TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF HISTORY OF STATE AND LAW
Reference:
Isaev, I.A. (2013). Marquis de Sade
and the revolutionary law. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1213–1222. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63208
Abstract:
The article is devoted to the study of Marquis de Sade as an eccentric political figure of the late
Enlightenment period and first years of the French Revolution. His attitude towards revolutionary legislation
and revolutionary ideas reflected political and legal positions of a specific social group — the Libertines, who
had a considerable influence on the development of legal ideology and legislation of the Revolutionary epoch.
Political and legal Ideology of skeptical aristocrats, are expressed by Marquis de Sade was almost identical
with the ideas of the Jacobins. Terror of prevailing revolution was collective, while Marquis de Sade supported
individual terrorism. Being a participant of revolutionary events, Marquis de Sade had a negative attitude towards
organizational violence, which was used by the revolutionaries. While upholding the power of passion
and enthusiasm, he had a negative attitude towards the soulless violence by the state. He considered laws and
decrees of a new political regime to be legal fictions. Legal nihilism of Marquis de Sade was expressed in his attitude
towards revolutionary law as an artificial measure, failing to meet true internal needs of human nature.
He also considered nature to be alien. The idea of nature, which may be found at the very basis for natural law,
is just as alien for a human being, as it Is machinery substituting for men in the new epoch.
Keywords:
violence, law, terror, repression, Libertines, tribunal, revolution, execution, crime, court.
TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF CONSTITUTIONAL LAW OF RUSSIA AND FOREIGN STATES
Reference:
Pibaev, I.A. (2013). Constitutional legal status of military priests
in the Russian Federation and in Italy:
history and modern tendencies. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1223–1231. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63209
Abstract:
The institutions of military priests in the Russian Federation and in Italy have a rather lengthy history.
At the same time after 70 years of atheist ideology the revival of the military priesthood has become an
object to many discussions in Russia. On one hand, the need to improve spiritual and moral values of the Russian
army is obvious, on the other hand, there is no clear concept, which would conform to the constitutional
principle of the secular state, implementation of right of people to freedom of conscience and religion in the
military forces. The study of the normative legal acts of Italy allowed to establish constitutional legal status of
chaplains and to signify the key problems, which the state and religious associations have to face.
Keywords:
jurisprudence, secular, religion, secularism, religious associations, military priest, army, freedom of conscience, freedom of religion, state.
TOPICAL PROBLEM OF FINANCIAL LAW
Reference:
Kastanova, E.D. (2013). Tax information exchange within
the framework of fighting tax evasion
in the new international context. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1232–1238. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63210
Abstract:
The article is devoted to exchange of tax information as a type of international cooperation among
the tax administrations, which has been successfully developing for decades. It has been used by foreign states
within the framework of their treaties, and it currently becomes more popular in the Russian Federation. The
author discusses all the types of information exchange, as well as benefits of each of these types. Additionally,
the author provides detailed efficiency analysis for this method of international cooperation for the purpose
of fighting international tax evasion. The article includes detailed analysis of banking secrecy, history of its
formation and the measures taken by the international organizations against this negative phenomenon, as
well as results of transparency improvement. The article gets the reader acquainted with the normative legal
basis for the tax information exchange, as well as with the principles of its implementation, without which the
information exchange would be Impossible. The article Includes description of successful experience of foreign
tax bodies in the sphere of tax information exchange, and it also discusses the position of the Russian Federation
on this issue, the author makes propositions for making this type of administrative aid more efficient,
which would improve the input into the budget.
Keywords:
jurisprudence, treaty, tax, evasion, banking secret, information, exchange, administration, taxpayer.
