Editor-in-Chief's column
Reference:
Gurevich, P. S.
Reform VS Revolution
// Philosophy and Culture.
2013. ¹ 7.
P. 883-888.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=62936
Abstract:
At the end of XIX century Japan was about to jump from feudalism into a modern world. How
would it be possible to perform such transformation in history? Experience of Europe mostly showed that it
would be impossible without a social revolution. As many social philosophers assumed, only a social revolution
could enable a fast shift from one socio-economic system to another. Of course social reformation was
also taken into account, but it was believed that only social revolution would break the ties of traditions.
From the political point of view, all revolutions need a destruction or neutralization of inner enemies as well
as forces incompatible with their historical orientation. A revolution would never be over unless that target
was achieved. At the end of the century Japan dreamt of coming back to the Emperor’s reign. As a famous
American researcher R. Benedict noted, Japanese tried to protect Japan from the influence of the other world
and come back to the golden epoch of X century when the government was not ‘shared’ by the Emperor
and Shogun. R. Benedict meant Meiji Restoration’s reforms (1867-1868) — so called bourgeois revolution in
Japan when the institution of ‘shared government’ was eliminated and the Emperor’s power was restored.
However, many Japanese did not like such outcome.
Keywords:
philosophy, reform, revolution, history, society, evolutionism, social studies, politics, management, economics.
Spiritual and moral search
Reference:
Prokofiev, A. V.
The Role of Reactive Anti-Altruistic Emotions in Psychological Experience
of Justice
// Philosophy and Culture.
2013. ¹ 7.
P. 889-899.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=62937
Abstract:
The author of the article analyzes issues arising from the fact that psychological experience of justice
includes reactive altruistic emotions. Such emotions apparently contradict to the central idea of morals —
a demand to perform self-initiated altruistic actions. Some philosophers of morals and moralists eliminate
this contradiction trying to prove the thesis that true justice has nothing to do with reactive anti-altruistic
feelings such as indignation and, in particular, envy and rancor. The author of the article uses results of various
researches in social psychology, socio-biology and psychology of moral development proving that that
aforesaid statement is wrong. However, this connection does not demean psychological experience of justice
because both envious and rancorous emotional impulses are held back and considerably transformed in the
process of moral development.
Keywords:
philosophy, ethics, morals, psychology of morals, socio-biology, justice, emotions, envy, indignation, rancor.
The issues of holistic world
Reference:
Popov, E. A.
Modern Society and Corruption Issues: Ontological and Axiological Aspects
// Philosophy and Culture.
2013. ¹ 7.
P. 900-906.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=62938
Abstract:
The article is devoted to patters and reasons of corruption drastically becoming the part of human
spiritual life and his system of values. The author of the article focuses on socio-cultural factors of corruption
development and fixation in social life. Special attention is paid at the need to research this anti-social and
illegal phenomenon of corruption from the point of view of socio-humanitarian science and philosophy of
science. The author particularly underlines how important the opinion of modern society on corruption and
philosophical evaluation of an ontological status of corruption are. These aspects are paid special attention
and these moments are to be taken into account by experts and researchers in the sphere of law.
Keywords:
philosophy, corruption, power, society, state institution, values, norms, community, meaning, culture.
Space and time
Reference:
Korolev, S. A.
Fundamental Historical Processes in Russia: Retro- and Perspective
// Philosophy and Culture.
2013. ¹ 7.
P. 907-925.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=62939
Abstract:
The article describes peculiarities of fundamental historical processes in Russian government.
These fundamental processes include colonization, modernization and globalization. The author of the article
provides definitions of the mentioned processes and reveal what they mean. The author analyzes these processes in the ‘space-time’, ‘center-periphery’, ‘extensive-intensive’, ‘vertical-horizontal’ coordinates. Special
attention is paid t peculiarities of the Russian space and time and the influence of the Russian space-time
continuum on fundamental historical transformations. It is stated that there are certain Russian historical
(but not only geographical) conditions, circumstances and mechanisms of development of these processes.
