Published in journal "Administrative and municipal law", 2015-1 in rubric "Administrative process and procedure", pages 89-96.

Resume: The author analyzes the administrative proceedings of public authorities in the sphere of cultural heritage in some particular cases (harmonization of projects, licensure of preservation works, carrying out historical-cultural expertise, organization of state protection) and the procedure of appeal against these proceedings. The article reveals the essential problems of the process of appeal (legal expertise), of the legislation in the sphere of cultural heritage objects (relating to regulation of particular actions), of the competencies of the authorized bodies (including the abuse of authority). The author uses the general scientific methods: from the abstract to the concrete, induction, deduction, analysis, synthesis, the comparative-legal method, the system approach. The scientific originality is based on the very formulation of the problem in this sphere, in carrying out of the comparative analysis of the existing legislation and the judicial and administrative practice of this legislation application and in the solutions suggested: the necessity of legal expertise in such cases, the prohibition of substitution of the authorized body by the court, the shortening of the list of “discretionary” authorities of a public body, and of the legislative support of some terms.

Keywords: cultural heritage object, appeal, administrative procedure, discretionary authorities, corruption factor, historical- cultural expertise, preservation works, inclusion in the list, subject of protection, restrictions/burdens.

DOI: 10.7256/1999-2807.2015.1.13929

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

Bibliography:
Ob ob'ektakh kul'turnogo naslediya (pamyatnikakh istorii i kul'tury) narodov Rossiyskoy Federatsii : Federal'nyy zakon ot 25 iyunya 2002 g. ¹ 73-FZ (v red. ot 23 iyulya 2013 g. ¹ 245-FZ) // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federatsii. – 2002. – ¹ 26. – St. 2519; 2013. – ¹ 30 (chast' 1). – St. 4078.
Ob utverzhdenii Polozheniya o poryadke attestatsii ekspertov po provedeniyu gosudarstvennoy istoriko-kul'turnoy ekspertizy : prikaz Ministerstva kul'tury RF ot 26 avgusta 2010 goda ¹ 563 (v red. ot 17 oktyabrya 2011 g. ¹ 1003) // Rossiyskaya gazeta. – 2010. – ¹ 246; Byulleten' normativnykh aktov federal'nykh organov ispolnitel'noy vlasti. – 2011.-¹ 49.
Reshenie Arbitrazhnogo suda Krasnodarskogo kraya ot 8 iyulya 2009 goda po delu ¹ A32-7328/2009-63/171 // Razmeshcheno na ofitsial'nom sayte Vysshego Arbitrazhnogo suda RF. URL.: www.kad.arbitr.ru.
Reshenie Severskogo rayonnogo suda Krasnodarskogo kraya ot 15 iyulya 2014 goda po delu ¹ 2-1156/14 // Razmeshcheno na ofitsial'nom sayte Krasnodarskogo kraevogo suda. URL.: www.kubansud.ru.
Opredelenie Verkhovnogo Suda RF ot 4 dekabrya 2013 goda po delu ¹ 69-APG13-5 // Razmeshcheno na ofitsial'nom sayte Verkhovnogo Suda RF. URL.: www.vsrf.ru.
Reshenie Oktyabr'skogo rayonnogo suda g.Krasnodara ot 19 sentyabrya 2013 goda po zayavleniyu prokurora Zapadnogo okruga g.Krasnodara k GAU KK «Krasnodarkraygosekspertiza»; reshenie Pervomayskogo rayonnogo suda g.Krasnodara ot 15 iyulya 2013 goda po zayavleniyu prokurora Zapadnogo okruga g.Krasnodara k departamentu arkhitektury i gradostroitel'stva m.o. g.Krasnodar // Razmeshcheny na ofitsial'nom sayte Krasnodarskogo kraevogo suda. URL.: www.kubansud.ru.
