Reference:
Khabrieva T.Y. (2014). Main Vectors and Problems of Development
of Social Legislation. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 608–615. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65587
Abstract:
The article on the guidelines for the development of social legislation of the Russian Federation predicts a rapid
and accelerated development of this block of Russian law system. Among the large-scale trends typical for social legislation
the author includes: expanding of the scope of regulation (juridification) and the corresponding expansion of legal regulations,
differentiation of social legislation on the new brunches (in particular, immigration legislation), the formation of new
sub-brunches within the existing ones (for instance, labor relations in the public service) and institutions (biotechnology and
so on).
The article discusses some "growth problems" of social legislation: the tendency of commercialization of the sphere leads to
a decrease of the quality of services, the weakening of safeguards for the most vulnerable categories of citizens (for example,
cancellation of the rules on prior consent of the guardianship authorities to carry out transactions with premises where
children live, led to a decline of living conditions of many minors of the Russian Federation). As a result the very content of
constitutional rights is expressly questioned. At the same time it is underlined that the positive aspect of social legislation
juridificationis the appearance of new obligations of the state in the social sphere.
To overcome the existing problems and to prevent new ones it is proposed to strengthen the role of science in determining
the broad guidelines of development of social legislation in the systematization of social legislation, unification of regional
legislation in the social sphere, preventing the rejection of statutory approach in the formation of the secondary legislation,
reduction of by-law regulation, strengthening the greater coherence of other branches of Russian legislation with the norms
of social legislation.
Optimization of legislative regulation through the adoption of the Federal Law "On Normative Legal Acts" will contribute to
the elimination of many defects of social legislation and greater stability of legislation of the Russian Federation in the whole.
Keywords:
social development, juridification, social legislation, public services, public relations, obligations, systematization of legislation, migration law, inter-branch legal complexes.
Reference:
Thorgeirsdottir Herdís (2014). Protection of Economic and Social Rights of Children
in Times of Financial Crisis: the Challenges. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 616–618. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65588
Abstract:
The article is devoted to the protection of economic and social rights of children in times of financial crisis: issues
and challenges in this sphere. The author underlines that proper international law mechanisms have already created among
which is the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. The Convention makes clear that children are autonomous
rights-holders which states have the duty to vindicate and protect. Article 4 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child
provides that Governments have a responsibility to take all available measures to make sure children’s rights are respected,
protected and fulfilled. Also the European Social Charter has significance importance. It complements the European Convention
on Human Rights in the field of economic and social rights and guarantees a wide range of rights relating to housing,
health, education, employment, social protection, movement of persons and non-discrimination.
The author points out that the recognition of children‘s rights has also permeated through national legal systems at various
levels.
The author emphasizes that the main threat to the protection of the children’s rights is the deepest economic crisis since the
Second World War. Governments are introducing austerity measures that scale back welfare support for families, cut funding
for basic public services, and withdraw support from the voluntary sector.
The author underlines the danger of the growing inequality, illegal exploitation of children, lack of appropriate welfare, human
traffic and insufficient efforts of state and business structures. In this regard there is a need to more serious involvement
of the international organizations including the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child, the Council of Europe
Commissioner of Human Rights, the International Labour Organisation in the protection of economic and social rights of
children.
Keywords:
Rights of children, financial crisis, international organizations, poverty, human traffic, the European Social Charter, the Venice Commission
Reference:
Busurmanov Z.D. (2014). Eurasian Economic Union as New Humanistic Value. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 619–621. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65589
Abstract:
The article deals with the protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms through the prism of Eurasian
integration. Special attention is paid to the signing of the Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union by the heads of the Russian Federation, the Republic of Belarus and the Republic of Kazakhstan, which aims, inter alia, to promote the rights of citizens of
the Eurasian Economic Union, in various fields, including the critical area of public relations – the social sphere.
It is noted that the concept of human rights should be based not only on international law and the domestic legal documents,
but also give special consideration to the mentality, culture, worldview, perception, i.e. such categories, which have human
rights no less, but sometimes even more pronounced effect than legal acts. In this regard, the author offers a science-based
Eurasian concept of human rights, the basis of which should make the Eurasian Declaration on Human Rights and Peoples'
Rights as a new international instrument in this area, extending to the Eurasian continent. In addition, the Eurasian Declaration
of Human Rights and Peoples' Rights, as suggested by the author, can be an important backbone document in the sphere
of human rights of the Eurasian Economic Union. Special attention is paid to the idea of creating of a Eurasian Court of Human
Rights, which can fully take into account the specificities and peculiarities of the states of Eurasian region, the existing
legal regulation, culture and traditions of the population. It is emphasized that the Eurasian Court of Human Rights can play
a role of the tribunal when intranational opportunities and mechanisms to eliminate facts of violation of civil rights and fundamental
freedoms and peoples in Eurasia are exhausted.