TOPICAL PROBLEM OF FINANCIAL LAW
Reference:
Solovova, E.V. (2013). Some aspects of securitized form
of public loans in the USA. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1239–1245. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63211
Abstract:
This article includes analysis of some types of state and municipal securities, which are issued In the
USA in order to finance the budget deficit, as well as some social and economic programs. The author also discusses
some issues regarding the public debt in the American theory. Analysis of types of the above-mentioned
financial instruments, being issued by the federal government, states, municipalities and non-governmental
organizations supported by federal government has a special value within the context of evaluation of the
public loans institution in the American practice, since the securitized form of public legal obligations is currently
dominant in the USA. Additionally, studies of the main parameters and characteristic features of such
financial instruments, taking a foreign state as an example, can serve as a basis for the further analysis of
the Russian theory and practice of use of state and municipal securities as a mechanism for the attraction of
loaned funds by the public bodies of various levels, as well as for the improvement of the Russian public loans
market.
Keywords:
state/municipal debt, state/municipal credit, securitization, state securities, municipal securities, issuing securities, debt instruments, percent, discount, financing of spendings, public debt, credit.
TOPICAL PROBLEM OF FINANCIAL LAW
Reference:
Mirzoeva, A.G. (2013). Legal value of correctly defining
the taxation object and tax object
as key legal elements of tax in tax legislation:
theoretical and practical problems. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1246–1253. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63212
Abstract:
The article is devoted to the analysis of one of the key legal elements of taxes: object of taxation,
which is closely related to the tax object. However, the Art. 12.3 of the Tax Code of the Republic of Azerbaijan
they are recognized as equal terms. Under this norm, it turns out that object of taxation and tax object are the
same. This legislative ambiguity has already caused and may still cause various judicial disputes. The article
includes examples of judicial cases, where the object of dispute was related to lack of clarity in defining tax
object and taxation object. It should be noted that taxation object expresses the legal link between the tax
object and taxpayer. And the connection of a taxpayer to an object is a legal fact. Therefore, these two terms
are different. The taxation object as a legal fact appears due to the presence of certain objects (material and
immaterial benefits). It is offered to amend the legislation of the Republic of Azerbaijan to change the contents
of terms tax object and tax subject taking into account the opinions of the author, since these are not identical
terms, rather they are independent elements of tax.
Keywords:
jurisprudence, problems, tax, element, object, subject, income, dividend, taxpayer, obligation.
TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF CIVIL LAW
Reference:
Nozhkina, A.A. (2013). Insuring professional liability within
the system of existing types of taxation. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1254–1263. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63213
Abstract:
In this article the author analyzes the Issue of legal qualification of contract for insurance of professional
liability within the system of types of insurance, as provided for by legislation, including contractual
liability and liability for causing harm. The author provides qualification of various types of professional liability
insurance, including those of tour operators, advocates, notaries, insolvency managers, appraisers and
auditors.
Keywords:
jurisprudence, insurance, professional liability, contractual liability, delict-based liability, appraiser, auditor, tour operator, notary, insolvency manager.
TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF ENTERPRENEURIAL LAW
Reference:
Yakovleva, I.A. (2013). Some problems of defining
a banking secrecy object
for entrepreneurial activities. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1264–1270. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63214
Abstract:
The article contains analysis of key theoretical and practical problems regarding recognition of banking
secrecyñó as a specific type of secrecy, lawfulness of its application towards information on clients and
their dealings, as well as to the temporal period for keeping secrecy. The author offers a definition of banking
secrecy, which corresponds to the modern legislative tendencies and judicial practice, providing for wider
scope of access to confidential information, at the same time applying the secrecy regime to all of the information
of the client of a credit organization. The broader approach to banking secrecy, which does not provide
limitations as to the types of information on a client, therefore allowing for various client-related information,
better correspond to the current reality. The banking secrecy is understood as a specific legal regime for a
limited access to information, introduced towards any information directly regarding a client, including information
of the main activities for which the accounts are being used, as well as banking operations and deals,
which is obtained during the core activities of a credit organization, a Bank of Russia, organization ensuring
bank accounts.
Keywords:
constitutional access guarantees, lawfulness, evaluation, regime of access, client information, confidential information, banking secrecy, term, list of data, format of request, character of the information.
TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF CRIMINAL LAW
Reference:
Esakov, G.A. (2013). Customary international law
as a source for criminal law prohibitions. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1271–1276. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63215
Abstract:
The article is devoted to customary international law as a source of Russian criminal law. The author
analyzes the issue of whether the norms of international customary law may be used as crime-forming elements
in the crime of use of prohibited means and methods of waging war. Based upon the study of history
of the issue and international practice («the Martens clause», practice of international tribunals, norms of
international humanitarian law, practice of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation and the European
Court of Human Rights) the author formulates the criteria for such use. In the opinion of the author, it
is acceptable to establish contents of criminal legal prohibition via the norms of international customary law,
which are included into the sphere of conventionally prohibited behavior through the «Martens clause», on
a condition that the obvious unlawfulness of the behavior was understood by a person at the moment when
the crime was being committed. At the same time it shall inevitably be decided ad hoc, and the national courts
shall have to face complicated issues of establishing the contents of norms of international customary law.
Keywords:
customary international law, elements of crime, crime, source of criminal law, act, disposition, foresight of criminal nature of behavior, international treaty, criminal law, lawfulness principle.
TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF CRIMINAL LAW
Reference:
Veliev, F.Z. (2013). The motive of hatred or enmity
in criminal legislation of Russia. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1277–1282. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63216
Abstract:
The motive of hatred or enmity is used in several meanings. Hovewer, neither the Criminal Code (both
the of the Russian Federation, and of the RSFSR), nor the Decrees of the Plenum of the Supreme Court N. 11 of
June 28, 2011 «On judicial practice on extremist crimes» provide for its contents. The article contains evaluation
of the terms «behavior motive», «crime motive», «incentive», «interest». The author pays special attention
to the motive of national (ethnical), racial, or religious hatred and enmity (discord). The author analyzes
some specific issues regarding qualification of crimes committed due to the motives of racial, national, or religious
hatred or enmity. He concludes that these motives should not be united with other motives, and should
be recognized as Independent qualifying elements in specific crimes (as it is provided for in international law
and in legislation of most foreign states). Additionally, he sustains that the proposition to exclude these motives
from the list of aggravating circumstances is untimely.
Keywords:
criminal legislation, behavior motive, crime motive, criminal legal value of motive, extremist crime, enticement, hatred, enmity, discord, qualification of crimes.
TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF CRIMINAL LAW
Reference:
Filatova, M.A. (2013). Target of crime, as provided for by
Art. 174, 1741 of the Criminal Code
of the Russian Federation. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1283–1290. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63217
Abstract:
The article contains analysis of the term «target of crime» within the context of the «laundering»
money and other criminally obtained valuables under Art. 174 and 174.1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian
Federation taking into account the new version of the criminal law of 2013. The author evaluates scholarly
opinions and judicial practice as to interpretation of this term. She studies the term «property» in its correlation
with its meaning in civil law, as well as other civil rights objects, as objects of «laundering». The author
also analyzes various points of view as to the amendments into the legislatively provided «laundering» target
definition, taking into account international provisions and foreign scholarly writings. The author offers to
regard target of this crime as property, works, services, and copyright. However, due to the complicated legal
construction of these articles, it is preferable to include into them the reference to «proprietary values» and
add a commentary to Art. 174 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.
Keywords:
laundering, legalization, target of crime, property, proprietary values, copyright, petty daily transactions, works (services), monetary funds, securities.
TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF CRIMINAL LAW
Reference:
Petrova, I.A. (2013). On the issue of definition
of “malicious evasion from alimony
payment for children”. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1291–1297. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63218
Abstract:
The article deals with the topical issues regarding difficulties appearing in legal practice of investigating
crimes of malicious evasion from alimony payment for children in accordance with a court decision. Based
upon analysis of specific court cases on Art. 157 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, the author
attempts to generalize the judicial practice in order to develop a unified approach towards the definition of
"malicious evasion from alimony payment for children". The article provides arguments in favor of amending
the criminal and family legislation.
Keywords:
jurisprudence, crime, evasion, malicious, alimony, money for sustenance, underage children, criminal law, responsibility, judicial practice.
TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF CRIMINAL PROCESS
Reference:
Kozubenko, Y.V. (2013). On the issue of bilateral coordination
of procedural and material discipline-specific
constructions within the mechanism
of criminal law regulation. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1298–1309. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63219
Abstract:
The article includes analysis of coordination of procedural and legal discipline-specific law constructions
within the inter-disciplinary legal construction of the mechanism of criminal law regulation. The author
provides detailed analysis of influence of criminal procedural law upon the criminal process and material
criminal law, such as subsidiary application of criminal procedural legal norms to some categories and terms
of material criminal law. Interpretation of elements of crime In procedural acts require corrections in the material
law, thus the criminal procedural law initiates the amendments into the Criminal Code of the Russian
Federation. Refusal to include into criminal law the crimes based on administrative prejudicial effect is due to
the issues of proof. Application of criminal procedural law when using retroactive force of laws, belonging to
other (non-criminal) legal disciplines, presupposes the possibility to apply the criminal material legal constructions.
The criminal legal constructions, as formed by the judicial practice, presuppose the possible application
of material criminal law. Non-application of criminal law may be due to the procedural inexpediency. Legal
practice requires that the norms of criminal law would be in accord with the criminal procedural law, and the
criminal procedural law provides for the grounds for avoiding criminal punishment, which are not recognized
in criminal law itself.
Keywords:
jurisprudence, mechanism of criminal law regulation, interrelation between material and procedural criminal law, Inter-disciplinary legal construction, bilateral coordination of legal construction, subsidiary application, forgiving a debt, safety mechanism, controlled delivery, administrative prejudicial effect.
TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF FORENSIC SCIENCES AND JUDICIAL EXPERTISE
Reference:
Rossinskaya, E.R., Galyashina, E.I. (2013). On the issue of form and contents
of expert opinion for anti-corruption expertise
of normative legal acts and their drafts. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1310–1315. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63220
Abstract:
In this article the authors discuss nature of normative legal text, provide the definition of anticorruption
expertise of normative legal acts, define object, target, goals and aims of this expertise, as well
as forms and contents of expert opinion for anti-corruption expertise through the prism of general theory
of judicial expertise as a methodological basis for any expert activity. The authors analyze requirements
to competence of experts, structure of an opinion in general and contents of its main constituent parts:
introduction, research, synthesis, and conclusions. It is noted that the legislative provisions for typical corruptogenic
factors provides for two directions for anti-corruption expert evaluation. These directions are
uncovering and providing basis for typical corruptogenic factors as provided for in a general method. Based
upon the above-mentioned matters, the authors express their opinion on the means for solving legal, scientific,
methodological and organizational problems of anti-corruption expertise of normative legal acts and
legislative drafts.
Keywords:
corruption, corruptogenic factor, method, anti-corruption expertise, normative legal acts, draft of a normative legal act, normative legal text, legal expertise, legal linguistic expertise, expert opinion.
TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF FORENSIC SCIENCES AND JUDICIAL EXPERTISE
Reference:
Podvolotskiy, I.N. (2013). Interaction between judicial experts
and participants of procedural activities,
when holding portrait expertise. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1316–1321. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63221
Abstract:
Efficiency of the judicial system of a state depends upon the coordination of the activities of all of
the participants of the process. The key element of the interaction may be recognized as the activities of the
party initiating a judicial expertise and of a judicial expert. The basis for their interaction is the presence of
the complex of special knowledge, allowing them to evaluate the results of each other’s work. The lack of due
understanding of the abilities of a specific expert to resolve the problems relevant for proving the case leads
to the need to take additional procedural actions, such as interrogation of an expert or assigning an additional
expertise. This, in turn, has a negative impact upon the length of the judicial procedures on the case. Solution
of this problem may be found in closer cooperation between the experts (specialists) and initiators of an
expertise, holding preliminary consultations during which one may clarify the goals of the parties, the type of
the expertise, competence of an expert, the list of objects for expertise, information related to assigning this
expertise, and the prospective use of its results.
Keywords:
portrait expertise, habitoscopy, special knowledge, forensic studies, interaction, expert opinion, consultation of a specialist, video image, type of expert, object, studies.
TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF ORGANIZATION OF LAW ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITIES
Reference:
Romanova, I. (2013). Legal consequences
of disclosure of corruptogenic factors
in normative legal acts and their drafts by
the prosecution bodies. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1322–1326. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63222
Abstract:
The article is devoted to the study of legal consequences of the requests by the prosecutors to amend
a normative legal act based upon the results of anti-corruption expertise. The author discusses topical issues
regarding the period for the consideration of the requirements by the law-making bodies, options for challenging
the requirements and cases when protest of a prosecutor was filed instead. The author views the
cases when the prosecutors sent information on the corruptogenic factors, which they have found. It is due
to the fact, that the information acts should be filed when corruptogenic factors are uncovered in legal acts
formally falling outside the scope of prosecutor control under the Federal Law «On Anti-Corruption expertise
of Normative Legal Acts and Drafts of Normative Legal Acts» (such as legislative drafts, non-normative legal
acts). If, while holding anti-corruption expertise, a law (or a legal norm) is found to be in contradiction with
the federal law, the protest of prosecutor is used. Special attention is paid to the legislative provisions for the
prosecutors to require amendments into normative legal acts in court; the author offers possible solutions for
the problems.
Keywords:
anti-corruption expertise, prosecution, requirement to amend, protest, challenging decisions, normative legal act, fighting corruption, corruptogenic factor, information, petition by a prosecutor.
TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF INTERNATIONAL LAW
Reference:
Busol, K.I. (2013). Compliance of the US actions on protection
of cultural property during the Iraq War
in 2003-2011 to international law
and national law of the USA. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1327–1333. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63223
Abstract:
Novel different nature of modern armed conflicts sets new goals for the international law, including
the sphere of international legal protection of cultural property. The article includes analysis of whether
the coalition for the protection of Iraqi cultural property acted in compliance or not in compliance with the
modern international law in 2003-2011. The author used comparative legal, historical, inductive and deductive
methods in her work. The first part of the article is devoted to the obligations of the parties under the
relevant treaties and customary international law. The author establishes the arguments according to which
non-ratification of the Hague Convention For the Protection of Cultural Property of 1954 does not diminish the
obligations to protect the cultural property of Iraq due to the norms of customary international humanitarian
law. The second part of the article includes analysis of efficiency of the national legal measures adopted by the
USA In order to fight consequences of marauding in Iraq. The author evaluates a number of national American
acts, such as General Order A1, Republic of Iraq Antiquities Law, Implementation of the Convention For the
Protection of Cultural Property Act. It is established that while a number of measures, such as import limitation
corresponded to the critical situation regarding Iraqi artifacts, such measures were either taken too late, or were not sufficient due to non-ratification by the USA of some key provisions of international legal instruments
for the protection of cultural objects.
Keywords:
jurisprudence, cultural property, international law, the Hague Convention of 1954, Iraq, USA, import limitations, marauding, art, museum.
TOPICAL PROBLEMS OF INTERNATIONAL LAW
Reference:
Kozheurov, Y.S. (2013). International responsibility for
the violations of the WTO law:
correlation with the common
international law. Actual problems of Russian law, 10, 1334–1340. https://en.nbpublish.com/library_read_article.php?id=63224
Abstract:
The article contains analysis of the issues of correlation of the World Trade Organization (WTO) law
with the common International law within the framework of international responsibility law. The author supports
a point of view that norms of international common law on responsibility of the states, as codified by the
International Law Commission of the UN in the Articles on State Responsibility for Internationally Wrongful
Acts of 2001, are applicable to the relationships within the WTO framework. The WTO law, being an autonomous
legal regime within the general framework of international law, contains a number of special rules and
procedures regulating contents and implementation of responsibility for violation of the obligations in the
WTO. However, in all cases when the WTO law provides otherwise, the general principles of international law
should apply. Moreover, these principles are used to interpret and define the contents of special rules and
procedures in the WTO law, such as counter-measures.
Keywords:
common international law, international responsibility, the WTO law, fragmenting international law, counter-measures, restitution, compensation, proportionality, autonomous regimes, lex specialis.