ARCHIVE
Reference:
V.M. Artemov. (2009). The Problem of Correlation of Morality and Law in the
Context of Value-Based Dimension of Truth. LEX RUSSICA (Russian Law), 4, 815–823. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=59761
Abstract:
Being the main goal of scientific knowledge, the truth simultaneously
appears as value of social and cultural being, symbolizes power and abilities of
man with regard to theoretical and practical activity. The latter, especially when
it comes to improvement of political and legal relationships and institutes, implies
not only objective knowledge about things as they are, but some ideal
meaning. This also includes ideas about things that could be positively meaningful
from the point of view of morally trusted ideal. In its turn, a more or less
complete implementation of such ideal is not possible without longing for truth
and adequate trustworthy knowledge. In the post-non-classical era of scientific,
especially social and humanitarian knowledge, classical (correspondent) understanding
of truth must match a more solid than ever before account of valuebased
and meaning-based factors.
With regard to legal theory and practice, it is important, by fully considering
the real pattern of correlation of morality and law, to carry out a consistent
axiological, humanistically oriented of certain results but of projects aiming
modify legislation. Essentially, the core of personal responsibility and professional
competence in this regard is equally determined by practically proven
knowledge about man and society and by positive charge of conduct signposted
with rules of morality.
Despite apparent efficiency of formally legal mechanisms intended for
solving various social and individual conflicts in the modern Russia, it is moral
and ethical notions and principles that remain to be crucial as far as promotion of
justice is concerned and also with regard to relatively painless solving of the said
conflicts and purely human problems. Considering particular features of national
culture and philosophy, we ought to seek not the minimum but the maximum of
morality of law. Including the insight into the truth, this attitude allows to see
positive perspectives of further expansion and convergence of the said forms of
social regulation. This is how value-based dimension of the truth is revealed in
general.
Keywords:
pravo, istina, filosofiya
ARCHIVE
Reference:
L.L. Popov, Y.I. Migachev. (2009). Information-Oriented Society: Problems of
Culture, Ecology and Law Development. LEX RUSSICA (Russian Law), 4, 824–836. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=59762
Abstract:
In this article the author surveys the problems connected with passing of
humanity to the information-oriented society which have a new structure where
the main role is taken by the departments which are closely linked with receiving,
spreading and handling the information and that leads to the transformation
of human being. Information and knowledge becomes more significant factors of
production and motive power of economical development and the well-being of
the society.
Information-oriented society is going to replace industrialized society,
and it have some specific features such as in the main new technological way of
reproduction of the whole system of human relations and temper of intercommunication
between human, technics and nature.
This article focuses on the four internal connected fundamental features
of the forming Information-oriented society:
Change of the information and knowledge role in human society which
expressed prima facie in unprecedented increasing informational saturation of
economic, administrating, law enforcement and other activity spheres and transformation
of the information and knowledge to the main source of the socialeconomical
development.
Transformation of the information industry to the most dynamic, profitable
and prestigious productive branch, which provides the leading role of detached
countries and cities in the world economy system.
Origin of advanced market infrastructure of information and informational
services consumption and specifically wide adoption of Information and
Communications Technology (ICT) in different live spheres not only in professional
and domestic at that.
Profound changes in models of social organization and cooperation,
when in all spheres of the society changes of centralized hierarchical structures
to the flexible network types of organization take place, this types of organization
are adept to the rapid sweep and innovative development.
On this ground premises for considerable rise of production efficiency,
economy of the natural resources, environmental protection, passing from stabilization
period to steady development are being created.
This article concludes that in the era of total informatization and creating
of Information-oriented society, united informational space becomes one of the
most stategenerating indication and obligatory term and characteristic of the Information-
oriented society itself.
One of the most objective processes which should be taken into account
by the modern world is globalization, created by explosive development of Information
Technologies, creating of global networks, triumph of market economy,
liberalization of world trade system, transport development. Somehow or other all of this factors leads to the washing out of the political and national borders
and to the acceleration pace of industrialization and unifying of the cultures,
partly at the expense of creating new global conglomerates in information, telecommunication
and leisure spheres. We should bear in mind that globalization
gives not only new opportunities and solutions but it also brings new problems,
such as, financial crisis which should be predicted and considerate in daily activities.
