'The Concepts of 'Culture' and 'Civilization' as a Mean of Problematisation of Modern Socio-Humanitarian Disciplines' Philosophy and Culture nbpublish.com
Please select your language to translate the article

You can just close the window to don't translate
Your profile

Kuznetsov A.M. The Concepts of 'Culture' and 'Civilization' as a Mean of Problematisation of Modern Socio-Humanitarian Disciplines

Published in journal "Philosophy and Culture", 2015-3 in rubric "Philosophy and culture", pages 457-468.

Resume: In his article Kuznetsov studies Leslie White's concept of culture and the definitions of civilization and culture offered by a Russian philosopher Merab Mamardashvili. The analysis of these authors' opinions make modern specialists pay attentino to the difference in the analysis levels. Kuznetsov discovers the main contradiction of Leslie White's theory (universal and multilineal cultural evolution). This conclusion as well as the results of the analysis of 'culture' and 'civilization' definitions offered by different authors have created grounds for the author's approach to the analysis of culture and civilization as a multilevel form of the anthropological universum. The research is based on the principles of complementarity, classification strategy and the main provisions of the systems paradigm including the classical definition of the structure and a number of provisions of social constructivism. The author's special contribution to the research of the topic is the deconstruction of the practice of using the concepts of 'culture' and 'civilization', discovery of their contradictions and ways to overcome these contradictions.
The novelty of the article is caused by the fact that the author analyzes Leslie White's theory of culture from the point of view of the systems paradigm, compares Leslie White's theory to Merab Mamardashvili's concepts of civilization and culture and offers to return the initial integrative meaning to the concepts of culture and civilization but also to compare these concepts at the different levels of interdisciplinary research.

Keywords: interdisciplinarity, culture, civilization, concept, Leslie White, Merab Mamardashvili, cultural studies, systems paradigm, multilineal, consciousness