Keywords:
Republic of Kazakhstan, Eurasian integration, human rights, the Eurasian Economic Union, the concept of rights and obligations, international law, national law.
Reference:
Voronin Y.V. (2014). To the Role of Social Security in Market Economy. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 622–626. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65590
Abstract:
Within the framework of this article the attempt to correlate the economic aspects of the modern state with its
social and legal nature was made. It is concluded that the existing social liabilities – is the legal reality that Russia, as successor
to the USSR as a legal and social state is obliged to execute and further develop.
Social security is not seen as a burden, but a prerequisite for economic growth, in the spirit of international instruments in
recent years. This suggests that adequate social security is in any case not the result of economic growth, and its necessary
precondition. Legal content of social policy has long time been recorded by minimum standards of social security enshrined
in ILO Convention ¹ 102.
Following the early ratification of this Convention, for the creation of proper frame of reference of social policy Russia is going
to ratify the three other core ILO conventions in the field of social security – the Convention of 1962 ¹ 118 "On the equality
of social welfare," Convention of 1967 ¹ 128 "On the invalidity, Old-Age and Survivors'" and the Convention of 1982 ¹ 157
"On the preservation of rights in the field of social security".
Keywords:
market economy, social policy, social security, social and legal nature, social obligations, economic growth, social solidarity, social redistribution, ILO Convention, the principle of tripartism.
Reference:
Makhnik D.I., Krysenkova N.B., Tsomartova F.V. (2014). Law and Social Development: New Humanitarian
Hierarchy of Values. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 627–645. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65591
Abstract:
The IX International Practical School of Young Legal Scholars devoted to the theme “Law and Social Development:
New Humanitarian Hierarchy of Values” took place at the Institute of Legislation and Comparative Law under the Government
of the Russian Federation in May 29-30, 2014. Young scholars from more than 20 countries as well as representatives
of state authorities, international organizations, business society, different scientific and educational centers took part in the
event.
The theme of the International Practical School of Young Legal Scholars is acute because of a row of reasons, such as: necessity
of social legislation perfection, particularly, the aspects of social and economic rights protection and guaranties, cultural
and educational space development, solving of problems in the sphere of health care and sport.
The major significance of problems, brought up for discussion by young scientists approved because of participation in the
conference of such persons as: the Chairman of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation S.E.
Naryshkin, Deputy Chairman of the Government of the Russian Federation O.Y. Golodets, director of the Institute of Legislation
and Comparative Law under the Government of the Russian Federation T.Y. Khabrieva, representatives of foreign countries
and international organizations – the Vice-Chairman of the European Commissin for Democracy through Law (Venica
Commission) Herdis Thorgeirsdottir, professor of the University Paris-I Pantheon-Sorbonne Gerard Marcou and others.
Keywords:
comparative law, social legislation, law, health care, sport, cultural and educational space.
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW
Reference:
Lafitsky V.I., Troshchinsky P.V. (2014). Constitutional Way of China: to the Sixtieth Anniversary
of the PRC Constitution of 1954. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 646–657. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65592
Abstract:
The present research is devoted to the 60th anniversary of China's first Constitution (September 1954). The article
presents the characteristics of all Chinese constitutions, including the current Constitution of the PRC of 1982, and examines
the impact of domestic policies on constitutional-legal framework of the PRC. The constitutional provisions, adopted immediately
after the Xinhai Revolution of 1911, and four constitutions of formed in 1949 the People's Republic of China – in 1954, 1975, 1978 and 1982 are subjected to analysis. A special place is given to the amendments to the current Constitution of
PRC of 1982, fixing the term "socialist legal state" and raising the role of human rights institution in the life of society. Special
characteristics of the constitutional development of the PRC, which have their own "Chinese peculiarities" are pointed out,
a forecast of the constitutional development of the Chinese state in the near future is presented. Article identifies parallels
enshrined in the norms of constitutions with the teachings of the great Confucius. The authors place particular emphasis on
the influence of the teachings of Confucius in the formation of justice of Chinese lawmaker and its subsequent impact on the
rules and regulations fixed in the basic laws of China.