Reshenie Arbitrazhnogo suda Krasnodarskogo kraya ot 25 sentyabrya 2008 goda po delu ¹ A32-6680/2008-39/132; Reshenie Arbitrazhnogo suda Krasnodarskogo kraya ot 17 noyabrya 2009 goda ¹ A32-21579/2008-5/295; Reshenie Arbitrazhnogo suda Krasnodarskogo kraya ot 17 marta 2010 goda po delu ¹ A32-55816/2009-63/1023 i pr. // Razmeshcheno na ofitsial'nom sayte Vysshego Arbitrazhnogo suda RF. URL.: www.kad.arbitr.ru.
Reshenie Arbitrazhnogo suda Krasnodarskogo kraya ot 31 yanvarya 2007 goda po delu ¹ A32-8172/2006-50/1 // Razmeshcheno na ofitsial'nom sayte Vysshego Arbitrazhnogo suda RF. URL.: www.kad.arbitr.ru.
Postanovlenie Pyatnadtsatogo apellyatsionnogo suda ot 15 iyulya 2013 goda po delu ¹ A32-18248/2012 // Razmeshcheno na ofitsial'nom sayte Vysshego Arbitrazhnogo suda RF. URL.: www.kad.arbitr.ru.
Reshenie Arbitrazhnogo suda Krasnodarskogo kraya ot 22 dekabrya 2012 goda po delu ¹ A32-21193/2012 // Razmeshcheno na ofitsial'nom sayte Vysshego Arbitrazhnogo suda RF. URL.: www.kad.arbitr.ru.
Reshenie Oktyabr'skogo rayonnogo suda g.Krasnodara ot 24 iyunya 2014 goda po isku gr-ki Petrenko G.V. k gr-nu Trofimovskomu A.I., IP Shamsha E.P., IP Elizarovoy I.Yu. o demontazhe vyveski // Razmeshcheno na ofitsial'nom sayte Krasnodarskogo kraevogo suda. URL.: www.kubansud.ru.
Ob utverzhdenii Polozheniya o gosudarstvennoy istoriko-kul'turnoy ekspertize : Postanovlenie Pravitel'stva RF ot 15 iyulya 2009 goda ¹ 569 ( v red. ot 4 sentyabrya 2012 g. ¹ 880) // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federatsii. – 2009. – ¹ 30. – St. 3812; 2012. – ¹ 37. – St. 5000.
Reshenie Arbitrazhnogo suda Krasnodarskogo kraya ot 15 avgusta 2012 goda po delu ¹ A32-17829/2011 // Razmeshcheno na ofitsial'nom sayte Vysshego Arbitrazhnogo suda RF. URL.: www.kad.arbitr.ru.
Reshenie Arbitrazhnogo suda Krasnodarskogo kraya ot 18 maya 2011 goda po delu ¹ A32-25849/2010 // Razmeshcheno na ofitsial'nom sayte Vysshego Arbitrazhnogo suda RF. URL.: www.kad.arbitr.ru.
Reshenie Arbitrazhnogo suda Krasnodarskogo kraya ot 2 fevralya 2011 goda po delu ¹ A32-31326/2010-36/753 // Razmeshcheno na ofitsial'nom sayte Vysshego Arbitrazhnogo suda RF. URL.: www.kad.arbitr.ru.
Reshenie Arbitrazhnogo suda Krasnodarskogo kraya ot 19 sentyabrya 2011 goda po delu ¹ A32-37144/10 // Razmeshcheno na ofitsial'nom sayte Vysshego Arbitrazhnogo suda RF. URL.: www.kad.arbitr.ru.
Ob organizatsii predostavleniya gosudarstvennykh i munitsipal'nykh uslug : Federal'nyy zakon ot 27 iyulya 2010 goda ¹ 210-FZ (v red. ot 21.07.2014 g. ¹ 263-FZ) // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federatsii. – 2010. – ¹ 31. – St. 4179; 2014. – ¹ 30 (Chast' 1). – St. 4264.
Ob utverzhdenii administrativnykh reglamentov upravleniya gosudarstvennoy okhrany ob'ektov kul'turnogo naslediya Krasnodarskogo kraya «Soglasovanie razmeshcheniya i (ili) ustanovki, a takzhe ekspluatatsii reklamnykh konstruktsiy, afish, vyvesok, televizionnykh antenn, elektricheskikh i telefonnykh kabeley, ventilyatsionnykh sistem i inogo oborudovaniya v otnoshenii ob'ektov kul'turnogo naslediya» : prikaz upravleniya po okhrane, restavratsii i ekspluatatsii istoriko-kul'turnykh tsennostey (naslediya) Krasnodarskogo kraya ot 24.05.2012 g. ¹ 50 // Razmeshchen na ofitsial'nom sayte organa. URL.: uorn.krasnodar.ru.

Correct link to this article:
just copy this link to clipboard
Berlizov M.P. The problems of administrative procedure of the legislation in the sphere of cultural heritage objects application (Krasnodarskiy kray case study). // Administrative and municipal law. - 2015. - ¹ 1. - pp. 89-96. DOI: 10.7256/1999-2807.2015.1.13929