DOI: 10.7256/1999-2793.2015.3.13943

This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article

Pigalev A.I. Kul'tura kak bytie: istoki i granitsy paradigmy v kontekste tsivilizatsii // Tsivilizatsiya. Voskhozhdenie i slom. M. Nauka. 2003. S. 147-195.
Mostova L.A. Uayt Lesli // Kul'turologiya KhKh vek. Entsiklopediya. M.1996. T. 2. S. 272-275.
Markaryan E.S. Kul'turologicheskaya teoriya L. Uayta i istoricheskiy materializm // Voprosy filosofii. 1986. 2. S. 78-88.
Markaryan E.S. Kul'turologicheskaya teoriya Lesli Uayta i istoricheskiy protsess // Voprosy filosofii. 1966. 2. S. 104-105.
Malinovskiy B. Nauchnaya istoriya kul'tury. O.G.I. M. 1999. 136 s.
Mamardashvili M.K. Soznanie i tsivilizatsiya // Priroda. 1988. 11 S. 57-68.
Komadorova I.V. Kul'tura kak sotsial'nyy fenomen v simvolicheskoy antropologii Lesli A. Uayta. Diss. kand. filosof. n. Naberezhnye Chelny. 1999. 201 s.
Lynsha V.A. Gordon Chayld i amerikanskiy neoevolyutsionizm // Etnograficheskoe obozrenie. 2001. 5. S. 3-17.
Klassen Kh. Dzh. M. Problemy, paradoksy i perspektivy evolyutsionizma internet-resurs www.abuss.narod.ru
Diligenskiy G.G. Konets istorii smena tsivilizatsiy? // Tsivilizatsii. M. 1993. Vyp. 2. S. 44-52.
Girts K. Kak my segodnya dumaem. K etnografii sovremennoy mysli // Etnograficheskoe obozrenie 2007. 2. S. 3-16.
Barne G. E. Moya druzhba s Lesli Uaytom // Lesli Uayt. Izbrannoe: evolyutsiya kul'tury. M. ROSSPEN. 2004. S. S. 5-46
Artanovskiy S. N. Marksistskoe uchenie ob obshchestvennom progresse i "evolyutsiya kul'tury" L. Uayta // Sovremennaya amerikanskaya etnografiya, M., 1963. S. 50-64
Averkieva Yu. P. Istoriya teoreticheskoy mysli v amerikanskoy etnografii. M.: Nauka. 1979. 288 s.
Ryabova A.L. Kul'turologiya Lesli Uayta v kontekste amerikanskoy kul'turantropologii. Diss. na soisk. uch. stepeni kand. filosof. n. Sankt-Peterburg, 2008. 187 s.
Uayt L. Istorizm, evolyutsionizm i funktsionalizm kak tri tipa interpretatsii kul'tury // Izbrannoe: evolyutsiya kul'tury. M. ROSSPEN. 2004. S. 473-504.
Uayt L. Nauka o kul'ture // Uayt Lesli. Izbrannoe: nauka o kul'ture. M.: ROSSPEN. 2004. S.5-462.
Uayt L. Evolyutsionizm i antievolyutsionizm v amerikanskoy etnologicheskoy teorii // Lesli Uayt. Izbrannoe: evolyutsiya kul'tury. M. ROSSPEN. 2004. S. 573-606.
Uayt L. Evolyutsiya kul'tury. Razvitie tsivilizatsii do padeniya Rima // Uayt Lesli. Izbrannoe: evolyutsiya kul'tury. M.: ROSSPEN. 2004. S. 47-606.
Fevr L. Tsivilizatsiya: evolyutsiya slova i gruppy idey // Boi za istoriyu. M.: Nauka. 1991. S. 239-281.
Shpengler O. Zakat Evropy. T. 1: Geshtal't i deystvitel'nost' / Per. s nem. K.A. Svas'yan. M.: Mysl', 1998. 606 s.
Elias N. O protsesse tsivilizatsii: sotsiogeneticheskie i psikhogeneticheskie issledovaniya. T. 1. M., SPb.: 2001. 332 s.
Barrett R.A. The Paradoxical Anthropology of Leslie White // American Anthropologists. 1989. v. 9. P. 986-999.
Beardsley R. An Appraisal of Leslie A. Whites Scholarly Influence // American Anthropologist. 1976. 91. P. 986-999.
Carneiro R.L. Leslie A. White // Totems and Teachers: Perspectives on the History of Anthropology / Ed. S. Silverman. New York: Columbia University Press: 1981. P. 208-252.
Evans-Pritchard, E. E. A History of Anthropological Thought. André Singer, ed. London: Faber and Faber. 1981.218 r.
Hatch E. Theories of Man and Culture. New York: Columbia University Press. 1973. 384 r.
Kroeber A.L., Kluckhohn C. Culture: a critical review of concepts and definition. Papers of the Peabody museum of American archaeology and ethnology 47. Cambridge (Mass.), 1952.
Service E. R. Leslie Alvin White (1900-1975}. American Anthropologist. 1976. 78. R. 612-617.
White L. The Evolution of Culture. New York: McGraw-Hill. 1959
White L. The Concept of Cultural Systems: A Key to Understanding Tribes and Nations. Columbia University Press, 1975. 192 r
Peace W.J. Leslie A. White. Evolution and Revolution in Anthropology. Board of Regents University of Nebraska. 2004. 278 r.
Service E.R. Leslie Alvin White 1900-1975 // American Anthropologist. 1976. V. 78. P. 612-617 (www.aaanet.org).
Schoenmarkers H. The Power of Culture. A Short History of Anthropological Theory about Culture and Power. 2012 (www.rug.nl).
Steward J.H. Theory of Culture Change: the Methodology of Multilinear Evolution. Urbana, 1955. 244 r.
Williams R. Keywords: A Vocabulary of Culture and Society. NY. Oxford University Press. 1983. 343 p.

Correct link to this article:
just copy this link to clipboard