It also concludes that, from the 70s years of the XX century clearly
formed not only planetary scales of industrial society, but the worldwide crisis
also took place and showed up the origin of the humanity global problems. They
revealed itself as an objective factor of development of the modern society in all
regions, touched interests of all humanity and its local dependence could occur
peril to the world society and its future. Difference of the modern situation from
the existing in previous ages is that anthropogenic changes in living milieu have
a negative impact on the human nature, human needs, biological, spiritual and
ecological conditions.
Determination of humanity global problems is possible only in framework
of Information-oriented society.
Keywords:
informatsionnoe obshchestvo, globalizatsiya, finansovo-ekonomicheskii krizis, informatsionnaya sreda, gosudarstvoobrazuyushchii priznak, informatsionno-kommunikativnye tekhnologii
ARCHIVE
Reference:
V.I. Fadeev. (2009). Excerpts from the History of Popular Representation:
Formation of Functional Representation. LEX RUSSICA (Russian Law), 4, 837–863. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=59763
Abstract:
Historical and theoretical roots of people’s representation in general
have been thoroughly well known by historians of legal science, but modern research
drawing on the origins of people’s representation is likely to face considerable
difficulties and hazards, which are barely surmountable in order to recreate
an integral, consistent and free of contradictions pattern of formation and
development of functional representation system in the field of public authority.
The author of the article determines which institutions of public authority
have laid foundation of becoming and development of institutes of representation
democracy which should be understood as the starting point of this process
thus directly and indirectly contributing to formation of representation authorities.
The article also addresses a number of other issues, specifically: what
was the precursor of people’s representation, what political institution even in
the very beginning of its existence contained future potential of people’s representation
including the direction of its development.
The author of this article considered the origination of the Cortes in
Spain, formation of the English Parliament and establishment of States General
in France.
The author looking back to historical roots of people’s representation
emerging from the depths of society and expressing in the most clear-cut manner
the idea of people’s sovereignty, the idea of the law as embodiment of common will aiming to achieve the common good, attempts to determine how efficient
people’s representation can be today as far as its social roles are concerned.
Based on historical theory methodology, the author showed how efficiently
people’s representation can contribute to development of democratic
rule, by ensuring public dialogue of people and authorities about directions of
development of society and state and about selection of ways and means of solving
objectives and problems. And to what extent it can organize public movement
intended for serving supreme spiritual goals, creation of healthy statehood
and preventing severance of authorities from society, its full and uncontrolled
domination of society, while ensuring political and personal liberty of human
being.
Keywords:
angliiskii parlament, kortesy, reikhstag i landtagi, zemskie sobory
ARCHIVE
Reference:
V.B. Agafonov. (2009). Main Ways of Improvement of the Russian Federation
Legislation in the Sphere of State Monitoring of the Subsoil Resources Condition. LEX RUSSICA (Russian Law), 4, 864–872. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=59764
Abstract:
State monitoring of the subsoil resources condition is an integral component
of the state environmental monitoring (state ecological monitoring). According
to the Regulations on conducting state monitoring of the condition of the
Russian Federation subsoil resources, approved by Order of the Russian Federation
Ministry of Natural Resources ¹ 433 and dated May 21, 2001, state monitoring
of condition of subsoil resources or geological environment is a system of
regular observations, data collection, compiling, processing and analysis of information,
assessment of the condition of the geological environment and forecast
of its changes under the impact of natural factors, use of subsoil resources
and other types of economic activities. State monitoring of subsoil resources
condition is an integral component (subsystem) of the complex system of the
environmental monitoring.
The Ministry of Natural Resources îf the Russian Federation carries out
the works on state monitoring of the subsoil resources condition in cooperation
with other specially authorized state agencies in the sphere of protection of environment
and nature management.
However, the existing regulation on state monitoring of the subsoil resources
condition, in reality does not have regulatory mechanisms, providing
exercising of power in the state monitoring of the subsoil resources condition by
the Ministry of Natural Resources of the Russian Federation. The existing regulation
also does not enable the state agencies of Krai, Oblast and other local governments
in the Russian Federation to participate in carrying out of the state environmental
monitoring with the right to establish and provide functioning of
territorial systems of observation of the state of environment on their respective
territories, although Article 6 of the Federal Law “On Environmental Protection”
(¹ 7-FZ) dated January 10, 2002 does provide for granting such power to local
governments. It does not also include participation in carrying out of the state
monitoring of the subsoil resources condition, based on the analysis of the Regulations on organization and implementation of the state environmental monitoring,
(state ecological monitoring) approved by Resolution ¹ 177 of the Russian
Federation Government.