Keywords:
Constitution, Confucius, the legal system, legislation, the law of China, comparative law, legal state, the Cultural Revolution, Chinese peculiarities, Xinhai Revolution.
TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF PUBLIC LAW
Reference:
Vinogradova P.A. (2014). Legal Measures Aimed at Settlement
of Interethnic Conflicts. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 658–664. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65593
Abstract:
The National Security Strategy of the Russian Federation until 2020 establishes the creation of the mechanisms of
preventing and neutralization of interethnic conflicts as a priority. In the modern world activities of different national and
religious organizations based on the ethnicity concept are used as instrument of ethnic and religious tension provocation.
On the background of the revitalization of the public authorities on the preventive measures legal means of preventing interethnic
conflicts are scarcely explored in the legal literature. These circumstances determine the importance of the content
of the concept of ethnic conflict, their classification, stages and settlement. The author has generalized factors of ethnic and
religious tension and proposed measures to prevent them.
Interethnic disagreements also settled in court. New powers of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation, aimed at
maintenance of unity and sovereignty of the law enforcement practice of the national legal system, are given a special role
in the paper.
Consideration of these issues allows us to formulate the basic measures to ensure the prevention of the negative effects of
ethnic differences. The need to respect national traditions and ensuring the legitimacy of law identified as the basic principles
of legal development in the sphere of international relations.
Keywords:
relations between the nations, interethnic conflicts, state and public security, national policy, federal relations, territorial claims, illegal migration, the Constitutional Court, ECHR.
Reference:
Tagaeva S.N. (2014). Collisional-Legal Regulation of Family Liability. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 665–676. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65594
Abstract:
Article is dedicated to the collision problems of the family-legal responsibility. The analysis of existing international
agreements in that area and the national legislation of the Republic of Tajikistan are given. The article describes the main provisions
of the international conventions governing the issues of family – legal responsibility. Special attention is given to the
provisions of Kishinev Convention on Legal Assistance and Legal Relations of 2002 and compliance of the provisions of the
Family Code of the Republic of Tajikistan with it. The viewpoint that "defective relations" are the consequence of non-compliance
with the mandatory principles of domestic law by the participants of family relations is expressed. For the preparation
of the article mainly comparative legal method of research was used. Furthermore, the method of synthesis, deduction and
induction as well. The attention to the legal regulation of family -legal liability was drawn for the first time. The opinion on the
possibility of use of the term “cross-border family law liability” was suggested. A comprehensive comparative study of the
forming legal framework on the responsibilities of family members is made. The view that the possibility of use of the term
"defective relations" as penalties for failure to comply with the national law by member of family relationship is expressed.
Keywords:
collisional-legal, "defective relations", family-legal, responsibility, family members, Convention, national legislation, sanctions, regulations.
Reference:
Smirnova V.M. (2014). Legal Nature of Specification of Choreographic
Works in the Modern Russian and Foreign Copyright. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 677–683. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65595
Abstract:
Author of the article notes that the right to use the work in the system of exclusive right has a special place. Such a
method of choreographic works as its specification is considered. The most common methods of using choreographic works
include the reproduction and distribution of works, public performance, the right to broadcast and alteration of works. It is
noted that as a result of alteration of the work is a derivative of the original, which is the basis for the recognition of it as a
new subject of copyright. The same legal regime of derivative works exists in foreign countries. The author focuses his attention
to that currently the most common concept in the field of choreographic art is its revision. A combination of methods
of knowledge, the basis of which amounted to a systematic and dialectical approaches, as well as formal-legal, comparative
legal, structural and functional were used. The author concludes that the concept of "edition of choreographic works" in civil
law and in the choreography is not unique; it often has different sense and content.
The feature of specification applied to the choreographic art is the need of reference of "editorial choreographic works" to it,
in the framework of which the creation of a new object of copyright – derivative is made. It is concluded that the main role in the specification of choreographic works plays a material form of fixation of choreographic works, which allows to save and
protect them from the voluntary and involuntary specification.
Keywords:
form of use of the work, alteration of choreographic works, derivative work, specification of choreographic works, method of use, a choreographic work, the exclusive right, original work, author, intellectual property.
