'The Conceptualization of Theoretical and Methodological Bases of Comparative Jurisprudence in the Works of Jean Louis Eugène Lerminier' Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law nbpublish.com
Eng
Please select your language to translate the article


You can just close the window to don't translate
Library
Your profile

A.V. Kresin The Conceptualization of Theoretical and Methodological Bases of Comparative Jurisprudence in the Works of Jean Louis Eugène Lerminier

Published in journal "Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law", 2012-6 , pages 99-118.

Resume: The article is devoted to the analysis of the biography and most valuable works of Eugène Lerminier (1803- 1857) the chair of general and philosophic history of comparative legislations in the College de France (1831- 1849) the first chair of the comparative jurisprudence character in the world. The author reconstructs the development of philosophical and historical approaches to the comprehension of law in the works of Eugène Lerminier and the formation of his comparative methodological approach, the methodic of comparative-legal investigation, the grounds of comparative legal history and elements of the philosophy of comparative jurisprudence, new conceptual vision of national law and interaction between legal systems. The author comes to the conclusion that Eugène Lerminier formulated comparative-legal approach around 1836 in the context of teaching the history of comparative legislations and the new system of legal sciences construction, proves that this approach is the original set of ideas and concepts, created on the ground of critical reassessment of historical school ideas as well as German and French legal philosophy trends of the early XIX century.

Keywords: comparative jurisprudence, comparative law, comparative legislation, comparative legal history, comparative approach, legal philosophy, institutionalization of comparative jurisprudence.