One of the defining moments here is a frequent appearance of the phenomenon of pseudomorphosis in Russian
history. This makes it the method and type of development in Russia and for Russia. Besides that, the
author analyzes the influence of an active historical person on how the aforesaid fundamental processes go
as well as the role of violence in colonization and modernization projects and forms of opposition to emanation
of violence.
Keywords:
colonization, modernization, globalization, space, time, center, periphery, extensity, violence, opposition.
Philosophy of knowledge
Reference:
Agafonova, O. V.
Constructive-Epistemological Analysis of Lev Tolstoy’s Philosophy of Art
// Philosophy and Culture.
2013. ¹ 7.
P. 926-931.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=62940
Abstract:
The article is devoted to the analysis of Lev Tolstoy’s philosophical thoughts and diary notes on
philosophy of art as well as his critics of interpretation of art as a mere recognition of beauty. The author of
the article proves that Lev Tolstoy’s definition of art as a mean of communication and exchange of feelings is
still quite topical and demanded nowadays for a modern understanding of the relations between philosophy,
religion, art and science as well as development of particular methods of humanitarian science and philosophy
of culture.
Keywords:
philosophy, epistemology, constructivism, radicalism, realism, art, Lev Tolstoy, beauty, feeling, communication.
Value and truth
Reference:
Voronin, A. A.
Condition of Choice and Choice of Conditions
// Philosophy and Culture.
2013. ¹ 7.
P. 932-941.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=62941
Abstract:
The author of the article raises a question whether it is actually possible to create a general theory
of human behavior, and makes an attempt to outline the area of valid analysis of such a theory. Choice is
viewed as a concrete union of external conditions and internal motives. Conscious choice is not the same as
the rational choice because consciousness is not the same as rationality. The author of the article focuses on
the analysis of organization of consciousness in mass culture and its relation with the socio-cultural environment.
A classical dilemma of the rational (Kant) and fideistic (Kierkegaard) grounds of moral choice does
not work in a modern situation. Differentiation of rationality and philosophizing is interpreted as a deep
socio-cultural shift that caused changed in social mind along with the other factors such as forced inconsistency
and axiological reorientation of the society. The author also developed the definitions of ‘identification
matrix’ as a ‘cell’ of self-consciousness of homo-demos and offered particular terms for describing true collisions
of human facing the problem of choice.
Keywords:
choice, environment, motive, rationality, values, self-consciousness, identity, identification matrix, mass society, philosophizing.
Philosophy and culture
Reference:
Bliskavitsky, A. A.
Symbol and Myth in Vyacheslav Ivanov’s Philosophy
// Philosophy and Culture.
2013. ¹ 7.
P. 942-950.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=62942
Abstract:
The article is devoted to the problem of symbol and myth in Vyacheslav Ivanov’s philosophy. The
author of the article defines peculiarities of philosophy of a Russian symbolist conditioned by his believing
in the priority of belief and the second role of the rational thinking. The author describes peculiarities of
the Medieval perception of the world that was reflected in Ivanov’s philosophy, too. The author also studies
Vyacheslav Ivanov’s definition of symbol and the difference between Ivanov’s philosophy and French
symbolism. The author describes several features of Friedrich Schelling’s works which made a considerable
influence on Vyacheslav Ivanov as well. Studying Ivanov’s interpretation of myth from the point of view of
its relation to a symbol, the author makes a hypothesis about special antinomic unity of symbol and myth.
The author describes Ivanov’s thoughts on communicative features of myth and views the problem of the
language expression of symbol as well as symbolic features of language.
Keywords:
philosophy, symbolism, theurgy, esthetics, beauty, myth, art, mystery, language, artist.
Religions and religious renaissance
Reference:
Fisher, N.
Concerning the Future of Metaphysics and the Question about God According to Immanuel
Kant (with Insights into Martin Heidegger’s Critics). Translated by Kirsberg, I. V.