Reference:
Bogdan V.V. (2014). The Acts “On the Protection of Consumers’ Rights”
in Russia and Ukraine: a Comparative Legal Review. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 684–691. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65596
Abstract:
The issues of legal regulation of consumer rights protection are of current importance to any democratic state.
The transition to a market economy in the former Soviet Union republics caused an acute need for a clear legal regulation of
relations arising between consumers and business entities. Consumer legislation is intended to protect not only the rights of
a particular consumer, but also to ensure the stability of all relations at the market of goods and services. The formation of
the civil law system of consumer rights protection is a complex, multi aspect process. The present article analyzes the provisions
of consumer rights protection laws in Russia and Ukraine. The subjects of the research are legal standards regulating
the procedures of consumer rights protection, and law enforcement practice. The main attention is focused on the specifics
of the above mentioned two States laws, enshrining the rights of consumers, their implementation mechanisms, and their
common and distinctive features. The similarity of the legal systems and the same time experience in the application of the
law in practice, allow the author to draw conclusions about the possibilities and prospects of mutual borrowing of individual
legal norms.
Keywords:
consumer, protection of consumers’ rights in the Ukraine, national mechanism of consumers’ rights protection, law, comparative legal studies, consumer rights, judicial practice, entrepreneurship, balance of interests.
CONSTITUTIONAL ECONOMICS
Reference:
Kukushkin V.M. (2014). US law "Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act"
and its Impact on the Legal System of Russia. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 692–698. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65597
Abstract:
The author considers the act of the U.S. "Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act" (FATCA) and its extraterritorial effect
on the example of Russia. The main research aspects are the provisions of U.S. law, which establish requirements for foreign
financial institutions. The analysis of this law from the standpoint of the rules of national law and international law is made.
As the result of the legal analysis the conclusion that FATCA can be considered as a law that does not match the norms of
international law is made. It is noted that currently the problem of FATCA should be examined from the political, economic
and legal positions. The problem of FATCA in Russia must be resolved through the signing of international agreement, but not
by adjusting the national legislation to enable it to fulfill the American law on the territory of Russia.
Keywords:
law of the United States, Russian legislation, international law, financial institutions, tax relations, sovereignty, international Treaty.
Reference:
Basyrov R.N. (2014). Foreign Experience of Legal Securing of Completion
Works Performance by Subsoil Users. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 699–705. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65598
Abstract:
The main issue addressed herein is the lack in the legislation of the Russian Federation of effective mechanism
of legal securing of performance by subsoil users of reclamation works, abandonment of mining enterprises and different
subsoil facilities, which are offered to be merged into a single group of works – «Completion works». The author pays attention
to the fact that by the time when Completion works are to be performed, subsoil user may have been insolvent, and
by virtue of the end of subsoil use process the sanction for non-compliance in the form of early termination of the subsoil
use right becomes ineffective. The relevance of this topic is reinforced by existence of numerous waste and abandoned
subsoil, which certainly exacerbates ecological problems on the territory of Russia. All this evidences that it is necessary to
enshrine additional guarantees of such obligations performance by subsoil users in relevant legislation. Using methods of
analysis, synthesis and comparison, the author investigates into foreign experience of legal securing of compliance by subsoil
users with environmental requirements at subsoil use closing stage. This article analyzes mining legislation of the USA,
several countries in Western Europe and CIS. The article concludes that money deposit method (formation of abandonment
funds by subsoil users) has proved to be effective and is currently applied by a number of countries. Considering that such
measures place a great burden on subsoil users, the author offers to ensure, on the first stage, that licensing authorities are
familiar with subsoil users’ financial standing for the purposes of such authorities’ rapid response in case of their insolvency.
Keywords:
subsoil use, securing of performance of obligations, environmental protection, abandonment, mining enterprise, subsoil facility, reclamation, foreign experience, abandonment funds, deposit, responsibility.
THEORY AND METHODOLOGY OF COMPARATIVE LAW
Reference:
Tikhomirov Y.A. (2014). Dynamics of Legal Systems in the Integration of States. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 706–713. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65599
Abstract:
The article deals with a range of topical legal and institutional problems arising during the interstate integration.