This article contains analysis of the existing Russian Federation legislation,
which gives the definition of “state monitoring of the subsoil resources
condition” and states its correlation with the state environmental monitoring
(state ecological monitoring) and requirements to the method of its organization
and carrying out, with the purpose of identifying deficiencies of the legal regulation
in the mentioned area, and, herewith, aiming at development of proposals on
how to improve the existing legislation of the Russian Federation and legislations
of its local governments, related to the problems of state monitoring of
subsoil resources condition.
Keywords:
gosudarstvennyi monitoring sostoyaniya nedr, Ministerstvo prirodnykh resursov i ekologii Rossiiskoi Federatsii, gosudarstvennyi ekologicheskii monitoring, informatsiya o sostoyanii nedr, sistema nablyudeniya za sostoyaniem okruzhayushchei sredy
ARCHIVE
Reference:
N.A. Gromoshina. (2009). Adversary Proceedings on Cases Arising from Public
Legal Relations from the Point of View of Law Enforcement. LEX RUSSICA (Russian Law), 4, 873–900. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=59765
Abstract:
The article deals with the place of the norms of law of civil procedure,
regulating the order of proceedings on the cases arising from public legal relations.
The substantive approach to the differentiation of the procedures in civil
and arbitration procedure according to the peculiarities of law enforcement activities
was chosen as a starting point of this article.
Comparing activity of the court on enforcement of material law in adversary
proceedings and the proceedings arising from public legal relations and
analyzing generally excepted criteria of division of these kinds of proceedings,
as well as characteristics of proceedings arising from public legal relations, the
author comes to the conclusion that the above mentioned categories and characteristics
“do not work,” because they both together as well as separately, may be
typical for the cases, examined both in adversary and special proceedings. In
other words these characteristics in theory or practice do not allow to define
strictly according to what procedure the case is to be tried and solved.
As a result additional argumentation of scientific points of view on inclusion
of norms, regulating proceedings on cases arising from public legal relations
into adversary proceedings was proposed.
Out of categories of cases regarded by the law in force as the proceedings
arising from public legal relations the author separates the cases on invalidation
of normative legal acts because law enforcement activities in these cases
has important special features. Here we do not have all stages of enforcement of
the material law and the court interprets the norms of material law.
After study of the cases on invalidation of normative legal acts through
the prism of law enforcement and finding peculiarities of such law enforcement,
the author came to some conclusions:
First. The author supports the point of view that the procedure of the
court examination of normative acts needs special regulation. Second. If other cases arising from public legal relations are of the same
substance as actionable cases and they are to be classified in a group of special
adversary proceedings, then cases on normocontrol substantively differ from
adversary proceedings and thus have to have their own specific procedure delimited
from adversary proceedings.
Third. The norms, regulating examination of cases on normocontrol
should not be classified in the same subgroup with other cases arising from public
legal relations.
In conclusion the author puts out a proposal to pass the decision of cases
connected with contestable normative acts to the competence of constitutional
(ustavny) courts .
Keywords:
pravoprimenenie, grazhdanskii i arbitrazhnyi protsess, dela iz publichnykh pravootnoshenii, iskovoe proizvodstvo
ARCHIVE
Reference:
G.V. Dashkov. (2009). Problems of Organization and Conducting Research
and Development of Ways to Combat Corruption Crimes. LEX RUSSICA (Russian Law), 4, 901–916. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=59766
Abstract:
The problem of combating corruption has been always there. Knowing
quantitative and qualitative features of corruption and revealing reasons and
conditions of corruption crime that are especially relevant today development of
effective measures of deterring such crime is barely possible without conducting
scientific research and developments related specifically to criminological
evaluation of economic and other consequences of this social hazard.
As far as research methodology is concerned it is less labor-consuming
but otherwise more difficult, due political, departmental and other reasons to
address the problem of rating bribery, analysis of corruption specifics within
particular areas of organizational, economic, educational, law-enforcement and
managerial activities.
Development and implementation of various means of combating corruption
crime is barely feasible without objective scientific evaluation of the socalled
positive aspects of corrupt conduct. Of course it is unthinkable to consider
corruption as a public good. However, since this phenomenon actually exists it is
necessary to assess it in quantitative and qualitative terms from criminological
point of view, determine its reasons, and develop means of opposing it.
