Ðóñ Eng Cn Translate this page:
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

Back to contents

Culture and Art
Reference:

Khrenov, N. A. Between the Linear Principle and the Cyclic Principle: Art History From the Point of View of Pitirim Sorokin’s Social Dynamics

Abstract: The article touches upon one of the most topical issues in the methodology of art history. The absolute priority given in the history research to the linear principle which genesis goes back to the age of Enlightenment has made art historians to pay more attention to certain periods while leaving other periods without adequate interpretations. This, above all, refers to the period of the archaic ancient art, medieval art and Byzantine art. In the latter case art is perceived as declining and not demonstrating complete or definite artwork as it seemed. This is the reason why those periods in art history were rarely studied. As the science that was formed in the age of Enlightenment, esthetics took the exclusive Renaissance art as the starting point in the art development. The same situation had continued until historians discovered the alternative principle in the historical process, in particular, the cyclic principle the present article is devoted to. Even though the interest towards that principle already developed in the 19th century, most efficiently the principle was used in woks by the Russian scientist Pitirim Sorokin who started his academic career as a social scientist. The author of the article emphasizes the important role of Pitirim Sorokin’s major work on social and cultural dynamics in the development of the cultural science. The article shows how the Russian scientist gradually proceeded to the discovery and substantiation of the cyclic principle, how Sorokin applied the aforesaid principle to his historical research of art in his work on social and cultural dynamics has become so famous today and, most importantly, how the principle can be used to eliminate the unexplored facts (so called ‘white spots’) in art studies. In addition, Pitirim Sorokin’ work that is unparalleled anywhere in the world science allows to solve some difficulties that may arise in modern art studies. Meanwhile, when the work was first published, it was not understood or appraised as it deserved. However, the modern situation in the development of the cultural science makes Pitirim Sorokin’s work highly important.


Keywords:

Cultural dynamics, cultural history, art history, crisis of culture, linear principle, cyclic principle, short periods of time, long periods of time, sensual culture, rational culture.


This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article

This article written in Russian. You can find original text of the article here .
References
1. Bazen Zh. istoriya istorii iskusstva. Ot Vazari do nashi dney. M., 1995;
2. Bel'ting Kh. Obraz i kul't. Istoriya obraza do epokhi iskusstva. M., 2002;
3. Berdyaev N. Filosofiya svobody. Smysl tvorchestva. M., 1989;
4. Brodel' F. Istoriya i obshchestvennye nauki. Istoricheskaya dlitel'nost' // Filosofiya i metodologiya istorii. M., 1977;
5. Burkkhardt Ya. Kul'tura Italii v epokhu Vozrozhdeniya. M., 1996;
6. Bryusov V. Sobranie sochineniy v 7 t., t.
7. , M., 1975; 7. Vipper B. Iskusstvo Drevney Gretsii. M., 1972;
8. Dvorzhak M. Istoriya iskusstva kak istoriya dukha. SPb., 2001;
9. Zavadskaya E. Kul'tura Vostoka v sovremennom mire. M., 1977;
10. Zedl'mayr Kh. Utrata serediny. M., 2008;
11. Iskusstvo v situatsii smeny tsiklov. Mezhdistsiplinarnye issledovaniya kul'tury v perekhodnykh protsessakh. M., 2002 (Otvetstvennyy redaktor N. A. Khrenov);
12. Kessidi F. Ot mifa k logosu. M., 1972;
13. Kozer L. O Pitirime Sorokine // Sorokin P. Krizis nashego vremeni. M., 2009;
14. Konrad N. Polibiy i Syma Tsyan' // Konrad N. Zapad i Vostok. M., 1972;
15. Leont'ev K. Vizantizm i slavyanstvo // Leont'ev K. Vostok, Rossiya i slavyanstvo. t. 1., M., 1885;
16. Merton R. Sotsial'naya teoriya i sotsial'naya struktura. M., 2006;
17. Muratov P. Drevnerusskaya zhivopis'. Istoriya otkrytiya i issledovaniya. M., 2005;
18. Nitsshe F. Sochineniya. V 2-kh t., t. 1. M., 1990;
19. Osipov G. Tri vstrechi s P. Sorokinym // Sorokin P. Krizis nashego vremeni. M., 2009;
20. Perekhodnye protsessy v russkoy khudozhestvennoy kul'ture . Novoe i Noveyshee vremya. M., 2003 (Otvetstvennyy redaktor N. A. Khrenov);
21. Palomnichestvo Germana Gesse v stranu Vostoka // Vostok-Zapad. Issledovaniya. Perevody. publikatsii., M., 1882;
22. Panofskiy E. Idea. K istorii ponyatiya v teoriya iskusstva ot antichnosti do klassitsizma. SPb., 1999;
23. Sorokin P. Sistema sotsiologii. V 2-kh t., M., 1993;
24. Sorokin P. Sotsiologicheskie teorii sovremennosti. M., 1992;
25. Sorokin P. Sotsial'naya i kul'turnaya dinamika. Issledovanie izmeneniy v bol'shikh sistemakh iskusstva, istiny, etiki, prava i obshchestvennykh otnosheniy. SPb., 2000;
26. Sorokin P. Krizis nashego vremeni. M., 2009;
27. Sorokin P. Chelovek. Tsivildizatsiya. Obshchestvo. M., 1992;
28. Sorokin P. Obzor tsiklicheskikh kontseptsiy sotsial'no-istoricheskogo protsessa // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. 1998., ¹ 11;
29. Sorokin P. Sotsial'naya dinamika i evolyutsionizm // Amerikanskaya sotsiologicheskaya mysl'. M., 1994;
30. Florenskiy P. Sochineniya. V 4-kh t., t. 1. M., 1994;
31. Kheyzinga Y. Teni zavtrashnego dnya. Chelovek i kul'tura. Zatemnennyy mir. SPb., 2010;
32. Khrenov N. Izbrannye raboty po kul'turologii. Kul'tura i imperiya. M., 2014;
33. Tsiklicheskie ritmy v istorii, kul'ture, iskusstve (Otvetstvennyy redaktor N. A. Khrenov)., M., 2004;
34. Shelling F. Vvedenie v filosofiyu mifologii. V 2-kh t., SPb., 2013;
35. Shpengler O. Zakat Evropy. Ocherki morfologii mirovoy istorii. M., 1993;
36. Shubart V. Evropa i dusha Vostoka. M., 1997;
37. Yaspers K. Nitsshe. Vvedenie v ponimanie ego filosofstvovaniya. SPb., 2004
38. A. V. Makeenkova Fenomeny «klassicheskogo» i «sovremennogo»
39. v istorii izobrazitel'nogo iskusstva // Kul'tura i iskusstvo. - 2013. - 2. - C. 215 - 227. DOI: 10.7256/2222-1956.2013.02.10.