Expanding the boundaries of comparative law allows different legal systems to enter into the orbit of research which differ
by objectives, construction and regulatory mechanisms. There are national and international legal systems, reflecting the
origins of the legal system of the national legislation and legal components which combine the strategic objectives. Their relationship resembles the "nested doll". At the intersection of different systems interstate associations arise, largely reflecting
the system of national state and legal institutions. Such features of interstate associations, as the similarity of their institutions
with the institutions of the member states of legal systems based on the aggregation of national legislation, mutual
functional "connectivity", the presence of structures and procedures for the preparation and consistent decision-making are
proved. Analysis of the experience of their development makes it possible to characterize the dynamics of their structures
and legal controls on the basis of a combination of the principle of state sovereignty and the principles of international law.
On the agenda – the recognition of the emerging integration law.
Keywords:
interstate integration, integration law, comparative law methodology, combined legal regulators, legal environment, cross-border legal communication, legal sovereignty.
Reference:
Osminin B.I. (2014). Distinctive Features of Conclusion and Implementation
of International Treaties by the Netherlands. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 714–721. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65600
Abstract:
The Netherlands is a state with a legal system that is very open to international law. All treaties that are binding on
the Netherlands as matter of international law are automatically incorporated in the domestic legal order. The Constitution
of the Netherlands establishes that acts of national legislation shall not be applicable if such application is in conflict with
provisions of treaties that are binding on all persons.
The Constitution permits the possibility of tacit approval of treaties by parliament. As an exception the treaty can be submitted
to parliament for approval once consent to be bound has been expressed. Any provisions of a treaty that conflict with the
Constitution may be approved by parliament only if at least two-thirds of the votes cast are in favour.
The most remarkable aspects of the implementation of international treaties by the Netherlands are the relatively large
possibility of direct application by the courts and executive and the supremacy of directly effective treaty provisions over
statutes and even the Constitution.
Keywords:
automatic incorporation, express approval, tacit approval, binding on all persons, direct effect, supremacy, treaty obligations, self-executing treaties, non-self-executing treaties, the supremacy of treaties.
Reference:
Kostin A.A. (2014). History of Regulation and Modern Features
of Arbitration in the Law of England and Wales. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 722–729. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65601
Abstract:
The Article attempts to cover the main stages of development and modern trends of arbitration under the law of
England and Wales. The first section of the article discusses the sources and early judgments of English courts on arbitration.
The Author emphasizes that arbitration tribunals had to counter the opposition of the state courts before the judgment Scot
v. Avery. This opposition was driven by the fact that the state courts were unwilling to tolerate the existence of alternative
dispute resolution system and by the fact that the ability of the parties to submit the dispute to arbitration seriously reduced
the court’s fees.
The second part deals with the modern trends in arbitration of England and Wales. The Author brings to attention that under
Art. 69 of the Arbitration Act 1996 arbitral award may be appealed to the Court of Appeals (unless the parties agreed otherwise).
However, such occurrence is genuinely exceptional. Besides, the second part of the Article touches upon arbitrability
of the dispute under the doctrine and case law.
The Article is concluded by a comparative analysis of Russian and English Law on arbitration.
Keywords:
international commercial arbitration, the English law, arbitration clause.
Reference:
Kurbanov R.A., Shvedkova O.V., Belyalova A.M. (2014). Analytical Review of the Work of the 99th Plenary
Session of the European Commission for Democracy
through Law (Venice Commission). Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 730–740. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65602
Abstract:
This article presents a summary of the 99th plenary session of the European Commission for Democracy through
Law (Venice Commission of the Council of Europe), which adopted a number of opinions on the legislation of the countries –
members of the Venice Commission, including the opinion on Russian Law amending the NGO Law (Law on Foreign Agents)
and the Penal Code (Act on treason and espionage). Also at the 99th plenary session was approved the study by the national
legislations on freedom of peaceful assembly, prepared under the request of the Commission by the German Institute of
Max Planck.
Keywords:
European Commission for Democracy through Law, Venice Commission, Council of Europe, 99th plenary session, the law on non-profit organizations, the law on treason and espionage, opinion, analysis of legislation.
Reference:
(2014). Na vershine prava: k 90-letiyu Veniamina Evgen'evicha Chirkina. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 741–742. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65603
Reference:
(2014). Komparativistskii vklad v razvitie prava: k 75-letiyu Uil'yamya Batlera. Journal of Foreign Legislation and Comparative Law, 4, 743–745. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=65604