvelichenii soderzhaniya Chlenov Okruzhnykh Sudov i ob izmeneniyakh v sostave okrugov i shtatakh Sudebnykh Palat: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 12 iyunya 1884 goda//PSZ III. T.IV. 2313.-SPb.: Gos. tip., 1887.
Ob ustanovlenii dobavochnykh okladov Chlenam Okruzhnykh Sudov: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe mnenie Gosudarstvennogo Soveta ot 13 maya 1896 goda//PSZ III. T.XVI. Otd. I. 12931.-SPb.: Gos. tip., 1899.
Ob uchrezhdenii sudebnykh ustanovleniy i o Sudebnykh ustavakh: Imennoy dannyy Senatu ukaz 20 noyabrya 1864 goda// PSZ II. T.XXXIX. Otd. II. 41473.-SPb.: Tip. II Otd-niya SEIV Kantselyarii,1867.
Osnovnye polozheniya preobrazovaniya sudebnoy chasti v Rossii: Vysochayshe utverzhdennye 29 sentyabrya 1862 goda//PSZ II. T. XXXVII. Otd. II. 38761.-SPB.: Tip. II Otd-niya SEIV Kantselyarii, 1865.
Polozhenie o vvedenii v deystvie Sudebnykh Ustavov 20 noyabrya 1864 goda: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe 19 oktyabrya 1865 goda//PSZ II. T.XL Otd.II. 42587.-SPb.: Tip. II Otd-niya SEIV Kantselyarii, 1867.
Uchrezhdenie Sudebnykh Sledovateley: Imennoy ukaz, dannyy Pravitel'stvuyushchemu Senatu 8 iyunya 1860 goda; Nakaz Sudebnym Sledovatelyam: Vysochayshe utverzhdennyy 8 iyunya 1860 goda; Nakaz politsii o proizvodstve doznaniya po proisshestviyam, mogushchim zaklyuchat' v sebe prestuplenie ili prostupok: Vysochayshe utverzhdennyy 8 iyunya 1860 goda //PSZ II. T.XXXV. Otd. I. 35890,35891,35892.-SPb.:Tip.II Otd-niya SEIV Kantselyarii,1862.
Uchrezhdenie sudebnykh ustanovleniy: Vysochayshe utverzhdennoe 20 noyabrya 1864 goda; Ustav ugolovnogo sudoproizvodstva: Vysochayshe utverzhdennyy 20 noyabrya 1864 goda; Ustav grazhdanskogo sudoproizvodstva: Vysochayshe utverzhdennyy 20 noyabrya 1964 goda; Ustav o nakazaniyakh, nalagaemykh mirovymi sud'yami: Vysochayshe utverzhdennyy 20 noyabrya 1864 goda 41478//PSZ II. T.XXXIX. Otd. II. 41475,41476,41477, 41478.-SPb.: Tip. II Otd-niya SEIV Kantselyarii, 1867. Nauchnye publikatsii:
Vereshchagina A.V. Nuzhna li reforma predvaritel'nogo sledstviya?//Izvestiya vysshikh uchebnykh zavedeniy. Pravovedenie.-2005.-1.-S.160-168.
Vereshchagina A.V. Sposoby ogranicheniya samostoyatel'nosti sudebnoy vlasti v dorevolyutsionnom zakonodatel'stve//Pravo i politika.-2014.-7.-S.1033-1041.
Vereshchagina A.V. Sudoustroystvennoe i ugolovno-protsessual'noe zakonodatel'stvo Roscii kontsa XIX nachala XX veka: tendentsii razvitiya i idei reformirovaniya [Tekst]: monografiya.-Vladivostok: Izd-vo VGUES, 2014.-250 s.
Galkin A.G. Al'ternativy sudebnoy reformy 1864 goda v otsenkakh obrazovannoy publiki 1860-1900-kh godov//Vestnik Chuvashskogo universiteta.-2011.-4.-S.33.