Comparative analysis of conditions, structure and dynamics of corruption
crime worldwide shows that unlike Russian Federation many other nations
that quite recently were known for high levels of domestic corruption crime,
have lately embarked on a steady positive trend of dealing with this sort of
crime. Russian Federation tends to draw on experience of these countries albeit
in a random, irregular way. Russian researches that are dedicated to combating
crime abroad mainly comment on respective regulations which from our Russian
point of view seem to be by far not adequate.
Lawmaking and law-enforcement practices in all ages and countries
have shown that given multiple ways and means of deterring bribery, there is no
better remedy for this disease other than harsh penal punishment of the guilty
ones.
Keywords:
korruptsiya, vzyatochnichestvo, prichina, protivodeistvie
ARCHIVE
Reference:
E.G. Moiseev. (2009). International Legal Foundations of the Middle East
Peace Settlement. LEX RUSSICA (Russian Law), 4, 917–933. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=59767
Abstract:
The Middle East conflict has continued for more than 60 years now. Israel
and Palestine, which has not moulded its sovereignty yet are parties to it.
There are several causes of the Middle East conflict. They piled up gradually
joining together. The author of the article undertakes an effort to find out the
causes of the conflict.
During the past sixty years a rare year has been peaceful for inhabitants
of this region. Unfortunately, almost every year armed conflicts broke out in the
region, sometimes they developed into bloodsheds. Tens of thousands of lives
have been destroyed, the damage is assessed in billions of dollars.
The United Nations General Assembly and the Security Council resolutions
adopted in different years form the international legal basis for the Middle
East peace settlement.
Recently the international community has been taking a great deal of effort
to settle the Middle East conflict. The four cosponsors of the Middle East
peace settlement such as the United Nations, the European Union, the Russian
Federation and the United States of America do their best in order to ensure
peace in the Middle East now and forever.
In 2009 an international conference on the Middle East is to be held in
Russia. Its results will surely be helpful for a peaceful settlement of the conflict.
Russia does not support any one party to the abovementioned conflict the way it
did back in the Soviet times. It does not look for the right and the wrong. Russia
wishes a permanent peace would be really brought about in the long-suffering
Middle East land.
The Middle East conflict has lasted over more than 60 years. A significant
number of armed conflicts, including four big wars have broken out during
this period. On the one hand, Israel, on the other – the adjacent Arab counties
and Palestine, which has not gained its sovereignty yet, are parties to this conflict.
The author of the article is trying to find out the causes of the Middle East
conflict and considering possible ways of its settlement.
A number of efforts has been taken recently to settle the Middle East
problem. The Russian Federation as a cosponsor of the Middle East Settlement
makes its contribution to this noble cause. It is planned to hold an international
conference in Moscow in the near future. Hopefully its results will help the conflicting
parties and the international community to bring forward the time for a
final settlement of the Middle East conflict.
Keywords:
blizhnevostochnoe uregulirovanie, arabskie strany, Palestina, mezhdunarodnaya konferentsiya v Moskve
ARCHIVE
Reference:
N.G. Skachkov. (2009). Features of a Mutual Insurance of the Responsibility
by Transportation Hazard Cargoes Complicated by Military Risks. LEX RUSSICA (Russian Law), 4, 934–945. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=59768
Abstract:
Economic and political instability in various regions of the world adversely
affects the safety of sea navigation, creating additional difficulties on the
whole ship route. In order to keep a cargo conserved it is necessary to join efforts
of every subject of legal relationship from shippers to employees at the
auxiliary transport terminal.
Integration of obligations is a proven approach to repayment as applied
to essential risks of one or another type. This concept represents one of the most
important traditions in the insurance practice and the method for risk repayment
tested up during long term history for scale risks of a certain kind. The contributions
to an insurance pool are considered to be either proportional to the transferred
premium value or to the established parities. Both losses and rested responsibility
are taken into account by these payments.
Undoubtedly, humanitarian crisis in its displays affects current formats
of the reinsurance. For example, if the formats of the so-called “dark blue card,”
manifesting the intentions of the insurer, really need to be changed preliminary,
it would be obligatory to establish optimum sizes of the capital investments and
then to state, who (insurer, insurant, P&I club, namely) pays the limiting shares
as a whole.
Deficit in the informational exchange obviously aggravates cardinal distinctions
between different homogeneous techniques for calculating the insurance
payments. Unambiguous losses of transport operation in any case provide a
reason for investigating casual relations with due regard for different factors.