This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article

Bibliography:
1. Taranovskiy F. Sravnitel'noe pravovedenie v kontse Kh?Kh veka // Por?vnyal'ne pravoznavstvo: Antolog?ya
ukra?ns'ko? komparativ?stiki Kh?Kh-KhKh stol?t' / Za red. O.V. Kres?na. K.: ?nstitut derzhavi ? prava ?m.
V.M. Korets'kogo NAN Ukra?ni, Vidavnitstvo Logos, 2008. S. 182, 195.
2. HugW. The history of comparative law // Harvardilawireview. 1931-1932. Vol. 45. P. 1061.
3. David R., Zhoffre-Spinozi K. Osnovnye pravovye sistemy sovremennosti / Per. s fr. i predisl. V.A. Tuma-
nova. M.: Mezhdunar. otnosheniya, 1999. S. 9.
4. Konstantinesko L.-Zh. Razvitie sravnitel'nogo pravovedeniya // Ocherki sravnitel'nogo prava: Sbornik /
Sost., perevod i vstup. stat'ya V.A. Tumanova. M.: Progress, 1981. S. 120.
5. Tsvaygert K., Ketts Kh. Vvedenie v sravnitel'noe pravovedenie v sfere chastnogo prava: V 2-kh tt. T. ?: Osnovy:
Per. s nem. M.: Mezhdunar. otnosheniya, 2000. S. 90.
6. Fauvarque-Cosson B. Development of comparative law in France // The Oxford handbook of comparative law / Ed. by
M. Reimann, R. Zimmermann. New York: Oxford University press, 2006. P. 41.
7. Lafitskiy V.I. Sravnitel'noe pravovedenie v obrazakh prava. T. ?. M.: Statut, 2010. S. 68.
8. Kres?n O.V. Pitannya kriter??v pri vivchenn? genezi por?vnyal'nogo pravoznavstva // Por?vnyal'ne pravoznav-
stvo: suchasniy stan ? perspektivi rozvitku: Zb. naukovikh prats' / Za red. Yu.S. Shemshuchenka, ?.S. Gritsenka,
M.B. Buchka; upor. O.V. Kres?n. K.: Logos, 2010. S. 20-32 (russ. perevod stat'i: Kresin A.V. Kriterii v voprose
o genezise sravnitel'nogo pravovedeniya // Zhurnal zarubezhnogo zakonodatel'stva i sravnitel'nogo pravove-
deniya. 2011. 1)
9. Kres?n O.V. Lerm?n'e Zhan Lu? Ezhen / B?ograf?chniy slovnik os?b, yak? zgaduyut'sya v pratsyakh ukra?ns'kikh
komparativ?st?v Kh?Kh-KhKh st. // Por?vnyal'ne pravoznavstvo: Antolog?ya ukra?ns'ko? komparativ?stiki Kh?Kh-KhKh
stol?t' / Za red. O.V. Kres?na. K.: ?nstitut derzhavi ? prava ?m. V.M. Korets'kogo NAN Ukra?ni, Vidavnitstvo
Logos, 2008. S. 360; i dr.
10. Lerminier J.-L.-E. De Possessione analytica savignianeae doctrinae expositio, dissertatio juridica inauguralis, quam
die XIII julii 1827. Parisiis: typis E. Guiraudet, 1827. IV, 144 p.
11. Navet G. Eugéne Lerminier (1803-1857): La science du droit comme synthése de lhistoire et de la philosophie //
Revue dhistoire des sciences humaines. 2001. Vol. 1. No. 4. P. 34.
12. Ordonnance du Roi qui crée au collége de France une chaire dhistoire générale et philosophique des législations
comparées // Bulletin des lois du Royaume de France. IXe série. Régne de Louis-Philippe Ier, Roi des Français.
T. II. Partie II. P.: De L-Imprimerie royale, 1831. P. 331.
13. Audren F., Navet G. Note sur la carrière dEugène Lerminier au Collège de France (1831-1849) // Revue dhistoire des
sciences humaines. 2001. Vol. 1. No. 4. P. 59.
14. Le Collége de France. Quelques donnés sur son histoire et son caractére propre // Annuaire du Collége de France.
2005-2006. 106eannée. P., 2006. R. 7 [Elektronnyy resurs] // Sayt CollégedeFrance. Rezhim dostupa: www.
college-de-france.fr/media/cours-et-travaux/UPL4814_Annuaire_introduction.pdf
15. Smith B.G. The Rise and Fall of Eugène Lerminier // French Historical Studies. 1982. Vol. 12. No. 3. P. 377.
16. Lerminier E. De lenseignement des législations comparées // Ėtudes dhistoire et de philosophie. T. II. Paris:
Charpentier, Libraire-Ėditeur, 1836. R. 12.
17. Eugene Lerminier [Elektronnyy resurs] // ?nternet-sayt Corpus des OEuvres de Philosophie en Langue française.
Rezhim dostupa: www.corpus-philo.fr/notice_lerminier.html
18. Lermimier E. Dix ans denseigment. Paris: Librairie de Ch. Gosselin, 1839. P. 20.
19. Notice de Victor Cousin [Elektronnyyresurs] / Sayt Philo19. Base de donnèes bibliographiques sur la philosophie
française du XIXe siècle. Rezhimdostupa: www.textesrares.com/philo19/noticeCousin.php
20. Tableau des chaires depuis 1800 // Annuaire du Collége de France. 2005-2006. 106eannée. P., 2006. R. 30 [Elek-
tronnyy resurs] // Sayt CollégedeFrance. Rezhim dostupa: www.college-de-france.fr/media/cours-et-travaux/
UPL4814_Annuaire_introduction.pdf
21. Delmas-Marty M. Ėtudes juridiques comparatives et internationalisation du droit. P. 4. [Elektronnyy resurs] //
Sayt CollègedeFrance. Rezhim dostupa: www.college-de-france.fr/
22. Adelman J. Republic of Capital: Buenos Aires and the legal transformation of the Atlantic World. Stanford: Stanford
University Press, 1999. R. 170.
23. Audren F., Halpérin J.-L. La science juridique entre politique et sciences humaines (XIXéme XXéme siécles) //
Revue dhistoire des sciences humaines. 2001. Vol. 1. No. 4. P. 3.
24. Lerminier E. Cours dhistoire des législations comparées, professé au Collége de France. Paris: G. Ange et C, [1836].
25. Lerminier E. Lhébraïsme et le christianisme // Revue des Deux Mondes. 1846. T. 16. // Sayt Wikisource.
Labibliothéquelibre [Elektronnyy resurs]. Rezhim dostupa: fr.wikisource.org/wiki/LHébraïsme_et_le_
christianisme
26. Kres?n O.V. Viniknennya ta rannya ?stor?ya por?vnyal'nogo pravoznavstva // Por?vnyal'ne pravoznavstvo. 2012.
1-2. S. 332-345; i dr.
27. Hugo G. Lehrbuch eines civilistischen Cursus, Zweyter Band, welcher das Naturrecht, als eine Philosophie des
positiven Rechts enthalt. Berlin, 1798. S. 10.
28. Mohnhaupt H. Universalgeschichte, Universal-Jurisprudenz und rechtsvergleichende Methode im Werk P.J.A.
Feuerbachs // Rechtsgeschichte in den beiden deutschen Staaten (1988-1990): Beispiele, Parallelen, Positionen / Hrsg.
Von H. Mohnhaupt. Frankfurt am Main: Klostermann, 1991. S. 102.
29. Rapetti P.N. Cours de lègislations comparèes, Discours douverture. Paris: Cosson, 1842; Rapetti P.N. Discours
prononcè a louverture du Cours de lègislation comparèe du dècembre 1843. Paris: Fau, Thunot, 1844.

Correct link to this article:
just copy this link to clipboard