Ðóñ Eng During last 365 days Approved articles: 2065,   Articles in work: 293 Declined articles: 786 

O. S. Berezkina The classification of political regimes: the historiography of the question

Published in journal "History magazine: researches", 2014-2 in rubric "Interdisciplinary research", pages 143-156.

Resume: The article addresses the named topic, which is much discussed in modern historical and political sciences. The aim is to review the formation and development of political regime typologies, exposing the factors that had a definitive influence on this process. The article contains a critical analysis of the existing classifications, showing their strong and weak points. Special attention is given to the inadequacy of the identification of the Soviet system within the framework of totalitarian and authoritarian paradigms, pointing out the factors that prevent its objective assessment. Comparing the changing interpretations and recognizing the limitations imposed by the discourse should contribute to the elaboration of more exact perceptions of history progressions and of political processes in the modern world. The historical approach is applied to the works of politologists: the topic is considered through its development in time, taking into account the changes in the objective historical settings and in the concepts of the researchers. It is noted that the systematic development of political regime typologies began after World War II and was based on the dichotomy “democracy – totalitarianism”. Thereafter significant effort has been devoted to the development of the concept of “authoritarianism”, to the adjustment of the definition of Soviet-type regimes and of liberal-democratic systems. Contemporary historiography retains the triad “totalitarianism – authoritarianism – democracy”, however, there exist some significant researches by scholars, who go beyond the dominant discourse. The acceptance of the democratic characteristics of the Soviet-like systems and describing them as “totalitarian democracy” will allow for the development of more adequate classifications, taking into account alternative variants in political modernization.

Keywords: political regime, classification of regimes, history, liberal democracy, totalitarianism, totalitarian democracy, authoritarian regime, democratization, political modernization, discourse.

DOI: 10.7256/2222-1972.2014.2.12428

This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article

Borkenau F. The Totalitarian Enemy. L., 1939.
Authoritarian Politics in Modern Society. The Dynamics of Established One-Party Systems / Ed. by Samuel H. Hantington and Clement H. Moore. N. Y., 1970.
Apter D. The Politics of Modernization. Chicago, 1966.
Khayek F. Doroga k rabstvu. M., 1992.
Endreyn Ch. Sravnitel'nyy analiz politicheskikh sistem. M., 2000.
Almond G. A. Comparative Political Systems // Journal of Politics. 1956. ¹ 3.
Chernev A. D. 229 kremlevskikh vozhdey. Politbyuro, Orgbyuro, Sekretariat TsK kommunisticheskoy partii v litsakh i tsifrakh. M., 1996.
Tsygankov A. P. Sovremennye politicheskie rezhimy: struktura, tipologiya, dinamika. M., 1995.
Fashizm i antidemokraticheskie rezhimy v Evrope. M., 1981.
Totalitarizm v Evrope KhKh v. Iz istorii ideologiy, dvizheniy, rezhimov i ikh preodoleniya. M., 1996.
Popper K. Otkrytoe obshchestvo i ego vragi. M., 1992.
Radaev V. V., Shkaratan O. I. Sotsial'naya stratifikatsiya. M., 1996.
Pugachev V. P., Solov'ev A. I. Vvedenie v politologiyu. M., 2003.
Politologiya / Pod red. M. A. Vasilika. M., 1999.
Plattner M. Ot liberalizma k liberal'noy demokratii // Apologiya. 2005. ¹ 1.
O’Donnell G. Delegativnaya demokratiya // Predely vlasti. 1994. ¹ 2–3.
Nikitaev V. Povestka dnya dlya Rossii: vlast', politika, demokratiya // Logos. 2004. ¹ 2.
Leypkhart A. Demokratiya v mnogosostavnykh obshchestvakh. Sravnitel'noe issledovanie. M., 1997.
Korzhikhina T. P., Figatner Yu. Yu. Sovetskaya nomenklatura: stanovlenie, mekhanizmy deystviya // Voprosy istorii. 1993. ¹ 7.
Zakariya F. Budushchee svobody: neliberal'naya demokratiya v SShA i za ikh predelami. M., 2004.
Zakariya F. Neliberal'naya demokratiya pyat' let spustya: sud'ba demokratii v dvadtsat' pervom veke // Logos. 2004. ¹ 2.
Dogan M., Pelassi D. Sravnitel'naya politicheskaya sotsiologiya. M., 1994.
Zakariya F. Vozniknovenie neliberal'nykh demokratiy // Logos. 2004. ¹ 2.
Dal' R. Poliarkhiya: uchastie i oppozitsiya. M., 2010.
Gromyko A. L. Politicheskie rezhimy: sushchnost', istoricheskie formy i real'naya praktika. M., 2003.
Voskresenskiy A. D. Politicheskie sistemy i modeli demokratii na Vostoke. M., 2007.
Golosov G. V. Sravnitel'naya politologiya. Novosibirsk, 1995.
Vert N. Istoriya Sovetskogo gosudarstva. 1900–1991. M., 1997.
Berezkina O. S. Politicheskiy rezhim v SSSR: osnovnye kharakteristiki // Ot Drevney Rusi k Rossiyskoy Federatsii: istoriya rossiyskoy gosudarstvennosti. Materialy mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii. Moskva, MGU imeni M. V. Lomonosova, 28-29 sentyabrya 2012 g. SPb., 2013.
Berezkina O. S. Politicheskie elity: chto i kak my izuchaem? M., 2003.
Beneton F. Vvedenie v politicheskuyu nauku. M., 2002.
Aron R. Demokratiya i totalitarizm. M., 1993.
Arendt Kh. Istoki totalitarizma. M., 1996.
Almond G., Pauell Dzh., Strom K., Dalton R. Sravnitel'naya politologiya segodnya. Mirovoy obzor. M., 2002.
Elites and Political Power in the USSR / Ed. by D. Lane. Cambridge, 1988.
Friedrich C., Brzezinski Z. Totalitarian Dictatorship and Autocracy. Cambridge, 1956.
Lasswell G., Kaplan A. Power and Society. A Framework for Political Inquiry. New Haven, 1957.
Linz J. Totalitarian and Authoritarian Regimes. Boulder, CO, 2000.
Neumann S. Permanent Revolution. Totalitarism in the Age of International Civil War. N.Y., 1965.
Political Leadership in the Soviet Union / Ed. by A. Brown. L., 1989.
Sartory G. Parties and Party System: A Framework for Analysis. Cambridge University Press, 1976.
Skilling H. G., Griffits F. Interest Groups and Communist Politics. Princeton, 1971.
Talmon J. L. The Origins of Totalitarian Democracy. L., 1952.

Correct link to this article:
just copy this link to clipboard