Dunyushkin P.A., Shevchenko G.V. Razvitie instituta distsiplinarnoy otvetstvennosti sudey v period sudebnoy reformy 1864 goda//Istoricheskie, filosofskie, politicheskie i yuridicheskie nauki, kul'turologiya i iskusstvovedenie. Voprosy teorii i praktiki. 2014.-8(46).-Ch.I.-S.56-58.
Efremova N.N. Reorganizatsiya rossiyskoy yustitsii v epokhu prosveshcheniya//Zhurnal rossiyskogo prava.-2008.-3.-S.135-148.
Krakovskiy K.P. Sovremennaya rossiyskaya istoriografiya sudebnoy reformy 1864 goda i poreformennoy istorii rossiyskogo suda//Istoriko-pravovye problemy: Novyy rakurs.-2014.-9-1.-S.32-56.
Ministerstvo yustitsii za sto let:1802-1902: ist.ocherk.-SPb.: Senatskaya Tipografiya, 1902.-340 s.
Nikolaev N.D. Iz istorii Rossiyskoy yustitsii [Elektronnyy resurs]//Rezhim dostupa: http://www.law.edu.ru/doc/document.asp?docID=1147397 (Data obrashcheniya 26 noyabrya 2014 goda).
Polyanskiy N.N. Mirovoy sud//Sud i prava lichnosti: sb.st. /pod red. N.V. Davydova, N.N. Polyanskogo.-M.: Statut; RAP, 2005.-S.200-317.
Rybin D.V. Kadrovaya politika ministerstva yustitsii Rossiyskoy imperii v poreformennyy period (1861-1904gg.)//Vestnik Leningradskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta im. A.S. Pushkina.-2010.-T. 4.- 1.-S.66-77.
Simonyan R.Z. Istoricheskie vekhi organov prokurorskogo nadzora Kurskogo kraya serediny XVII-nachala XX vv.// Uchenye zapiski Rossiyskogo gosudarstvennogo sotsial'nogo universiteta.-2010.- 3. S.110-117.
Speranskiy M.M. Proekty i zapiski.-M.;L.: Izd-vo AN SSSR,1961.-244 s.
Stepanenkova Z.V. Razrabotka otdel'nykh polozheniy sudebnoy reformy v rannikh rabotakh V.V. Bervi-Flerovskogo//Ural'skiy istoricheskiy vestnik.-2011.-3(32).-S.122-128.
Trostyanskiy A.G. Sotsial'nyy portret uezdnogo sud'i nakanune sudebnoy reformy 1864 goda (po materialam Penzenskoy i Samarskoy guberniy)//Nauka i sovremennost'. 2010. 1-1.-S. 148-151.
Chernik M.V. O nekotorykh problemakh realizatsii Sudebnykh ustavov 1864 g. v Kalmykii//Vestnik MGOU. Seriya Istoriya i politicheskie nauki.-2013.-1.-S.35-37.
Shevyrin V.M. Ministr yustitsii Dmitriy Nikolaevich Nabokov (1827-1904)//Rossiya i sovremennyy mir.-2001.-3.-S.184-196.
Shchedrina Yu.V. Sozdanie emerital'noy kassy sudebnogo vedomstva v 1860-kh-seredine 1880-kh gg. (k voprosu o sotsial'no-ekonomicheskikh garantiyakh nezavisimosti sudey) //Elektronnyy zhurnal Vestnik MGOU/www.evestnik-mgou.ru.-2013.-4.
Yakovleva O.N. Ministerstvo yustitsii i Ministerstvo vnutrennikh del Rossiyskoy imperii: opyt vzaimodeystviya po voprosam normotvorchestva v ramkakh deyatel'nosti Komiteta ministrov (1802-1864 gg.)//Vestnik Vladimirskogo yuridicheskogo instituta.-2012.-4(26).-S.187-191.

Correct link to this article:
just copy this link to clipboard