Though, if the declared insurance cost mismatches real situation, any reinsurance
procedure hardly supposes even relative objectivity for the undertaken calculations.
Obligatory reinsurance is disputable enough. It leads to actual crushing
the tonnage at an establishment of the instant of the risk origination. Such
method allows one to overcome the loss of an individual source for the insurance
cover on retention of general priorities for a whole insurance portfolio. But it
heavily requires the clients with an adequate corporate concept of the insurance
to be available. Such contingent of clients should be created taking use of the
important reinsurance persons. Bearing in mind that the beginning of war conflict
affects the fundamental basis of the reinsurance for a hazard cargo, the predictability
of the anticipated losses must be provided as soon as possible.
Though a lot of market players continue to adhere traditional ways for creating
portfolio of insurance payments getting around of which the risks are not comprehensible.
Military risks as innovation to be included to the insurance cover do not
form the steady way of commercial activity. In this case the character of immediate
reinsurance is considered to be as alternative free. Hence, it is possible to separate some options for the insurance, objectively influencing the transportation
operation. But the order of legal regulation of the procedures for insurance
and reinsurance as well is not settled by this.
Keywords:
strakhovanie, voennye riski, sudno, perevozka, more
ARCHIVE
Reference:
M.V. Zakharova. (2009). World-View Foundations of French Legal System
Ontologization. LEX RUSSICA (Russian Law), 4, 946–958. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=59769
Abstract:
The national legal order of each state has a certain cultural-andideological
as well as civilizational base. Those are the bases to a large extent
determining the course of evolution of national legal systems as well as qualitative
direction of attractors at bifurcation points.
Axiological analysis of the said ideological foundations of modern legal
systems’ functioning is of an undeniable value both in terms of analytical-andretrospective
tasks of legal science and in terms of forecasting functions of jurisprudence.
The below paper deals with ideological bases of the French legal system
formation and institutionalization. By means of a consistent step-by-step analysis
of the course of the modern-identification-type French legal system evolution
the author draws a conclusion that the legal system in question was affected by
the following major ideological determinants:
– the “rationalistic natural right” doctrine – historically one of the first
ethical theories that had a paramount impact on understanding by the French
state power structures of the essence of law-understanding and law-formation
processes;
– “legal dogmatism” – the ethical trend that has always had and is currently
having a predominant influence on the French legal system development
over the whole history of the Continental-European legal thinking style objectivation;
– “legal mysticism” having 2 forms of practical manifestation: the natural-
right form reflected in the works by the French Enlightenment thinkers (in
particular, J.-J. Rousseau) the form of “legal fetishism;”
– sociological right theory (was manifested in practice, first of all, in the
French theory of legal instructions’ interpretation);
– “legal neo-fetishism” of a supra-national nature (start of the objectivation
period – mid-XX century).
Keywords:
Frantsiya, estestvennoe pravo, yuridicheskii dogmatizm, yuridicheskii mistitsizm, sotsiologicheskoe uchenie o prave, yuridicheskii neofetishizm
ARCHIVE
Reference:
(2009). Independence of Judges and Prosecutors: New Challenges and New
Responces: Verbatim Report of Conference (June 17, 2009, Moscow State
Law Academy). LEX RUSSICA (Russian Law), 4, 959–1013. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=59770
Abstract:
The conference was organized by Moscow State Law Academy, Embassy
France in Russia, the Supreme Court of Russia, the Supreme Arbitration Court of Russia, the Constitutional Court of Russia, and the Prosecutor General’s
Offoce of Russia.
ARCHIVE
Reference:
(2009). Interuniversity Round-table Discussion Organized by the Chair of
Criminal Procedure Law of Moscow State Law Academy. LEX RUSSICA (Russian Law), 4, 1014–1019. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=59771
Abstract:
Moscow State Law Academy traditionally inspires and organizes scientific
discussions and debates on the most topical issues of law and administration
of justice. The chair of criminal procedure law of Moscow State Law Academy
proposed a new and original form for the organization of scientific debates: an
interuniversity round-table discussion of three monographs: “Evidences and
Proving in Criminal Cases” by S.A. Shafer, “Issues of Theory of Evidences in
Criminal Proceedings” by Yu.Ê. Îrlov, and “Proving in Criminal Procedure.
Learning Package” by V.A. Lazareva.
Keywords:
obsuzhdenie voprosov naznacheniya ugolovnogo sudoproizvodstva, problemy istiny v ugolovnom sudoproizvodstve