// Philosophy and Culture.
2013. ¹ 7.
P. 951-966.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=62943
Abstract:
Kant’s critical metaphysics is described in three chapters against the old and new tradition (Plato,
Aristotle, Anselm, Foma Akvinsky, Heidegger, Levinas) as the anticipation of future metaphysics. By origin
Heidegger’s philosophy has much in common not only with the Christian beliefs and theology but also Kant’s
metaphysics Thus, a famous remark about the language from a conversation with a Japanese makes us refer
to Kant. The expression shows that origin always means future to come.
Keywords:
philosophy, critical metaphysics, mind, theology, rational theology, belief, prosyllogisms, paralogisms, evidence of God’s existence, Kant’s philosophy.
Ethics
Reference:
Mekhed, G. N.
The Problem of Theodicy in Kant’s and Dostoevsky’s Ethics
// Philosophy and Culture.
2013. ¹ 7.
P. 967-973.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=62944
Abstract:
The article is devoted to theodicy and its role in Kant’s and Dostoevsky’s philosophies. The author of
the article tries to show that the problem of theodicy appeared in Kant’s and Dostoevsky’s work as a part of
the question about the moral ideal, freedom and responsibility. Despite different approaches and quite obvious
difference in their concepts of rationality as well as philosophizing methods, both of these philosophers have
many topics in common. In particular, they both talked about the relation between the absolute and personal
freedom, from one side, and the problem of the moral idea form the other. Both Kant and Dostoevsky were
also interested in the problem of self-will and how it relates to freedom and autonomy. However, despite the
philosophers’ belief that it was impossible to solve the problem of theodicy, the author shows that Kant and
Dostoevsky had very different definitions of freedom as well as borders and logic of moral reasoning.
Keywords:
philosophy, ethics, Kant, Dostoevsky, theodicy, freedom, absolute, autonomy, ideal, morals.
Axiology: values and relics
Reference:
Koptseva, N. P., Lozinskaya, V. P., Makhonina, A. A.
The Problem of Cultural Values and its
Solution in Heinrich Rickert’s Philosophy
// Philosophy and Culture.
2013. ¹ 7.
P. 974-984.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=62945
Abstract:
The article contains a review of modern Russian researches devoted to categorical analysis and
philosophical-cultural research of the terms ‘value’ and ‘cultural value’. The topic about cultural values is
proved to be important for our modern Russian philosophy of culture and theory of culture. According to the
author of the article, it would be perspective to conduct the kind of researches that would search for the solution
of the axiological crisis of modern Russian culture. The author also makes an assumption that Heinrich
Rickert’s philosophy of culture could help to find the conceptual and methodological grounds for the supposition
that cultural values are the priority in all spheres of existence of a modern Russian society. The author
also points out that cultural values have a transcendental existence in culture.
Keywords:
cultural studies, cultural values, ideals, axiology, Heinrich Rickert, methodology of culture, methods, humanitarian sciences, theory of culture, individualizing method.
Self-consciousness and identity
Reference:
Ryabushkina, T. M.
Self-Reflection of the Knower
// Philosophy and Culture.
2013. ¹ 7.
P. 985-995.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=62946
Abstract:
A classical concept about self-knowledge as the ‘appeal of the knower to himself’ (reflection) faces a difficulty:
in order to make it possible for one to understand himself by the means of reflection, it is necessary for him
to have the basic knowledge about his own structures (such as temporality and intentionality) allowing to state that
it is him who is being the object of reflection. Spontaneous features of the knower create the grounds for credibility
of facts discovered during the process of reflection. As a result, a gap between the knower and the other world can
be created. The author of the article shows that critics of the Cartesian paradigm, caused by the above difficulties,
is limited to subject-object relations and does not touch upon reflection as the process requiring certain knowledge
about ourselves. As a result, concepts that do not take into account the role of the knower are dependent on reflective
structures and certain difficulties caused by these structures. In order to overcome these difficulties we need to deny
the supposition about initial equivalence of the knower and the object of self-knowledge.
Keywords:
philosophy, subject, reflection, consciousness, self-consciousness, knowledge, intentionality, phenomenology, temporality, self-objectivation.
Philosophy of technology
Reference:
Nikitaev, V. V.
Marx, Infrastructure of Social Time and Genesis of the ‘Iron Man’
// Philosophy and Culture.
2013. ¹ 7.
P. 996-1003.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=62947
Abstract:
The author of the article views Karl Marx’s contribution to the philosophy of technology from
the point of view of the modern state of development of this philosophy and discovery of certain ideas in
Marx’s studies which could appear to be significant in XXI century. The author discusses the role of machines
in transformation of labor structure, birth of the ‘iron man’ who opposed an ‘alive’ worker in the
production process. It is shown that this event, which is paid much attention in Marx’s teaching, was possible
only under conditions of the ‘infrastructure of social time’ ensured by working hours and schedules.
In its turn, technological progress caused revolutionary changes in old infrastructures and creation of
new ones. Infrastructure introduced a global element into technology, inevitably changed and continues
to change our social life.
Keywords:
philosophy, machine, time, labor, capitalism, hours, time, infrastructure, Marx, Hegel.
History of ideas and teachings
Reference:
Mikhailenko, Yu. P.
Adam Smith: Becoming a Scientist. Part 1
// Philosophy and Culture.
2013. ¹ 7.
P. 1004-1019.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=62948
Abstract:
Adam Smith was lucky to receive brilliant and versatile education. He received his primary education
in his native Scottish town Kirkcaldy and then studied in such great universities as the University
of Glasgow and Oxford. In 1759 he published his first significant work that made him famous. Then Smith
gave lectures at universities in his native land — those were lectures in ethics, law, politics and economics.
At the University of Glasgow Smith actively participated in the first political economy club ever created.
In 1764-1767 Smith and his student visited Paris where Smith got an opportunity to expand his knowledge
communicating with famous intellectual leaders of the time such as Turgot and others. In 1767-1776 Smith
created his most significant work ‘The Wealth of Nations’ that gave him the fame of the pioneer of classical
English political economy. However, Smith did not manage to solve the contradiction between the two most
important categories in his works — altruism and egoism. Studying the history of ideas, Smith disagreed
with Plato’s and Aristotle’s conception about inherited differences between people and talked about natural
equality of all people instead.
Keywords:
philosophy, University of Glasgow, Watt, Yum, Pitt, egoism, altruism, Protagoras, Socrates, Plato, Aristotle.
The stream of books
Reference:
Gurevich, P. S.
Spiritual Experience of the Nation
// Philosophy and Culture.
2013. ¹ 7.
P. 1020-1027.
URL: https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=62949
Abstract:
A hundred years ago positivism ruled in the science of history. Followers of positivism believed
that elements of the truth could be easily found in concrete sources and described facts about the past life.
But is it actually the only way to discover the order of events in history? Positivists denied all other approaches.
They believed that first historians had to discover as many facts as possible, search for different
sources, if possible, and only then build the cause-and-reason relations that could help to describe laws of
historical development. The book ‘Selected publications 70’ by a famous expert in Russian philosophy, history
and culture Mikhail Gromov is some kind of a self-report devoted to Gromov’s 70th birthday. The book
is full of facts about Russian history. But there is no positivistic manner to collect particular details, events
and dates there. Even though Mikhail Gromov is a true historian, he is also a philosopher so the question
about research methods appears in the very first paragraph of his book. Based on Mikhail Gromov, Russian
philosophy can be viewed using different research methods while none of these methods can be the
only ‘correct’ one. Yet, altogether these methods reveal a perspective for creation of broad and adequate
understanding of the historical process.
Keywords:
philosophy, history, value, art, peasantry, Orthodoxy, creativity, culture, spirituality, Hesychasm.